Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

KCFSI as a Stock Market Return Predictor

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Economic Indicators

Key Insight

KCFSI monthly changes show no predictive power for S&P 500 returns (R-squared 0.000 next-month; Feb 1990–Mar 2021), with stock market returns leading KCFSI changes by one month rather than vice versa.

A subscriber suggested the Kansas City Financial Stress Index (KCFSI) as a potential U.S. stock market return predictor. This index “is a monthly measure of stress in the U.S. financial system based on 11 financial market variables. A positive value indicates that financial stress is above the long-run average, while a negative value signifies that financial stress is below the long-run average. Another useful way to assess the current level of financial stress is to compare the index to its value during past, widely recognized episodes of financial stress.” The paper “Financial Stress: What Is It, How Can It Be Measured, and Why Does It Matter?” describes the 11 financial inputs for KCFSI and its methodology, which involves monthly demeaning of inputs, monthly normalization of the overall indicator to have historical standard deviation one and principal component analysis. This process changes past values in the series, perhaps even changing their signs. Is KCFSI useful for U.S. stock market investors? To investigate, we relate monthly S&P 500 Index returns to monthly values of, and changes in, KCFSI. We match return calculation intervals to KCFSI release dates. Using monthly data for KCFSI and the S&P 500 Index during February 1990 (limited by KCFSI) through March 2021, we find that:

The following chart tracks monthly levels of the S&P 500 Index and KCFSI over the available sample period. Visual inspection suggests a negative relationship between the two series, accentuated when KCFSI spikes, but it is not obvious whether one series leads the other.

As noted, cumulative effects of monthly demeanings/renormalizations can be large, undermining use of the KCFSI series for backtesting. However, they should have little effects on past monthly changes in KCFSI, so we focus on relating monthly changes in KCFSI to future monthly stock market returns.

SP500 KCFSI

The following scatter plot relates S&P 500 Index next-month return to monthly change in KCFSI over the available sample period. The Pearson correlation for the two series is 0.00 and the R-squared statistic accordingly 0.000, indicating that change in KCFSI explains none of the variation in next-month stock market returns. R-squared between S&P 500 Index next-month return and monthly change in KCFSI is 0.028 (0.005) over the first (second) half of the sample, with break point August 2005.

Results do not support belief that monthly change in KCFSI predicts stock market return. However, in case there is a useful non-linearity, we look at ranges of monthly changes in KCFSI.

SP500 next month return vs monthly change in KCFSI

The next chart shows average next-month S&P 500 Index returns across ranked fifths (quintiles) of monthly changes in KCFSI over the full sample period (74-75 observations per quintile). Notable points are:

  • Overall, increases in KCFSI (financial stress) may be better for stocks than decreases. However, average returns do not not vary systematically across quintiles.
  • Variability of quintile returns is highest in extreme quintiles.
  • Average next-month S&P 500 Index return when stress decreases (increases) is 0.57% (0.89%).
  • Average next-month S&P 500 Index return for the 10 biggest drops (jumps) in KCFSI is 0.72% (1.55%).

Findings are conflicting and sometimes counter-intuitive.

Might KCFSI be a better predictor at horizons longer than one month?

average SP500 next month return by quintile of monthly change in KCFSI

The final chart summarizes correlations for various lead-lag relationships between monthly change in KCFSI and monthly S&P 500 Index return over the full sample period, ranging from stock market return leads monthly change in KCFSI by 12 months (-12) to monthly change in KCFSI leads stock market return by 12 months (12). Results indicate that:

  • Stock market return leads change in KCFSI by one month strongly and negatively. In other words, a strong (weak) stock market return predicts a decrease (increase) in KCFSI next month.
  • All other lead-lag relationships are weak and appear to be noise.

SP500 monthly return vs monthly change in KCFSI leadlag

In summary, evidence from simple tests on available data offers little support for belief that KCFSI is a useful predictor of U.S. stock market returns.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • The sample is small in terms of number of economic cycles and bull/bear markets, such that (as suggested by the first chart) peculiarities of the 2008-2009 financial crisis and market crash may dominate findings.
  • Analyses are in-sample. An investor operating in real time may draw different conclusions at different points during the sample period.
  • As noted, monthly demeanings/renormalizations of KCFSI and its inputs alter past values and undermines its direct use for backtesting.
  • KCFSI did not exist during most of the sample period (data are backfilled), raising suspicion of data snooping bias regarding pre-2009 data. Also, there is no feedback from the market before its publication in 2009.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Kansas City Financial Stress Index (KCFSI)?

The Kansas City Financial Stress Index (KCFSI) is a monthly measure of stress in the U.S. financial system based on 11 financial market variables. A positive value indicates financial stress above the long-run average, while a negative value indicates stress below the long-run average. It can also be compared with its values during past, widely recognized episodes of financial stress.

Does the Kansas City Financial Stress Index predict stock market returns?

The KCFSI does not predict S&P 500 Index returns in simple tests over February 1990 through March 2021. The correlation between monthly change in KCFSI and next-month S&P 500 return is 0.00, with an R-squared of 0.000. Instead, stock market returns lead KCFSI changes by one month, with a strong negative relationship, and other lead-lag relationships out to 12 months appear to be noise.

How is the Kansas City Financial Stress Index calculated?

The KCFSI is built from 11 financial market variables using monthly demeaning of the inputs, principal component analysis, and monthly normalization of the overall indicator to a historical standard deviation of one. This process changes past values in the series, perhaps even flipping their signs. Because of this, the analysis relates monthly changes in KCFSI, rather than levels, to S&P 500 returns, with return intervals matched to KCFSI release dates.

Do rising financial stress levels mean lower stock returns afterward?

Rising financial stress, as measured by KCFSI, does not reliably imply lower subsequent stock returns. Average next-month S&P 500 return is 0.89% after stress increases versus 0.57% after decreases, and 1.55% after the 10 biggest KCFSI jumps versus 0.72% after the 10 biggest drops. Average returns do not vary systematically across quintiles of KCFSI change, so findings are conflicting and sometimes counter-intuitive.

What are the limitations of using the KCFSI to forecast stock market returns?

The KCFSI has several limitations as a stock return predictor. The sample covers few economic cycles and bull/bear markets, so the 2008-2009 financial crisis may dominate findings, and the analyses are in-sample. Monthly demeaning and renormalization alter past values, undermining backtesting, and most of the data are backfilled because KCFSI was not published until 2009, raising data snooping concerns for pre-2009 results.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›