Objective research to aid investing decisions

Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)

Allocations for December 2024 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY

Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)

Allocations for December 2024 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Momentum Investing in a Nutshell?

| | Posted in: Momentum Investing

How, in a nutshell, do momentum investing strategies work? In his December 2017 paper entitled “Keep Up the Momentum”, Thierry Roncalli summarizes the nature of the momentum premium in a less mathematical way than in the previously available “Understanding the Momentum Risk Premium: An In-Depth Journey Through Trend-Following Strategies”. He distinguishes between:

  • Time-series or trend-following or intrinsic or absolute momentum (long assets with a positive past trend and short assets with a negative past trend).
  • Cross-sectional or relative or winners-minus-losers momentum (long assets that have outperformed and short assets that have underperformed relative to each other).

Based on mathematical derivations and prior research, he concludes that:

  • Momentum strategy performance depends on:
    1. Absolute value of asset Sharpe ratios.
    2. Pairwise correlations between asset returns.
    3. The length of the interval used to calculate momentum.
  • Intrinsic momentum works best when pairwise asset correlations are zero, and hence makes sense for multi-class assets.
  • Relative momentum works best with highly correlated assets, and hence works best for similar assets (such as regional stocks).
  • Short-term momentum is riskier, has a lower Sharpe ratio and is more sensitive to the type of moving average employed than long-term momentum.
  • In the long run, intrinsic momentum has low correlation with traditional asset classes due to averaging of high beta during bull markets and low beta during bear markets.
  • Too much leverage can be harmful to momentum portfolios.
  • One way to view intrinsic momentum (and perhaps long-only relative momentum) is as a beta strategy during good times and a diversification strategy during bad times.

In summary, theoretical analysis indicates that long-short intrinsic momentum applies best to asset classes and long-short relative momentum applies best to similar assets.

Note that long-only relative momentum may be more like intrinsic momentum than relative (winners-minus-losers) momentum.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • Findings derive from a simple model of momentum summarized in “Momentum Risk Premium Theory”. As noted there, this model is imperfect.
  • As also noted there, findings do not account for implementation frictions/barriers, including:
    • Using indexes as assets ignores implementation costs/fees of creating liquid funds that track the indexes. These costs/fees may vary considerably across asset classes.
    • Monthly portfolio turnover may be high, generating additional material costs.
    • Shorting may in some cases be costly/infeasible due to lack of assets to borrow for shorting. Using futures rather than underlying assets eliminates this concern, but momentum may work differently for futures versus underlying assets.
  • The author does not address long-only momentum strategy variations.
Login
Daily Email Updates
Filter Research
  • Research Categories (select one or more)