What do basic U.S. stock market return statistics say about consistency of equity risks and predictability of returns? We define basic statistics as first through fourth moments of the return distribution: mean (average), standard deviation, skewness and kurtosis. For tractability, we calculate these four statistics month-by-month based on daily returns. Using daily closes of the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) since January 1930 and the S&P 500 Index since January 1950, both through September 2018, we find that:
The following chart summarizes averages of mean daily returns by month for the U.S. stock market over full sample periods and decade-by-decade (with 2010s partial). It shows that the investing environment varies based on average return, with the 1950s, 1980s, 1990s and 2010s standing out as “easy” decades and the 1930s, 1970s and especially the 2000s standing out as “hard” decades. In other words, reward from passively investing in equities varies considerably over fairly long subperiods.

The next chart summarizes averages of standard deviation of daily returns by month for the U.S. stock market over full sample periods and decade-by-decade (with 2010s again partial). It shows that the investing environment varies also based on return volatility, with the 1950s and the 1960s being “calm” decades and the 1930s and the 2000s standing out as “jumpy” decades. The 2010s so far are about typical. In other words, risk measured by return volatility varies over fairly long subperiods.

The next chart summarizes average skewness of daily returns by month for the U.S. stock market over full sample periods and decade-by-decade (with 2010s again partial). It shows that the investing environment also varies considerably based on this measure of distribution asymmetry, with the 1940s and 1950s notable for negative skewness (long left tail) and the 1970s notable for positive skewness (long right tail). The 2010s so far are mixed. In other words, skewness risk varies considerably over fairly long subperiods.

The next chart summarizes average kurtosis of daily returns by month for the U.S. stock market over full sample periods and decade-by-decade (with 2010s again partial). It shows that the investing environment varies also based on this measure of return distribution fat-tailedness, with the 1940s, 1950s, 1980s and 2010s standing out as “fat-tailed” and the 1960s and 1970s standing out as “normal” decades. in other words, kurtosis risk varies over fairly long subperiods.
Do the statistics of monthly stock market return distributions predict next-month returns?

The next chart summarizes correlations between DJIA and S&P 500 Index monthly returns and the above four statistics for daily returns for the preceding month since the 1950s. Correlations are small, suggesting that daily return statistics for a given month have little or no power to predict next-month stock market behavior. The strongest, but still weak, indication is a negative relationship between return volatility (standard deviation) last month and return next month.
Are these relationships stable over time?

The final two charts summarize correlations between DJIA monthly returns (upper chart) and S&P 500 Index monthly returns (lower chart) and the above four statistics for daily returns for the preceding month by decade since the 1930s and 1950s, respectively (with 2010s again partial). Relationships between last month’s daily return statistics and this month’s return are generally not stable across decades.


In summary, evidence from simple statistics suggests that investors should not count on the long-run stability of the equity investing environment or on the reliability of relationships between past return statistics and future returns.
By extension, investors may want to demand a fairly high level of proof that more specialized stock return indicators offer reliable predictive power.
Cautions regarding findings include:
- The sample for the 2010s could still change as new data become available.
- Other ways of measuring the four moments of equity index returns (for example, measuring by year rather than by month) may produce different results.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the four moments of a stock return distribution?
The four moments of a stock return distribution are the mean (average return), standard deviation (volatility), skewness (asymmetry of returns) and kurtosis (fat-tailedness). In the article, each is calculated month-by-month from daily returns of the Dow Jones Industrial Average (since January 1930) and the S&P 500 Index (since January 1950), both through September 2018.
Can last month's stock market return statistics predict next month's returns?
Last month's daily return statistics (mean, standard deviation, skewness and kurtosis) have little or no power to predict next-month U.S. stock market returns. Correlations with DJIA and S&P 500 monthly returns since the 1950s are small, with the strongest but still weak relationship being a negative one between prior-month volatility and next-month return. These relationships are also generally not stable across decades.
How do you calculate mean, volatility, skewness and kurtosis of stock returns by month?
Each of the four statistics is calculated for every calendar month using that month's daily index returns, based on daily closes of the DJIA since January 1930 and the S&P 500 since January 1950, through September 2018. The monthly statistics are then averaged by decade and correlated with the following month's index return to test predictive power. The article treats this month-by-month approach as a tractable choice.
How do easy and hard decades for U.S. stocks differ in return and volatility?
The 1950s, 1980s, 1990s and 2010s stand out as "easy" decades with high average daily returns, while the 1930s, 1970s and especially the 2000s are "hard" decades. On volatility, the 1950s and 1960s are "calm" and the 1930s and 2000s are "jumpy," with the 2010s about typical. Skewness and kurtosis also vary by decade, so the equity investing environment is not consistent over long subperiods.
What are the limitations of using basic return statistics to forecast stock market returns?
Basic return statistics show weak, unstable relationships with future returns, so investors should not count on their reliability across decades. The article cautions that the 2010s sample is partial and could change as new data arrive, and that measuring the four moments differently, such as by year rather than by month, may produce different results. It suggests demanding a fairly high level of proof before trusting more specialized return predictors.