Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Testing Zweig’s Combined Super Model

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Economic Indicators, Strategic Allocation, Technical Trading

Guide Market Indicators Breadth and technical indicators

Key Insight

Zweig's Combined Super Model matched FFIDX CAGR while modestly improving Sharpe ratios via reduced volatility (Dec 1986–Mar 2020; monthly rebalancing between FFIDX and cash/bonds based on monetary indicators).

A subscriber requested testing Martin Zweig’s Combined Super Model, which each month specifies an equity allocation based on a system that assigns up to eight points from his Monetary Model and 0 or 2 points from his Four Percent Model. We consider two versions of the Combined Super Model:

  1. Zweig-Cash – Allocate to Fidelity Fund (FFIDX) as equities, with the balance in cash earning the 3-month U.S. Treasury bill (T-bill) yield.
  2. Zweig-FGOVX – Allocate to FFIDX as equities, with the balance in Fidelity Government Income Fund (FGOVX)

The benchmark is buying and holding FFIDX. We focus on compound annual growth rate (CAGR), maximum drawdown (MaxDD) and annual Sharpe ratio, with average monthly T-bill yield during a year as the risk-free rate for that year. We ignore impediments to mutual fund trading and any issues regarding timeliness of allocation changes for end-of-month rebalancing. Using monthly Combined Super Model allocations and monthly fund returns/T-bill yield during December 1986 through March 2020, we find that:

The following table summarizes average monthly returns, standard deviations of monthly returns, CAGRs, MaxDDs, average annual returns (1987-2019), standard deviations of annual returns and annual Sharpe ratios for the benchmark and the two Combined Super Model versions. Combined Super Model versions:

  • Do not boost CAGR.
  • Generate slightly shallower, but still deep, MaxDDs.
  • Offer modestly higher Sharpe ratios by lowering annual volatilities.

Given uncertainties in model execution and the possibility that test and model development periods overlap (introducing some data snooping bias), the Sharpe ratio improvements are not compelling.

For perspective, we look at cumulative performances.

Zweig Super Model performance stats

The following chart tracks cumulative values of $1 initial investments in the benchmark and the two Combined Super Model versions over the full sample period. On most days, the benchmark wins, with much of its higher volatility upside.

Zweig Super Model cumulatives

In summary, evidence indicates that Martin Zweig’s Combined Super Model applied to a diversified U.S. equity fund may offer modest improvement in risk-adjusted, but not raw, performance.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • There may have been impediments to monthly mutual fund rebalancing as assumed (such as loads and/or 1-month redemption penalties) during the sample period.
  • Monthly model allocation changes may not be available for precise end-of-month mutual fund rebalancing.
  • As noted, model development and test periods may overlap, incorporating snooping bias into test results.

See also “Martin Zweig’s Four Percent Model” from some years ago.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Martin Zweig's Combined Super Model for stock market timing?

Martin Zweig's Combined Super Model is a monthly equity allocation system that assigns up to eight points from his Monetary Model and 0 or 2 points from his Four Percent Model. The combined points determine how much of a portfolio is allocated to equities each month. The remainder is held in a safer asset such as cash or government bonds.

Does Zweig's Combined Super Model beat buy-and-hold investing?

Zweig's Combined Super Model did not beat buy-and-hold in raw returns, as neither tested version boosted compound annual growth rate (CAGR) relative to holding Fidelity Fund (FFIDX) during December 1986 through March 2020. Both versions offered modestly higher Sharpe ratios by lowering annual volatility. The Sharpe ratio improvements are not compelling, and the benchmark generally wins on cumulative value on most days.

How do you test a market timing model like Zweig's Combined Super Model against a buy-and-hold benchmark?

The Combined Super Model was tested by applying its monthly equity allocations to Fidelity Fund (FFIDX) returns from December 1986 through March 2020, with the balance in either 3-month T-bills (Zweig-Cash) or Fidelity Government Income Fund (FGOVX) (Zweig-FGOVX). Results were compared against buying and holding FFIDX using CAGR, maximum drawdown and annual Sharpe ratio. The risk-free rate for each year was the average monthly T-bill yield during that year.

Is holding cash or a bond fund better as the non-equity side of Zweig's Combined Super Model?

The article tests both a cash version (Zweig-Cash, using the 3-month T-bill yield) and a bond fund version (Zweig-FGOVX, using Fidelity Government Income Fund) of Zweig's Combined Super Model. Both versions failed to boost CAGR versus buying and holding FFIDX, produced slightly shallower but still deep maximum drawdowns, and offered modestly higher Sharpe ratios. The summary does not identify a clearly superior non-equity choice.

What are the limitations and risks of backtesting Zweig's Combined Super Model?

The backtest of Zweig's Combined Super Model has three main caveats. Monthly mutual fund rebalancing may have faced impediments such as loads or 1-month redemption penalties, and model allocation changes may not have been available for precise end-of-month trades. Test and model development periods may also overlap, introducing data snooping bias that further weakens the modest Sharpe ratio improvements.

Market Indicators guide

More on breadth and technical indicators

All 309 articles in the Market Indicators guide

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 18, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›