Objective research to aid investing decisions

Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)

Allocations for October 2024 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY

Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)

Allocations for October 2024 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Equity Factor Performance During the 2010s

| | Posted in: Strategic Allocation

Are equity factors used in leading models of stock returns reliable performers in practice? In his March 2020 paper entitled “Factor Performance 2010-2019: A Lost Decade?”, David Blitz measures performances of factors tracked in the Kenneth French data library and the q-factor model library during 2010-2019 and compares results to their performances in prior decades. Using data from these libraries for 32 U.S. equity factors and six global non-U.S. factors over available sample periods through 2019, he finds that:

  • For the four non-market factors in the Fama-French 5-factor (market, size, book-to-market, profitability and investment) model:
    • Annualized average gross premium is -0.28% during 2010-2019, compared to 3.95% during 1963-2009.
    • Only the profitability factor has a noticeably positive return during 2010-2019, and at only about half its pre-2010 level.
    • Such a lost decade is not unprecedented, with performance in the 2010s similar to that in the 1990s (both of which decades have double-digit annualized market excess returns).
  • For 10 other in the Kenneth French data library:
    • Three low-risk alternatives, momentum, net share issuance, accruals and short-term reversal have positive premiums during 2010-2019. It is the second-best decade ever for low-risk (1980-1989 is best).
    • The three alternative value metrics all have negative returns, as do the alternative investment factor and net share issuance.
  • Results for global-ex-U.S. factors tracked in the Kenneth French data library  are similar to those for U.S. factors.
  • Results for factors covered in the q-factor model library generally confirm findings.

The following charts, taken from the paper, summarize annualized average gross returns for factors covered in the Kenneth French data library for two subperiods: 1963-2009 and 2010-2019. The upper chart summarizes results for factors in the widely used 5-factor model, while the lower chart addresses other factors. Notable findings for 2010-2019 are:

  • 5-factor model factors do not perform well.
  • Valuation ratios [earnings-to-price (E/P), cash flow-to-price (C/P) and dividend-to-price (D/P)] do not perform well.
  • Three low-risk factors (beta, variance and residual variance) perform very well.

In summary, over the past decade, low-risk factors have performed exceptionally well, while those from leading factor models have not.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • Performance data are gross, not net. Accounting for periodic portfolio reformation frictions and shorting costs would reduce all returns. Shorting may not always be feasible as specified.
  • Moreover, these frictions/costs may vary by factor, such that net comparisons differ from gross comparisons.
Login
Daily Email Updates
Filter Research
  • Research Categories (select one or more)