Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Liquidity in Asset Selection and Asset Class Allocation

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Big Ideas, Strategic Allocation

Guide Asset Allocation and Portfolios Rebalancing and diversification

Key Insight

Damodaran argues that conventional asset allocation and security selection overweight illiquid assets by ignoring trading friction, linking liquidity variations to systematic valuation biases (conceptual framework; descriptive analysis).

Many asset class allocation, asset valuation/selection and asset return anomaly studies ignore or treat lightly the implications of liquidity constraints. What are those implications and how serious are they? In his December 2010 paper entitled “Comatose Markets: What If Liquidity is Not the Norm?”, Aswath Damodaran examines how introducing illiquidity into decision processes affects investors with different time horizons and investment strategies. He focuses on trading friction (brokerage fees, bid-ask spread and price impact) as an illiquidity measurement. Using results from prior research and recent data on liquidity variations within and across asset classes, he finds that:

  • Liquidity varies widely across asset classes, with financial assets generally more liquid than real assets. Within each asset class, there are variations in liquidity across individual assets.
  • Liquidity also varies over time. Over the last century, there is a secular trend towards more liquidity (see “Trading Frictions Over the Long Run”). Within this secular trend, there are cyclical liquidity ebbs and flows. Spikes in illiquidity generally coincide with market crises (see the chart below).
  • Regulatory actions and tax policy can have significant effects on market liquidity (ending of fixed commissions, decimalization of the quote system, capital gain tax level and holding period).
  • Conventional valuation models, which ignore liquidity, tend to thereby overvalue illiquid assets. Moreover, since some investors care more about illiquidity than others, ignoring liquidity obscures the reality different investors value the same asset differently, especially during periods of market illiquidity. Ways of incorporating illiquidity into valuations are: (1) reducing the value of an asset by the present value of expected future transactions costs; and, (2) raising the required rate of return (discount rate) on an asset to reflect its illiquidity.
  • Portfolio optimization methods generally ignore differences in liquidity across asset classes. As market trading volume and liquidity decrease, the standard deviation of returns usually drops, making illiquid assets look less risky. Conventional asset allocation methods thus tend to overweight illiquid asset classes. Asset class allocation should have three dimensions of expectation: return, standard deviation of returns and illiquidity. Investors who value liquidity more (less) should tilt toward more (less) liquid asset classes, with the tilt accentuated during periods when the market is especially illiquid.
  • Most studies of return-enhancing characteristics for individual securities pay only lip service to trading friction, but the congruence between stocks that look cheap in these studies and illiquidity is too high to be coincidental. Failure to incorporate liquidity differences results in overweighting of illiquid securities (such as small-capitalization stocks). Three ways to account for liquidity differences in security selection are: (1) estimate trading frequency and friction and compute net expected returns; (2) add liquidity (volume or share turnover) to security selection screens; and, (3) explicitly add a liquidity (trading friction) constraint at the portfolio level.
  • Liquidity should be an explicit consideration in setting investment strategy leverage, with leverage decreasing as illiquidity increases.
  • Long-term value investors, who care little about liquidity because they trade very infrequently, can extract profits from liquidity-sensitive investors during market crises, as did Warren Buffett in 2008 with investments in Goldman Sachs and General Electric. Short-term traders who can anticipate shifts in liquidity may be able to extract profits from those who cannot.

The following chart, taken from the paper, shows the evolutions of the bid-ask spread for large-capitalization U.S. stocks, the implied volatility of the S&P 500 Index (VIX) and the TED spread during July 2006 to July 2009. For comparability, each series is scaled to have  zero mean and unit standard deviation. The bid-ask spread surges during the September-December 2008 financial crisis, tracking closely the behavior of VIX. The price impact of trading also surges during the crisis. The bid-ask spread remains elevated for months after the crisis. Investors whose strategies forced trading during this period incurred considerable trading friction likely unanticipated by those strategies.

crisis bid ask spread

In summary, evidence of variations in liquidity across asset classes, within asset classes and over time indicates that investors should incorporate liquidity as a decision factor in asset class allocation, security selection and trade timing. Instances of illiquidity may be bargains for long-term investors. Anticipation of liquidity changes may enable superior returns for traders.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is market illiquidity and how is it measured in investing?

Market illiquidity is the difficulty of trading an asset without incurring costs, and Aswath Damodaran measures it through trading friction: brokerage fees, the bid-ask spread and price impact. Liquidity varies widely across asset classes, with financial assets generally more liquid than real assets. It also varies among individual assets within a class and over time.

Does ignoring liquidity cause investors to overvalue illiquid assets?

Yes, according to Damodaran, ignoring liquidity causes conventional valuation and allocation methods to overvalue and overweight illiquid assets. Falling liquidity usually lowers the standard deviation of returns, making illiquid asset classes look less risky than they are. He also finds that stocks appearing cheap in return-anomaly studies overlap with illiquid stocks (such as small-capitalization stocks) too much to be coincidental.

How can liquidity be built into asset valuation and security selection?

Liquidity can be built into valuation by reducing an asset's value by the present value of expected future transaction costs, or by raising its required rate of return (discount rate). For security selection, Damodaran suggests estimating trading frequency and friction to compute net expected returns, adding volume or share turnover to screens, or imposing a portfolio-level trading friction constraint. Asset class allocation should also treat illiquidity as a third dimension alongside expected return and standard deviation.

How do long-term value investors differ from short-term traders in how they are affected by illiquidity?

Long-term value investors care little about liquidity because they trade infrequently, so they can profit from liquidity-sensitive investors during market crises, as Warren Buffett did in 2008 with investments in Goldman Sachs and General Electric. Short-term traders who can anticipate liquidity shifts may profit from those who cannot. Investors who value liquidity more should tilt toward more liquid asset classes, especially when markets are illiquid.

What risks does market illiquidity pose during financial crises?

Illiquidity spikes generally coincide with market crises, exposing investors to trading friction their strategies did not anticipate. During the September-December 2008 crisis, the bid-ask spread for large-capitalization U.S. stocks surged, tracking the VIX closely, and price impact also rose. The bid-ask spread stayed elevated for months afterward, so strategies forcing trading in this period incurred considerable costs.

Asset Allocation and Portfolios guide

More on rebalancing and diversification

All 247 articles in the Asset Allocation and Portfolios guide

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›