Purifying VIX of 18 price-dynamics variables raised profit factors of its trade signals versus random signals, while purification lowered profit factors for AAII, INV, HUL and PCR (five sentiment indicators; 1963–1987 starts through Oct 2008; regression residuals).
It is arguable that sentiment indicators derive substantially from what just happened in the stock market and that they therefore add little or no value to price action itself in predicting future returns. In their May 2009 paper entitled "Purified Sentiment Indicators for the Stock Market", David Aronson and John Wolberg investigate this thesis by removing the influence of recent stock market price dynamics (defined by 18 variations of price velocity, acceleration and volatility) to produce multiple "purified" versions of each of five sentiment indicators: (1) the CBOE Implied Volatility Index (VIX); (2), the CBOE Equity Put-to-Call Ratio (PCR); (3) the American Association of Individual Investors Bulls minus Bears (AAII); (4) the Investors Intelligence Bulls minus and Bears (INV); and, (5) Hulbert's Stock Newsletter Sentiment Index (HUL). They then measure the power of the purified sentiment indicators to generate profitable trading signals by testing 100 signaling rules for each indicator. Using data for the five sentiment indicators from initial availability (ranging from January 1963 to July 1987) through October 2008, along with contemporaneous daily closes of the S&P 500 index, they conclude that:
Read this study free
The rest of this study: 430 words and 1 chart.
Enter your email and we’ll send you a link to this article. 3 premium articles a month, no password or card.
Testing a Proxy for the Goldman Sachs Panic Index PremiumClaude-estimated Goldman Sachs Panic Index values (pixel-reconstructed from a chart) showed high readings (above 8) followed by 1.2% average next-week S&P 500 returns vs…
AI-simulated CFO Sentiment PremiumGPT-5.4-simulated CFO optimism correlates with actual Duke-Federal Reserve CFO Survey responses (LLM mean 56.6 vs actual 60.1; regression coefficient over six standard errors from…
CFO U.S. Economic Sentiment and Stock Market Returns PremiumCFO average U.S. economic sentiment shows little ability to predict S&P 500 returns; correlations with next-four-quarter returns are very weak and negative, while change…
How Are Sentiment-driven ETFs Doing? PremiumAn equal-weighted average of three sentiment ETFs (BUZZ, MOOD, NEWZ; monthly rebalanced) underperformed VTI (1.0% vs 10.7% CAGR; MaxDD -51% vs -25%; sample periods…
Goldman Sachs Panic Index Proxy PremiumA VIX-percentile Panic Index Proxy (trailing 2-year rank, 0–100) shows weak lead-lag association with daily S&P 500 returns, with very high and very low…