Do commodity price changes predict currency exchange rate fluctuations for commodity-exporting countries? In their March 2016 paper entitled “When the Walk is Not Random: Commodity Prices and Exchange Rates”, Emanuel Kohlscheen, Fernando Avalos and Andreas Schrimpf analyze relationships between commodity prices and exporter exchange rates. They first construct daily commodity export price indexes tailored to 11 commodity-exporting countries (Australia, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Colombia, Malaysia, Mexico, Norway, Peru, Russia, South Africa), encompassing 83 commodities (26 metal, 36 agricultural, 11 livestock, 10 energy). They then relate index levels to daily currency exchange rates by country. Using daily UN Comtrade statistics, commodity prices and currency exchange rates in U.S. dollars and Japanese yen as available during January 2004 (Malaysia starts in August 2005, and Russia starts in February 2009) through February 2015, they find that:
- Overall, contemporaneous linear regressions with daily data show that a 10% increase (decrease) in prices of a country’s commodity exports accompanies on average a 2.1% appreciation (depreciation) of the respective. This relationship varies considerably in strength across countries, explaining more than 23% of the exchange rate variation versus the U.S. dollar for Australia and Canada but only about 3% for Peru.
- For in-sample predictive linear regressions, monthly data produce the most robust predictions across countries, exhibiting statistical significance for 10 of 11 countries (excepting South Africa).
- Predictions from out-of-sample linear regressions based on daily data and a rolling five-year estimation window outperform a random walk and a random walk with drift for 10 of 11 countries (excepting Norway) during January 2009 through February 2015. However:
- Results generally weaken for measurement intervals longer than one day.
- Inserting lags in commodity price indexes to ensure time for data collection materially weakens predictive power, suggesting that currency exchange markets are fairly efficient.
- Findings are generally robust to:
- Use of Japanese yen rather than U.S. dollar exchange rates.
- Accounting for changes in country interest rates.
- Accounting for changes in risk aversion as indicated by the S&P 500 Implied Volatility Index (VIX).
In summary, evidence indicates that commodity prices do predict currency exchange rates for commodity exporters, but a fairly efficient exchange market confounds simple exploitation of the predictive power.
Cautions regarding findings include:
- The study does not investigate any currency trading strategies.
- Relationships between export prices and currency exchange rates may not be linear (as assumed in applying linear regressions).
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a commodity currency?
A commodity currency is the currency of a country that relies heavily on commodity exports, so its exchange rate tends to move with the prices of those commodities. In a study of 11 commodity exporters (Australia, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Colombia, Malaysia, Mexico, Norway, Peru, Russia, South Africa), a 10% rise (fall) in a country's commodity export prices accompanied an average 2.1% currency appreciation (depreciation).
Do commodity prices predict exchange rates for commodity-exporting countries?
Commodity prices do predict exchange rates for commodity exporters, but the strength varies by country and horizon. Monthly in-sample regressions were statistically significant for 10 of 11 countries (all but South Africa), and out-of-sample daily regressions beat a random walk for 10 of 11 countries (all but Norway) during January 2009 through February 2015. A fairly efficient currency market makes simple exploitation of this predictive power difficult.
How are commodity export price indexes built and tested against currency exchange rates?
Researchers built daily commodity export price indexes for each of 11 countries using UN Comtrade export data and 83 commodities (26 metal, 36 agricultural, 11 livestock, 10 energy). They then related index levels to daily exchange rates versus the U.S. dollar and Japanese yen using contemporaneous, in-sample predictive and out-of-sample linear regressions over January 2004 through February 2015. The out-of-sample tests used a rolling five-year estimation window and were compared against a random walk and a random walk with drift.
How does the commodity-price link to currencies differ across countries like Australia, Canada and Peru?
The commodity-price link to currencies differs considerably in strength across commodity exporters. Commodity export prices explained more than 23% of exchange rate variation versus the U.S. dollar for Australia and Canada, but only about 3% for Peru. The findings were generally robust to using Japanese yen rather than U.S. dollar exchange rates and to accounting for interest rate changes and risk aversion as measured by the VIX.
What are the limitations of using commodity prices to forecast currency movements?
Commodity price forecasts of currency movements have several limitations: results generally weaken for measurement intervals longer than one day, and adding lags to the commodity price indexes materially weakens predictive power, suggesting fairly efficient currency markets. The study also did not investigate any currency trading strategies. In addition, it assumed linear relationships between export prices and exchange rates, which may not actually be linear.