Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Crowd Surges Predict Negative Returns?

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Animal Spirits

Key Insight

High crowd-sourced information reliance predicts underperformance (-1.7% cumulative abnormal return over 12 weeks; July 2014–July 2016; weekly Yahoo Finance page view ratios; U.S. stocks >$50M market cap).

Does relative demand for crowd-sourced information about a stock compared to other information (such as financial statements and analyst estimates) predict its performance? In their March 2017 paper entitled “Investor Reliance on the Crowd”, Alastair Lawrence, James Ryans, Estelle Sun and Akshay Soni investigate interactions between reliance on crowd-sourced information (Yahoo Finance message board page views) versus other information on individual stocks (via other relevant Yahoo Finance page views) and associated stock returns. They measure reliance as page views for a certain type of information divided by all page views for detailed information about a stock. Using weekly Yahoo Finance page view counts by type of page specific to individual listed U.S. stocks with market capitalizations greater than $50 million during July 2014 through early July 2016, they find that:

  • Page views for detailed information on stocks break down as follows: 74% for message boards, 6% for financial reporting, 4% for analyst estimates/opinions and 3% for historical prices.
  • Reliance on crowd-sourced information:
    • Varies substantially across industries: highest for pharmaceuticals, mining, electrical equipment and precious metals and lowest for textiles, shipping, beer/liquor and business services.
    • Tends to be higher for stocks with high return volatility, negative earnings and returns, high bid-ask spreads, high levels of short interest, low analyst coverage and complex financial reporting.
  • The largest weekly jumps and drops in reliance on crowd-sourced information are typically the same stocks, indicative of shocks followed by mean reversion. 54% of stocks in the lowest tenth (decile) of weekly changes in reliance are in the highest decile the prior week.
  • Stocks in the highest decile of weekly changes in reliance on crowd-sourced information have on average during the next 12 weeks:
    • -1.7% cumulative abnormal (relative to the market) return. This underperformance extends to about -2.5% at week 20, followed by partial reversion through week 36 (see the chart below).
    • 42% increase in bid-ask spread.
    • 5.2% increase in analyst forecast dispersion.

The following chart, taken from the paper, tracks average cumulative abnormal return of stocks in the highest decile of weekly change in reliance on crowd-sourced information on individual stocks from 12 weeks before through 36 weeks after measurement. Week t is the measurement week. Notable results are:

  • -1% drop during the measurement week.
  • Further -2.5% downward movement over the next 20 weeks.
  • +1% partial reversion after week 20.

average cumulative abnormal return for top decile of change in message board reliance

In summary, evidence indicates that sharp increases in reliance on (relative demand for) crowd-sourced information about a stock predict material market underperformance over the next four months.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • The sample period is short in terms of variety of market and investor sentiment conditions.
  • Reported returns are gross, not net. Trading frictions and shorting costs from exploitation of findings would reduce these returns. As noted in the study, bid-ask spreads (and therefore potentially costs of shorting) tend to be elevated during such trading.
  • Information reliance data are not publicly available. Even for those to whom it is available, exploitation is problematic at a portfolio level, requiring a reserve of cash to address opportunities as they unpredictably arise.
  • Future return effects are apparently non-linear, concentrating among stocks with the largest weekly increases in reliance on crowd-sourced information. In other words, stocks with big drops in reliance on crowd-sourced information do not exploitably outperform the market.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is reliance on crowd-sourced information in stock investing?

Reliance on crowd-sourced information is the share of an investor's attention to a stock that goes to crowd-generated content, such as Yahoo Finance message boards, rather than other sources like financial statements, analyst estimates and historical prices. It is measured as page views of one information type divided by all page views for detailed information about the stock. In the study, message boards accounted for 74% of detailed-information page views, versus 6% for financial reporting, 4% for analyst estimates/opinions and 3% for historical prices.

Does a surge in crowd-sourced information demand predict negative stock returns?

Yes, a surge in reliance on crowd-sourced information predicts stock underperformance. Stocks in the highest decile of weekly change in reliance averaged a -1.7% cumulative abnormal return relative to the market over the next 12 weeks, extending to about -2.5% by week 20 before partial reversion through week 36. The data covered U.S. stocks with market capitalizations above $50 million from July 2014 to early July 2016.

How is investor reliance on message board information measured and tested against returns?

Investor reliance on message boards is measured using weekly Yahoo Finance page view counts for individual U.S. stocks, calculated as message board page views divided by all page views for detailed information about that stock. Stocks are sorted into dedeciles by weekly change in this reliance, and subsequent cumulative abnormal returns relative to the market are tracked from 12 weeks before through 36 weeks after the measurement week. The sample covers stocks above $50 million in market capitalization from July 2014 to early July 2016.

Do stocks with big drops in crowd-sourced information reliance outperform like big increases underperform?

No, the return effect is not symmetric. Future returns are apparently non-linear, concentrating among stocks with the largest weekly increases in reliance on crowd-sourced information, while stocks with big drops in reliance do not exploitably outperform the market. The largest jumps and drops often occur in the same stocks, suggesting shocks followed by mean reversion, with 54% of stocks in the lowest decile of weekly changes having been in the highest decile the prior week.

What are the limitations of trading on crowd-sourced information reliance signals?

The main limitations are that the sample period is short and lacks variety in market and sentiment conditions, and reported returns are gross rather than net of costs. Trading frictions and shorting costs would reduce returns, and bid-ask spreads tend to be elevated (a 42% increase) during such trading. The page view reliance data are also not publicly available, and portfolio-level exploitation is problematic because opportunities arise unpredictably and require a cash reserve.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›