BuyWrite (BXM), PutWrite (PUT) and 95-110 Collar (CLL) indexes underperformed the S&P 500 Total Return Index (CAGR 8.6%, 9.7%, 7.5% vs 10.9%; June 1986–Mar 2022; monthly end-of-month levels, gross of costs); ETF versions PBP and PUTW lagged SPY.
Do simple stock index option strategies (stock-covered calls, cash-covered puts and collars) outperform the underlying index? To investigate, we examine performances of:
We focus on monthly return statistics, compound annual growth rates (CAGR) and maximum drawdowns (MaxDD) for comparisons. Using end-of-month levels for SPTR, BXM, PUT and CLL since June 1986, total returns for SPY and PBP since December 2007 (limited by PBP) and total returns for SPY and PUTW since February 2016 (limited by PUTW), all through March 2022, we find that:
Read this study free
The rest of this study: 680 words and 7 charts.
Enter your email and we’ll send you a link to this article. 3 premium articles a month, no password or card.
Historical U.S. Equity Returns for a 5-Year Horizon PremiumRolling 5-year nominal returns were negative about 22% of the time for both Shiller's S&P Composite Index (total return, 1871–2025; 149 overlapping intervals) and…
How Are Laddered Buffer ETFs Doing? PremiumFive laddered buffer ETFs had lower CAGRs than SPY or QQQ (equal-weighted average 9.9% vs 14.4%) but shallower monthly MaxDDs (-12% vs -24%) (sample…
Half-day Momentum and Reversal in Stock Options PremiumU.S. stock option returns show half-day momentum at even lags and reversal at odd lags, with daily long-short deciles earning 0.22% (intraday) and 0.45%…
Signals from Trading Volumes of Informed Traders PremiumThe INFO factor (long top/short bottom decile of equal-weighted stocks ranked monthly on insider net purchases, short interest, and option/stock volume) returned 1.12% gross…
Equity Options Trading Frictions PremiumIdentical market orders placed across six brokers averaged 3.9% round-trip frictions relative to position size, ranging from about 0% (Vanguard) to 7% (Robinhood) and…