Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Dynamic Retirement Portfolio Sustainable Withdrawal Rate

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Strategic Allocation

Guide Asset Allocation and Portfolios Fixed and lazy portfolios

Key Insight

Retirement withdrawal failure rates vary widely by country; for a 4% initial withdrawal and annually rebalanced 60/40 stocks/bonds, failure ranged 1.1% (Canada) to 67% (Italy), 4.4% for the U.S. (21 countries and world; 1900–2019; 30-year retirements).

How can retirees estimate whether their investment strategy will sustain all the withdrawals they expect to make in retirement? In his February 2021 paper entitled "The Sustainability of (Global) Withdrawal Strategies", Javier Estrada  presents two tools to monitor retirement plans for early signs of trouble:

  1. One evaluates sustainability of an existing withdrawal strategy.
  2. The other calculates the sustainable level of inflation-adjusted withdrawals at any given point during retirement.

Both change over time according to (1) deviations of actual returns from those used in modeling the retirement portfolio and (2) the number of years left in retirement. He also illustrates these tools for a sample of 21 countries and the world over a 120-year period assuming a 30-year retirement with 30 annual withdrawals at the beginning of each year. The terminal value one year after the final withdrawal is the bequest. All returns and portfolio values are in real (inflation-adjusted) terms. Using annual real total returns for stocks and government bonds for 21 countries in local currencies/inflation rates and the world in U.S. dollars/inflation rate from the Dimson-Marsh-Staunton database during 1900 through 2019, he finds that:

Subscribe to Keep Reading

Get the research edge serious investors rely on.

  • 1,200+ research articles
  • Monthly strategy signals
  • 20+ years of backtested analysis
$17.99 /month

Cancel anytime

Asset Allocation and Portfolios guide

More on fixed and lazy portfolios

  • Are Target Retirement Date Funds Attractive? Premium Vanguard Target Retirement 2020-2050 funds were generally not preferable to a monthly rebalanced 60% SPY/40% LQD mix on return, volatility and reward-to-risk metrics (inceptions…
  • Retirement Portfolio ETF Allocations by AI Panel Premium Is the evolving set of artificial intelligence (AI) platforms based on large language models interesting as retirement portfolio specification advisors? Are they monolithic, or…
  • Testing the All Weather Portfolio Premium The annually rebalanced 60/40 VTI/TLT benchmark beat the All Weather portfolio (30% VTI, 40% TLT, 15% IEF, 7.5% GLD, 7.5% DBC; annual rebalance) in…
  • Review of the Golden Butterfly Portfolio Premium Golden Butterfly (equal-weight VTI/IJS/TLT/SHY/GLD; monthly or annual rebalancing) had markedly lower CAGR than VTI and GLD but a fairly shallow maximum drawdown (ETFs Nov…
  • Best Defense for a 60/40 Portfolio? Premium Defensive Absolute Return (DAR; monthly long lowest-/short highest-correlation thirds of 25 long/short factors) averaged 0.8% gross monthly return in the 60/40 portfolio's worst 10%…

All 247 articles in the Asset Allocation and Portfolios guide