Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Use Short-term Signals to Inform Rebalancing?

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Technical Trading

Guide Asset Allocation and Portfolios Rebalancing and diversification

Key Insight

Informed trading (using weekly reversal signals to time rebalancing) boosted optimal net Sharpe ratio from 0.56 to 0.62 for a country index value-momentum portfolio (1980-2009; 18 developed markets).

Can long-term investors who periodically rebalance their portfolios materially enhance performance by using short-term signals to “permit” rebalancing? In their April 2010 paper entitled “To Trade or Not to Trade? Informed Trading with High-Frequency Signals for Long-Term Investors”, Roni Israelov and Michael Katz test the effects of such a tactical “informed trading” twist on long-run portfolio performance, focusing on the net Sharpe ratio as the bottom line discriminator. As an example, they apply one-week reversal signals to rebalancing a value-momentum portfolio that selects high value (book-to-market), high momentum (12-month past return) country indexes from among developed markets. Using book-to-market and return data for 18 developed markets over the period 1980-2009 (30 years), they conclude that:

  • For a given rebalancing frequency, “informed trading” reduces trading costs (because the short-term signal defers some trades).
  • Informed trading enhances long-term portfolio performance by avoiding those rebalancing trades that would transfer wealth to short-term traders.
  • Informed trading tends to shorten optimal portfolio rebalancing frequency because the information in the short-term signal decays rapidly. For example, applying a weekly reversal signal to inform rebalancing of the country index momentum-value portfolio described above:
    • Reduces optimal rebalancing frequency from 15 days to two days.
    • Boosts  optimal net Sharpe ratio from 0.56 to 0.62 over the entire sample period, with additional costs from more frequent rebalancing more than offset by enhanced gross performance.
  • For simulated portfolios, optimal net Sharpe ratio improves from 0.64 for the long-term portfolio alone to 0.68 for the informed trading portfolio.

The following chart, taken from the paper, compares long-term net Sharpe ratios of three alternative portfolios based on the country index value-momentum strategy described above for rebalancing frequencies ranging from one day to 65 days:

  • The Long-Term Portfolio uses only the long-term value (book-to-market) and momentum (12-month lagged return) signals with set rebalancing frequencies.
  • The Optimally Mixed Portfolio uses optimized, fixed weighting factors to combine the short-term weekly reversal and long-term momentum-value signals.
  • The Informed Trading Portfolio uses the short-term signal to decide whether to execute or delay each rebalancing action.

The assumed trading friction for all three portfolios is 0.10% one way. The chart shows that the trading frequency that maximizes net Sharpe ratio differs among the strategies, and that the informed trading approach wins at nearly all trading frequencies.

net sharpe ratios

In summary, evidence suggests that long-term investors may be able to boost net Sharpe ratio by using high-frequency signals to make trade-or-delay decisions at each scheduled portfolio rebalancing.

Some considerations regarding this analysis are:

  • Intensive comparison of rebalancing frequencies across multiple portfolio models may introduce material data snooping bias, resulting in overstatement of expected returns for the winning combinations.
  • The assumed level of trading friction in the example (0.10% one way) may be unrealistically low for investable implementations of country indexes over the sample period (especially for individual investors).
  • The rebalancing frequency optimization process appears to incorporate look-ahead bias. An investor operating in real time would not have known the frequency optimal for the entire sample period.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is informed trading in portfolio rebalancing?

Informed trading is a tactical approach in which a long-term investor uses a short-term signal, such as a one-week reversal signal, to decide whether to execute or delay each scheduled portfolio rebalancing trade. It aims to cut trading costs and avoid trades that would transfer wealth to short-term traders. The article tests it on a country index value-momentum portfolio of 18 developed markets over 1980-2009.

Does using short-term signals to time rebalancing improve a long-term portfolio's Sharpe ratio?

Using short-term signals to time rebalancing improved net Sharpe ratio in the article's test, raising the optimal net Sharpe ratio from 0.56 to 0.62 for a country index value-momentum portfolio over 1980-2009. For simulated portfolios, it rose from 0.64 to 0.68. The informed trading approach outperformed the long-term-only portfolio at nearly all tested rebalancing frequencies, though results are subject to data snooping and look-ahead caveats.

How is informed trading tested against a standard rebalancing strategy?

Informed trading was tested by comparing net Sharpe ratios of three portfolios built on a country index value-momentum strategy (book-to-market and 12-month past return) across rebalancing frequencies from one day to 65 days. The Long-Term Portfolio rebalances on set schedules, the Optimally Mixed Portfolio blends short-term reversal and long-term signals with fixed weights, and the Informed Trading Portfolio uses the weekly reversal signal to execute or delay each rebalance. All three assumed 0.10% one-way trading friction.

How does informed trading differ from simply blending short-term and long-term signals?

Informed trading uses the short-term signal only to decide whether to execute or delay each scheduled rebalancing trade, whereas the optimally mixed approach combines short-term reversal and long-term momentum-value signals using fixed, optimized weights. In the article's chart, the informed trading portfolio achieved higher net Sharpe ratios than the alternatives at nearly all rebalancing frequencies. Informed trading also shortened the optimal rebalancing frequency from 15 days to two days because the short-term signal's information decays rapidly.

What are the limitations of using short-term signals to inform portfolio rebalancing?

The article's results may be overstated because comparing many rebalancing frequencies across multiple portfolio models can introduce data snooping bias. The assumed 0.10% one-way trading friction may be unrealistically low for investable country index implementations, especially for individual investors. The optimization also appears to have look-ahead bias, since a real-time investor would not know the optimal rebalancing frequency for the entire sample period.

Asset Allocation and Portfolios guide

More on rebalancing and diversification

All 247 articles in the Asset Allocation and Portfolios guide

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›