A reader asked and commented: “How has Jack Steiman done? I have heard that he does a good job of calling the markets.”
Jack Steiman offers “stock picks, trade alerts, and technical analysis for swing traders” via SwingTradeOnline, a service of Market Insider Corporation. According to SwingTradeOnline, Jack Steiman “is a former columnist for TheStreet.com who is renowned for calling major shifts in the market. President of New York-based Visionary Research Group, Jack consults to individuals and companies on stock market analysis and education.” A search of TheStreet.com for “Jack Steiman” does not produce enough results to test his renown.
SwingTradeOnline presents a performance summary for his swing trade recommendations with summary data claiming triple-digit annual total returns and an average inception-to-date return per trade of 0.95%. Trade details are available only for about four months. According to the SwingTradeOnline disclaimer:
“Mr. Steiman’s commentaries and index analysis represent his own opinions and should not be relied upon for purposes of effecting securities transactions or other investing strategies… You should not interpret Mr. Steiman’s opinions as constituting investment advice. Trades mentioned on the site are hypothetical, not actual, positions and Mr. Steiman and the publishers of this site do not have personal positions in instruments mentioned on the site.
“Hypothetical performance results do not include trading commissions and other execution costs that would be incurred if the trades referenced on the site were actual trades. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
“Mr. Steiman and the publishers of this site cannot and do not assess, verify or guarantee the suitability or profitability of any particular investment.”
Note that the disclaimer is saying:
- The trades did not really happen.
- The performance calculations do not include reasonable trading frictions (bid-ask spread and transaction costs).
- Jack Steiman and his associates apparently choose not to make these trades themselves.
Note also that the SwingTradeOnline fee of about $100 per month is additive to trading frictions.
Note further that SwingTradeOnline does not state the assumptions about portfolio position management (percentage of portfolio allocated to each trade) used to calculate claimed total return performance. The following chart plots the number of SwingTradeOnline open positions derived from the detailed closed position data for 1/4/10-4/26/10. Based on this modest sample, a subscriber must plan for at least eight concurrent positions to participate in all trades, with the overall portfolio therefore mostly in cash much of the time. Only with perfect hindsight could the subscriber capture full per-trade returns at the portfolio level.

In summary, there is considerable burden on prospective subscribers to determine whether SwingTradeOnline signals could be profitable for them at a portfolio level after reasonable trading frictions and subscriber fee.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is SwingTradeOnline and what does swing trading mean?
SwingTradeOnline is a Market Insider Corporation service offering stock picks, trade alerts, and technical analysis for swing traders, led by Jack Steiman. Swing trading means holding positions for a short period to capture market moves. The service costs about $100 per month and presents a performance summary of Steiman's swing trade recommendations.
Does Jack Steiman's SwingTradeOnline actually deliver triple-digit annual returns?
SwingTradeOnline claims triple-digit annual total returns and an average inception-to-date return of 0.95% per trade for Jack Steiman's swing trades, but these claims are not verified as achievable. The trades are hypothetical, not actual positions, and the results exclude trading commissions and other execution costs. Detailed trade data covers only about four months (1/4/10-4/26/10), so the article finds the evidence insufficient to confirm profitability for subscribers.
How can you test whether a swing trading service's performance is realistic at the portfolio level?
Testing a swing trading service's performance at the portfolio level requires counting concurrent open positions from detailed closed-trade data and checking the position-sizing assumptions behind claimed returns. For SwingTradeOnline, the article derived open positions from closed-trade data for 1/4/10-4/26/10 and found a subscriber would need to plan for at least eight concurrent positions. Returns must also be adjusted for trading frictions such as bid-ask spreads, transaction costs, and the roughly $100 monthly subscriber fee.
Are hypothetical trade results the same as real trading performance?
Hypothetical trade results are not the same as real trading performance, because the trades never actually occurred and omit commissions and other execution costs. SwingTradeOnline's disclaimer states its trades are hypothetical and that neither Jack Steiman nor the publishers hold personal positions in them. Real subscribers would also bear bid-ask spreads and a subscription fee of about $100 per month, which reduce net returns relative to the claimed figures.
What are the limitations and risks of relying on SwingTradeOnline's performance claims?
SwingTradeOnline's performance claims have several limitations: the trades are hypothetical, costs like bid-ask spreads and commissions are excluded, and the roughly $100 monthly fee is not reflected. The service also does not state its portfolio position management assumptions, such as the percentage of portfolio allocated to each trade, and the detailed trade sample covers only about four months. The article notes that capturing full per-trade returns at the portfolio level would require perfect hindsight, since a subscriber needs at least eight concurrent positions and would be mostly in cash much of the time.