Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Categorical Versus Stock-specific Thinking

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Animal Spirits

Key Insight

Categorical thinking (industry/style focus over stock-specific analysis) underperformed in US equity mutual funds (lowest vs highest decile CTI: 3.7% net annual outperformance; 1990-2011; 2,812 funds).

How much do equity investors leave on the table by focusing on categories of stocks (industry or style) and paying little attention to individual stocks? In her July 2013 paper entitled “Categorical Thinking in Portfolio Choice”, Swasti Gupta-Mukherjee investigates whether such simplifying categorical thinking is economically beneficial and what factors magnify or diminish it. She focuses on managers of U.S. equity mutual funds. She defines a Categorical Thinking Index (CTI) as relative emphasis on category-wide information relative to stock-specific information for making portfolio adjustments. She implements CTI based on two-digit SIC codes (broad industries) as categories. Each quarter, she measures CTI for a mutual fund based on the explanatory power of past industry returns for portfolio changes relative to the explanatory power of past individual stock returns for these changes. Using monthly returns, quarterly holdings and style (benchmark) representations for 2,812 U.S. equity mutual funds, along with associated industry and individual stock returns, during 1990 to 2011, she finds that:

  • Categorical thinking as defined and measured varies considerably across funds, indicating the potential for meaningful explanation of fund performance.
  • In aggregate, categorical thinking tends to be high when investor sentiment is extreme and to increase with market uncertainty (as measured by VIX), asset-level information uncertainty (as for growth stocks) and level of portfolio diversification across industries and styles.
  • Categorical thinking tends to be stronger among fund managers who head contrarian and more expensive funds, have longer tenure and rely more on public information in the form of analyst forecasts.
  • Portfolio managers who exhibit strong categorical thinking significantly underperform those who exhibit weak categorical thinking.
    • The funds with the lowest tenth of CTI outperform those with the highest tenth by a net annual average of 3.7%, with average net annual four-factor (market, size, book-to-market ratio, momentum) alpha 2.2%.
    • Outperformance of low-CTI managers is attributable largely to stock picking and not style timing.

In summary, evidence suggests that U.S. equity investors who focus strongly on industries/styles and weakly on individual stocks underperform those with the opposite approach by roughly 4% net per year.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • The definition of categorical thinking is abstract, and its calculation numerically intensive. Investors therefore may consider findings more relevant to development of their own investment approaches rather than selection of mutual funds.
  • The study uses equities and equity categories (mostly industries and somewhat styles) to investigate categorical thinking. Results may differ when applied across asset classes.

See also “Stock Picking or Industry Picking?” and “Sector Rotation vs. Stock Picking”.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Categorical Thinking Index (CTI) for mutual fund managers?

The Categorical Thinking Index (CTI) measures a fund manager's relative emphasis on category-wide information (such as industry returns) versus stock-specific information when adjusting a portfolio. It is computed each quarter as the explanatory power of past industry returns for portfolio changes relative to the explanatory power of past individual stock returns. The study uses two-digit SIC codes (broad industries) as the categories.

Do mutual fund managers who focus on industries over individual stocks underperform?

Yes, U.S. equity mutual fund managers with strong categorical thinking significantly underperform those with weak categorical thinking. Funds in the lowest tenth of CTI outperformed those in the highest tenth by a net annual average of 3.7%, with an average net annual four-factor alpha of 2.2%, over 1990-2011 across 2,812 funds. The outperformance of low-CTI managers is attributable largely to stock picking rather than style timing.

How is categorical thinking measured in mutual fund portfolio decisions?

Categorical thinking is measured each quarter for each fund by comparing how well past industry returns explain the fund's portfolio changes against how well past individual stock returns explain those changes. The study used monthly returns, quarterly holdings and style (benchmark) representations for 2,812 U.S. equity mutual funds during 1990-2011, with two-digit SIC codes defining industries. Funds are then ranked by the resulting CTI, and performance is compared across deciles.

What conditions and manager traits are associated with higher categorical thinking versus stock-specific analysis?

Categorical thinking tends to be higher when investor sentiment is extreme and rises with market uncertainty (VIX), asset-level information uncertainty (as with growth stocks) and portfolio diversification across industries and styles. It is also stronger among managers of contrarian and more expensive funds, managers with longer tenure, and managers who rely more on public information such as analyst forecasts. These patterns contrast with stock-specific thinking, which is associated with better net performance.

What are the limitations of using categorical thinking measures to evaluate mutual funds?

The definition of categorical thinking is abstract and its calculation is numerically intensive, so the findings may be more useful for developing one's own investment approach than for selecting mutual funds. The study examines only equities and equity categories (mostly industries and somewhat styles), so results may differ across other asset classes.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 18, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›