The conventional binary animal metaphor for markets is bull (good returns, low volatility) and bear (poor returns, high volatility). Does rigorous analysis of empirical evidence support belief in (just) two market states? In their September 2011 paper entitled “The Number of Regimes Across Asset Returns: Identification and Economic Value”, Mathieu Gatumel and Florian Ielpo apply a regime-switching model and Monte Carlo simulations to determine the likely number of regimes implicit in the returns of 19 asset classes. Their general approach is to increase the number of regimes included in the model until adding a regime no longer materially improves the fit of the model to the actual return distribution. In other words, among statistically equivalent models, they always choose the one with the smallest number of regimes. They discuss the persistence of and performance under each regime discovered. Using weekly return data for various stock and bond indexes, currency exchange rates and commodity indexes over the period April 1998 through mid-December 2010 (650 weeks or 12.5 years), they find that:
- Over the sample period, the number of regimes required to describe asset return distributions ranges from two for exchange rates, commodities and investment grade bonds to three for many equity indexes to five for high yield bonds (see the chart below).
- Most of the assets exhibit the same number of regimes across subperiods. However, while the S&P 500 Index exhibits two regimes during 1998-2010, a third state emerges during 2007-2008 and 2007-2010 subperiods.
- Asset classes driven by:
- Two regimes tend to have two very persistent states.
- Three regimes tend to have one very persistent state and two transitory states.
- More than three regimes always have two persistent states, with the other states often transitory.
- A strategy of allocating funds based on the number of regimes evidenced in past data improves out-of-sample investment performance for 15 of 19 asset classes in comparison to a default two-regime strategy. This refinement works best for asset classes with the largest number of empirical regimes.
The following chart, taken from the paper, presents the estimated number of regimes for each of the 19 asset classes over the entire sample period for two modeling assumptions. The main conclusion is that most asset classes exhibit more than two return regimes. Consistency of results for the two modeling assumptions suggests robustness.

In summary, evidence from complex modeling suggests that investors may be able to improve asset class allocation performance by letting data determine the number of return regimes for each class (rather than assuming that bull and bear states explain behaviors of all asset classes).
Cautions regarding findings include:
- A 12.5 year sample seems small compared to secular trends that plausibly might disrupt market regime behaviors.
- Methods are complex and likely inaccessible to many investors.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a market regime in finance and investing?
A market regime is a distinct state of asset returns, such as the conventional bull state (good returns, low volatility) or bear state (poor returns, high volatility). Regime-switching models treat returns as moving between these states, and the paper tests whether two states are enough to describe the return behavior of 19 asset classes.
Does using more than two market regimes improve asset allocation performance?
Allocating based on the number of regimes found in past data improved out-of-sample performance for 15 of 19 asset classes compared with a default two-regime strategy. The improvement was largest for asset classes with the most empirical regimes. This comes from weekly data covering April 1998 through mid-December 2010.
How do researchers determine the number of regimes in asset returns?
Researchers apply a regime-switching model and Monte Carlo simulations, adding regimes until an extra regime no longer materially improves the fit to the actual return distribution. Among statistically equivalent models, they choose the one with the fewest regimes. The study used 650 weeks of data for stock and bond indexes, currencies and commodity indexes.
Do all asset classes have the same number of market regimes as stocks?
No, the number of regimes varies by asset class. Exchange rates, commodities and investment grade bonds need two regimes, many equity indexes need three, and high yield bonds need five. The S&P 500 Index showed two regimes over 1998-2010, but a third state emerged in the 2007-2008 and 2007-2010 subperiods.
What are the limitations of multi-regime models for investing?
The 12.5-year sample is short relative to secular trends that could plausibly disrupt market regime behavior. The methods are also complex and likely inaccessible to many investors. Regimes beyond two or three are often transitory, with typically only two persistent states.