Are low trading frictions, high trading speed and proliferation of trading strategies elevating market efficiency and thereby extinguishing U.S. stock anomalies? In their March 2012 paper entitled “Trends in the Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns”, Tarun Chordia, Avanidhar Subrahmanyam and Qing Tong examine the evolution of individual U.S. stock return predictability based on stock/firm characteristics found in the past (mostly during the 1990s) to have predictive power. Characteristics considered include: size; book-to-market ratio; share turnover; cumulative return over five months ending one month ago; cumulative return over six months ending six months ago; monthly return reversal; stock illiquidity; stock price; analyst forecast dispersion; standardized unexpected earnings; and, accounting accruals. They test anomaly evolution across two subperiods using both regressions and long-short portfolios. Using data as available for NYSE-AMEX common stocks during 1976-2009 (with equal subperiods 1976-1992 and 1993- 2009) and for NASDAQ commons stocks during 1983-2009 (with comparable subperiods 1983-1992 and 1993-2009), they find that:
- As markets have become more active and liquid in the recent subperiod, regressions show that return anomalies generally weaken in magnitude and statistical significance.
- The strengths of commonly applied (size, book-to-market and momentum) risk factors attenuate.
- Both momentum effects weaken, and the share turnover effect disappears.
- Effects derived from dispersion of analyst opinion, standardized unexpected earnings, monthly reversals and accounting accruals are inconsistent in the recent subsample, and completely lose significance for liquid NYSE/AMEX stocks. Liquid Nasdaq stocks also exhibit reduced predictability.
- Reward-risk ratios (measured by squared Sharpe ratios) for portfolios that are long (short) stocks with predicted returns above (below) average, reformed monthly, diminish markedly across subperiods. Significant profitability persists only for less liquid NASDAQ stocks. (See the chart below.)
- Performance of a liquidity-driven one-month reversal portfolio weakens dramatically from a statistically significant 0.8% per month in the early subperiod to an insignificant -0.2% per month in the recent subperiod.
The following chart, constructed from data in the paper, summarizes squared Sharpe ratios for portfolios that are long (short) NYSE/AMEX/NASDAQ common stocks with predicted returns above (below) average, reformed monthly, based on several individual and one combined stock return predictors. For all cases, the reward-risk ratio is much stronger during the early subperiod than the recent subperiod, and statistical significance is mostly lacking during the recent subperiod.
Refined results for the combined indicator show that statistical significance survives into the recent subperiod only for NASDAQ stocks with below-median liquidity.

In summary, evidence indicates that, as trading activity increases, anomalies associated with individual U.S. stock/firm characteristics weaken, both statistically and economically.
Cautions regarding findings include:
- Return and Sharpe ratio calculations are gross, not net. Incorporating realistic trading frictions, which vary considerably over the sample period, would reduce returns (more strongly in the early subperiod) and may alter findings. See “Trading Frictions Over the Long Run”. Trading frictions also vary with stock characteristics.
- Long-short portfolio return calculations do not consider the feasibility or cost of shorting, so results may be unrealistic.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a stock market anomaly in finance?
A stock market anomaly is a pattern in returns that can be predicted using stock or firm characteristics, such as size, book-to-market ratio, momentum, share turnover, or accruals. These characteristics were found, mostly during the 1990s, to have predictive power for U.S. stock returns. Such patterns are considered anomalies because they appear to contradict market efficiency.
Does greater market liquidity make stock return anomalies disappear?
Greater market liquidity weakens stock return anomalies markedly but does not eliminate every one. In U.S. stocks over 1976-2009, comparing 1976-1992 with 1993-2009, anomaly strength and statistical significance generally declined, and the share turnover effect disappeared. Significant profitability in the recent subperiod persisted only for less liquid NASDAQ stocks.
How do researchers test whether stock anomalies have weakened over time?
Researchers split the sample into two equal subperiods and compare anomaly strength using both regressions and long-short portfolios. The study covered NYSE-AMEX stocks for 1976-2009 (subperiods 1976-1992 and 1993-2009) and NASDAQ stocks for 1983-2009 (subperiods 1983-1992 and 1993-2009). Long-short portfolios, reformed monthly, buy stocks with above-average predicted returns and short those below average, with reward-risk measured by squared Sharpe ratios.
How do anomalies in liquid stocks compare with those in illiquid stocks?
Anomalies in liquid stocks are weaker than those in illiquid stocks in the recent subperiod. Effects tied to analyst forecast dispersion, standardized unexpected earnings, monthly reversals and accruals completely lose significance for liquid NYSE/AMEX stocks. For the combined predictor, significance survives in the recent subperiod only for NASDAQ stocks with below-median liquidity.
What are the limitations of long-short anomaly portfolio backtests?
The long-short portfolio backtests in this study use gross rather than net returns and Sharpe ratios, so they ignore trading frictions that varied considerably over the sample and would reduce returns, especially in the early subperiod. Trading frictions also vary with stock characteristics. The calculations also ignore the feasibility and cost of shorting, so results may be unrealistic.