Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Best Stock Market Forecasters?

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Investing Expertise

Key Insight

Academics outperformed other professional groups in Livingston Survey stock market forecasts, but no group convincingly beat a naive momentum approach (120 semi-annual surveys; 1-6 month horizons).

Where can investors find the best stock market forecasters: academia, banks, government? In the March 2012 draft of his paper entitled “On the Forecasting Quality of Professionals”, Aron Veress compares the stock market forecasting accuracies of different professional groups (academics, commercial bankers, investment bankers, government employees and non-financial professionals) who participate in the semi-annual Livingston Survey, both to each other and to quantitative predictors. He focuses on forecasts of the S&P Composite Index return at horizons of roughly one month and six months after publication of survey reports (early June/December of each year). He considers also a naive forecasting approach that invests in stocks or cash according to which has the higher preceding return. Using results from 120 semi-annual surveys and contemporaneous data for the S&P Composite Index and commonly used financial/economic U.S. stock market predictors, he finds that:

  • For six-month forecasts:
    • Academics and commercial bankers perform equal to or better than the survey average, while investment bankers significantly underperform.
    • Compared to survey results, the naive approach based on immediately preceding return performs better (worse) regarding direction (magnitude) of future returns.
  • For one-month forecasts:
    • Academics are again above average, while commercial (investment) bankers drop below (rise above) average. Governmental employees perform relatively well.
    • Again, compared to survey results, the naive approach performs notably better (worse) regarding direction (magnitude) of future returns.
  • Investment bankers (government employees) tend to be optimistic (pessimistic), and academics the most consistent. Forecast accuracy generally degrades during economic contractions.
  • Overall, bankers mostly underperform other professions in predicting U.S. stock market returns, while academicians outperform. No group convincingly outperforms the naive approach.
  • Out-of-sample stock market forecasts derived from linear regressions of future returns against dividend yield, earnings-price ratio, inflation rate, change in 3-month Treasury bill yield and NBER recessions are similar to those from the Livingston surveys.
  • With regard to influences:
    • Commercial (investment) bankers appear most influenced by dividend yield (earnings-price ratio).
    • Academics appear most influenced by the inflation rate.
    • In aggregate, survey participants seem not to believe in long-run mean reversion of stock market returns.

In summary, evidence from the Livingston survey does not support belief that either qualitative stock market forecasts or those generated by simple indicators beat a naive investing approach.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • As noted in the paper, dispersion in survey response dates confounds analysis.
  • Also as noted in the paper, group sample sizes are small, inhibiting confidence in findings.

For other studies of Livingston Survey forecasts, see “Professional Economists Forecasting Stock Returns” and “Should Equity Investors Hope for Good or Bad Economic Forecasts?”.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Livingston Survey and how does it track stock market forecasts?

The Livingston Survey is a semi-annual survey of professional forecasters, including academics, commercial bankers, investment bankers, government employees and non-financial professionals, who predict economic and financial variables such as the S&P Composite Index. In the study described, 120 semi-annual surveys were used to evaluate stock market forecasts made at horizons of roughly one month and six months after publication (early June and December each year).

Do professional forecasters beat a simple momentum strategy at predicting stock market returns?

Professional forecasters in the Livingston Survey do not convincingly beat a naive momentum approach, which invests in stocks or cash based on whichever had the higher preceding return. The naive approach predicted the direction of future returns better than the survey at both one-month and six-month horizons, though it was worse at predicting magnitude. Academics outperformed other groups, while bankers mostly underperformed.

How is the accuracy of stock market forecasters compared across professional groups?

The study compares the S&P Composite Index return forecasts of each professional group in the Livingston Survey against realized returns at horizons of about one month and six months, using 120 semi-annual surveys. Group forecasts are also benchmarked against a naive approach based on preceding return and against out-of-sample linear regressions using dividend yield, earnings-price ratio, inflation rate, change in the 3-month Treasury bill yield and NBER recessions. Accuracy is assessed for both direction and magnitude of future returns.

How do academic stock market forecasters compare with bankers and government economists?

Academics outperformed bankers in Livingston Survey stock market forecasts, performing at or above the survey average at both the one-month and six-month horizons and showing the most consistency. Investment bankers significantly underperformed at six months and tended to be optimistic, while commercial bankers dropped below average at one month. Government employees tended to be pessimistic but performed relatively well at one month.

What are the limitations of using survey-based stock market forecasts to judge forecaster skill?

Survey-based evaluations of stock market forecasters have limitations: in the Livingston Survey study, dispersion in survey response dates confounds the analysis, and small group sample sizes reduce confidence in the findings. Forecast accuracy also generally degrades during economic contractions. These caveats mean the finding that academics outperform bankers should be treated cautiously.