Recent research on the (stock picking and market timing) abilities of experts to generate excess returns has focused mostly on mutual funds and hedge funds. This focus stems from data availability (mutual funds via SEC filings) and headline value (hedge funds). Where is the research on investment newsletters? How do they rate in terms of excess returns? Digging deeper than usual, we find two on-target papers: (1) the February 1995 paper entitled “Market Timing Ability and Volatility Implied in Investment Newsletters’ Asset Allocation Recommendations” by John Graham and Campbell Harvey; and, (2) the November 1997 paper entitled “The Equity Performance of Investment Newsletters” by Andrew Metrick. Both papers draw upon the investment newsletter archive of the Hulbert Financial Digest. Using different aspects of this archive, they determine that:
In “Market Timing Ability and Volatility Implied in Investment Newsletters’ Asset Allocation Recommendations”, John Graham and Campbell Harvey use the equity/cash mix recommendations from a sample of 237 investment letters during 1980-1992 (15,172 total recommendations) to evaluate newsletter market timing ability. They conclude that:
- Fewer than 35% of the investment letters achieve long-term average returns that beat a matched S&P 500 index/cash buy-and-hold portfolio.
- Newsletters recommend increasing (decreasing) equity weights only 48.8% (51.4%) of the time before market advances (declines).
- Persistence of performance is much more evident among individual investment newsletters than among mutual funds, but this persistence is driven by poor performers. After one year of outperformance (underperformance), there is a 37.3% (67.6%) the newsletter portfolio will outperform (underperform) again the following year. There are 30 cases of outperformance for three consecutive years, compared to 168 cases of underperformance for three consecutive years.
- Disagreement among newsletters regarding future market direction is indicative of future market volatility.
In “The Equity Performance of Investment Newsletters”, Andrew Metrick analyzes the stock recommendations of 145 investment newsletters during 1980-1995. He concludes that:
- In aggregate, the newsletters show no significant evidence of superior stock-picking ability.
- Some individual newsletters exhibit superior performance, but not more often than expected by chance.
- While there is some short-term performance persistence, a strategy of buying past winners does not earn statistically significant excess returns.
The following table, taken from this paper, compares the average (equal-weighted) newsletter performance with the value-weighted market (VWM) return for each year during 1980-1995. It shows that, on average, newsletters underperformed the market in 11 out of 16 years.

In summary, the aggregate market timing ability, positive performance persistence and stock picking ability of investment newsletters are unimpressive.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an investment newsletter and how do researchers evaluate its stock picking and market timing ability?
An investment newsletter is a periodic publication offering stock picks or asset allocation (equity/cash mix) recommendations to subscribers. Researchers evaluate newsletters on stock picking (selecting securities that beat the market) and market timing (shifting equity weights before market advances or declines). Two studies of the Hulbert Financial Digest archive covered 237 newsletters in 1980-1992 and 145 newsletters in 1980-1995.
Do investment newsletters beat the stock market?
Investment newsletters do not beat the market in aggregate. Fewer than 35% of 237 newsletters achieved long-term average returns above a matched S&P 500/cash buy-and-hold portfolio during 1980-1992, and 145 newsletters showed no significant stock-picking ability in 1980-1995. On average, newsletters underperformed the value-weighted market in 11 of 16 years during 1980-1995.
How is the market timing ability of investment newsletters tested?
Graham and Harvey tested newsletter market timing ability by using 15,172 equity/cash mix recommendations from 237 newsletters during 1980-1992, drawn from the Hulbert Financial Digest. They compared newsletter portfolio returns with a matched S&P 500 index/cash buy-and-hold portfolio and checked whether equity weight increases preceded market advances and decreases preceded declines. Metrick separately tested stock picking using the stock recommendations of 145 newsletters during 1980-1995, comparing average newsletter returns with the value-weighted market.
Is investment newsletter performance persistence different from mutual fund performance persistence?
Performance persistence is much more evident among individual investment newsletters than among mutual funds, but it is driven by poor performers. After one year of outperformance, a newsletter has a 37.3% chance of outperforming again, versus a 67.6% chance of underperforming again after a year of underperformance. There were 30 cases of three consecutive years of outperformance versus 168 cases of three consecutive years of underperformance.
Can you profit by buying past winning investment newsletters or following their recommendations?
Following past winning investment newsletters does not reliably generate excess returns. Metrick found some short-term performance persistence, but a strategy of buying past winners did not earn statistically significant excess returns in the 1980-1995 sample. Some individual newsletters outperformed, but not more often than expected by chance, and Graham and Harvey found newsletters recommended higher equity weights before market advances only 48.8% of the time.