Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Evaluating “Retail” Investment Managers

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Individual Investing, Investing Expertise

Key Insight

Two retail investment managers charge 0.9%-2.0% annually plus underlying fund fees, creating substantial return headwinds; combined fees represent approximately one-third of gross returns (9.1% S&P 500; 1951-2006; Bogle data).

Readers recently requested evaluations of two different retail investment managers. Our reviews involve simply putting the information the firms make available on their web sites into the context of broad stock market research. Our findings for the two firms are similar, as follows:

Both of these investment management firms:

1. Serve clients by selecting and buying/selling mutual funds and/or exchange traded funds on their behalf.

2. Provide no specific information on the web regarding their past investing performance.

3. State that they charge clients fees based on a percentage of assets under management, ranging from 0.9% to 2.0% annually, depending on size and type of account. These fees are independent of investment performance and, of course, are in addition to any fees/costs charged by the funds used as investment vehicles.

The following figure illustrates the consequences of the compounded fees noted in the third point above. Using the data from Chart 23 from John Bogle’s May 2006 speech on “What’s Ahead for Stocks and Bonds – And How to Earn Your Fair Share”, we (conservatively) assume that the typical equity mutual fund charges investors 1.5% annually in total fees/costs. Based on the third point above, we assume that the typical “retail” investment manager charges an annual fee of 1.5%. If the investment manager selects for clients mutual funds with an aggregate gross return matching that of the S&P 500 index (an average of 9.1% per year for 1951-2006), the investment manager’s fee represents on average about one sixth of the gross mutual fund return. The combined fees of the investment manager and the mutual fund manager represent on average about one third of the gross mutual fund return. One third is a substantial average return headwind for clients.

Unless an investment manager can consistently pick strongly outperforming funds, an investor would do better by buying and holding a low-fee index fund directly. If the investor’s account is not tax-sheltered, the investment manager may have to generate even greater outperformance to overcome taxes incurred by trading in and out of funds. When deciding whether to use an investment manager, an individual investor should therefore request from candidates actual long-run, after-fee, average performance data and trading activity data.

net

In summary, in the absence of equity investment manager performance data that demonstrates strong and persistent net outperformance of the broad market, individual investors are likely better off buying and holding low-cost index funds directly.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a retail investment manager and how do they charge fees?

A retail investment manager selects and buys or sells mutual funds and/or exchange traded funds on behalf of individual clients. The two firms reviewed charge a percentage of assets under management, ranging from 0.9% to 2.0% annually depending on account size and type. These fees are independent of investment performance and are in addition to the fees charged by the underlying funds.

Are retail investment managers worth the fees compared with buying index funds?

Retail investment managers are likely not worth their fees unless they show strong and persistent net outperformance of the broad market. Assuming a 1.5% manager fee and 1.5% in mutual fund costs, combined fees equal about one third of a 9.1% average gross return (S&P 500, 1951-2006). Absent evidence of consistent outperformance, individual investors are likely better off buying and holding low-cost index funds directly.

How do you calculate how much investment management fees reduce your returns?

The analysis compares annual fees with the gross return of the S&P 500, which averaged 9.1% per year for 1951-2006. It assumes a typical retail manager fee of 1.5% and a typical equity mutual fund total cost of 1.5% (based on John Bogle's May 2006 data). The manager fee equals about one sixth of the gross return, and the combined fees equal about one third.

How does paying an investment manager to pick mutual funds compare with buying a low-cost index fund yourself?

Paying an investment manager to pick mutual funds layers a second fee on top of the underlying fund costs, while buying a low-cost index fund directly avoids the manager fee. Unless the manager can consistently select strongly outperforming funds, the investor would do better holding the index fund directly. In a non-tax-sheltered account, the manager must also overcome taxes generated by trading in and out of funds.

What should I ask an investment manager before hiring them, and what are the risks of not checking?

Investors should request actual long-run, after-fee average performance data and trading activity data from candidate managers. The two firms reviewed provided no specific past performance information on their web sites, so fee drag cannot be weighed against results. The analysis also rests on assumed fee levels (1.5% for both manager and funds) and does not account for taxes beyond noting that trading in non-sheltered accounts raises the outperformance hurdle.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›