Might the relative sizes of the gaps between analyst target and actual prices indicate degrees of current misvaluation? In other words, is a stock with analyst target price twice its current price a better buy than a stock presently at or near its target price? In their February 2006 paper entitled “Target Prices, Relative Valuations and the Premium for Liquidity Provision”, Zhi Da and Ernst Schaumburg investigate the usefulness of relative gaps between target and actual stock prices as an indicator of misvaluations. Using recently issued target prices for about 1,700 stocks each month over the period 1996-2004, they conclude that:
- Target-actual relative price gaps are economically and statistically significant indicators of future returns.
- A sector-neutral portfolio rebalanced monthly to be long S&P 500 stocks with the largest target-actual relative price gaps and short S&P 500 stocks with the smallest gaps earns an average risk-adjusted return of about 2% per month during 1999-2004 before transaction costs.
- Sector neutrality (weighting each sector equally) and monthly rebalancing are critical to this result.
- This strategy works best: (1) for small value stocks; (2) in certain sectors such as consumer discretionary, industrials, materials and financials; and, (3) in the month of January.
- This abnormal return correlates with technical liquidity measures such as the bid-ask spread, price impact and changes in signed trading volume. This correlation indicates that very large or very small target-actual relative price gaps are temporary liquidity phenomena rather than long-term fundamental misvaluations. The liquidity phenomena reflect unusual information asymmetries between expert analysts and the market at large.
The following chart, taken from the paper, shows the average return (in basis points on the vertical axis) by month (on the horizontal axis) for portfolios long S&P 500 stocks with the largest target-actual relative price gaps and short S&P 500 stocks with the smallest gaps. It shows that most of the returns come during the first month as gaps revert to normal. Hence, monthly rebalancing is critical to outperformance.

In summary, analysts are good for identifying the relative value of stocks within sectors in which they are experts, but not for forecasting macro factors that drive sector and overall market movements.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an analyst target-actual price gap?
An analyst target-actual price gap is the relative difference between an analyst's target price for a stock and its current market price. It is used as a possible indicator of misvaluation, such as a stock with a target price twice its current price versus one trading near its target. The Da and Schaumburg (2006) study used recently issued target prices for about 1,700 stocks each month over 1996-2004.
Do analyst target price gaps predict future stock returns?
Analyst target-actual price gaps are economically and statistically significant indicators of future stock returns. A sector-neutral portfolio long S&P 500 stocks with the largest gaps and short those with the smallest gaps earned an average risk-adjusted return of about 2% per month during 1999-2004, before transaction costs. The strategy works best for small value stocks, in sectors such as consumer discretionary, industrials, materials and financials, and in January.
How is a long-short strategy based on analyst price target gaps constructed?
The long-short strategy based on analyst price target gaps is rebalanced monthly to be long S&P 500 stocks with the largest target-actual relative price gaps and short those with the smallest gaps. It is sector-neutral, meaning each sector is weighted equally. Both sector neutrality and monthly rebalancing are critical to the result, since most returns arrive in the first month as gaps revert to normal.
Are large analyst target price gaps a sign of long-term undervaluation or something else?
Large analyst target-actual price gaps appear to reflect temporary liquidity phenomena rather than long-term fundamental misvaluation. The abnormal return correlates with technical liquidity measures such as bid-ask spread, price impact and changes in signed trading volume. The liquidity effects reflect unusual information asymmetries between expert analysts and the broader market.
What are the limitations of trading on analyst price target gaps?
Trading on analyst price target gaps has limits: the roughly 2% monthly risk-adjusted return for 1999-2004 is before transaction costs, and it depends on sector neutrality and monthly rebalancing. Results are strongest in small value stocks, certain sectors and January, so they are not uniform. Analysts appear useful for relative value within sectors they know but not for forecasting macro factors that drive sector and overall market movements.