Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Simple Sector ETF Momentum Strategy Robustness/Sensitivity Tests

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Momentum Investing

Guide Trend Following and Momentum Asset class and ETF momentum

Key Insight

Sector momentum strategy (rotating monthly to highest-return sector among 9 ETFs) shows erratic sensitivity to ranking intervals, with 10-month optimal but only modestly beating equally-weighted benchmark (Dec 1998–Dec 2015; 0.25% friction).

How sensitive is the performance of the “Simple Sector ETF Momentum Strategy” to selecting ranks other than winners and to choosing a momentum ranking interval other than six months? This strategy each month ranks the following nine sector exchange-traded funds (ETF) on past return and rotates to the strongest sector:

Materials Select Sector SPDR (XLB)
Energy Select Sector SPDR (XLE)
Financial Select Sector SPDR (XLF)
Industrial Select Sector SPDR (XLI)
Technology Select Sector SPDR (XLK)
Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR (XLP)
Utilities Select Sector SPDR (XLU)
Health Care Select Sector SPDR (XLV)
Consumer Discretionary Select SPDR (XLY)

Available data are so limited that sensitivity test results may mislead. With that reservation, we perform two robustness/sensitivity tests: (1) comparison of returns for all nine ranks of winner through loser based on a ranking interval of six months and a holding interval of one month (6-1); and, (2) comparison of winner returns for ranking intervals ranging from one to 12 months (1-1 through 12-1) and for a six-month lagged six-month ranking interval (12:7-1) per “Isolating the Decisive Momentum (Echo?)”, all with one-month holding intervals. Using monthly adjusted closing prices for the sector ETFs and SPDR S&P 500 (SPY) over the period December 1998 through December 2015 (205 months), we find that:

All calculations assume that monthly reallocation/rebalancing occurs at the close on the last trading day of each month (assuming that past returns for the ETFs can be calculated for ranking purposes just before the close).

The following chart shows average monthly 6-1 sector momentum strategy gross returns for rank 1 (highest momentum) through rank 9 (lowest momentum) since July 1999, with one standard deviation variability ranges. The chart also shows comparable statistics for an equally weighted, monthly rebalanced (EW) portfolio of the nine sectors as a simple benchmark (representing the value of diversification) and for SPY. Notable points are:

  • Rank 1 has an above average return, and the difference in average returns between ranks 1 and 9 is positive.
  • Average returns do not decline systematically from rank 1 through rank 9. Rank 6 has the lowest average return, and rank 5 has the highest. Ranks 7 and 8 have relatively high average returns.

Results do not compellingly support belief in sector momentum strategy effectiveness.

What happens for ranking intervals other than six months?

sector-ETF-momentum-monthly-stats-by-rank

The next chart shows average monthly net returns for sector momentum strategies 1-1 through 12-1 and 12:7-1 since January 2000 (allowing a 12-month return calculation). The assumed level of trading (switching) friction is 0.25% of the balance for all ranking intervals. Monthly EW portfolio rebalancing is frictionless for conservative benchmarking. Results suggest that:

  • A ranking interval of ten months is optimal over the available sample period. A six-month ranking interval is above the average across ranking intervals.
  • While longer ranking intervals generally outperform shorter ones, the seven-month interval does not work well.
  • Variation across ranking intervals is not systematic, undermining belief in a stable best choice.

The available sample period is short for confident inference. The best ranking intervals may be lucky rather than fundamentally meaningful.

For another perspective, we look at compound annual growth rates (CAGR) across ranking intervals.

sector-ETF-momentum-monthly-stats-by-ranking-interval

The final chart summarizes CAGRs for sector momentum strategies 1-1 through 12-1 and 12:7-1 since December 1999. Results confirm that a ranking interval ten months works best over the sample period. However, 10-1 only modestly beats the frictionless EW benchmark portfolio, which is much less volatile. At the assumed level of trading friction, three ranking intervals lose money.

sector-ETF-momentum-CAGRs-by-ranking-interval

In summary, evidence from momentum rank and ranking interval sensitivity tests for a limited sample offer little support for belief in simple sector ETF momentum strategy effectiveness.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • The performance of the best (worst) ranking/ranking interval incorporates data snooping bias and therefore likely overstates (understates) expected performance.
  • As noted, sample sizes (only 34 independent six-month ranking intervals in the first test and 17 independent 12-month ranking intervals in the second test) are very small for confident inference.
  • The method/parameters derive from research on individual stocks. While arguable that the findings should carry over to ETFs, there might be confounding effects. For example, hedging practices (using a sector ETF to hedge positions in individual stocks from the sector) might affect translation of an anomaly from individual stocks to ETFs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a sector ETF momentum strategy?

A sector ETF momentum strategy ranks sector exchange-traded funds on past return each month and rotates into the strongest performer. The version tested in the article uses nine Select Sector SPDR ETFs (materials, energy, financials, industrials, technology, consumer staples, utilities, health care, consumer discretionary) and holds the top-ranked sector for one month.

Does sector ETF momentum rotation actually beat an equally weighted sector portfolio?

Sector ETF momentum rotation beats an equally weighted sector portfolio only modestly and not reliably. Over December 1998 to December 2015, the best ranking interval (10 months) only modestly outperformed the frictionless equally weighted benchmark, which was much less volatile, and the article concludes the evidence offers little support for the strategy's effectiveness.

How do you test whether a momentum ranking interval works for sector ETFs?

The sector ETF momentum ranking interval is tested by ranking the nine sector ETFs on past returns and holding the winner for one month, then repeating this for ranking intervals from 1 to 12 months plus a lagged 12:7 interval. The article also compared returns across all nine ranks (winner through loser) for a six-month ranking interval. Results use monthly adjusted closing prices, month-end rebalancing, and an assumed 0.25% trading friction, compared against an equally weighted portfolio and SPY.

Is a longer momentum lookback period better than a shorter one for sector rotation?

Longer momentum lookback periods generally outperformed shorter ones for sector rotation in the article's sample, but the pattern was not systematic. A 10-month interval performed best and a six-month interval was above average, yet the seven-month interval did not work well and three ranking intervals lost money after 0.25% friction. This irregular variation undermines belief in a stable best lookback choice.

What are the limitations of backtesting a sector ETF momentum strategy?

Backtests of sector ETF momentum strategies suffer from very small samples, data snooping bias, and uncertain transfer from individual-stock research. The article had only 34 independent six-month ranking intervals and 17 independent 12-month intervals, so the best-performing parameters may be lucky and likely overstate expected performance. Practices such as using sector ETFs to hedge individual stock positions might also confound whether the stock momentum anomaly carries over to ETFs.

Trend Following and Momentum guide

More on asset class and etf momentum

  • Developed Country Stock ETF Momentum? Premium "Developed Country Stock Index Momentum?" summarizes a short paper finding that  MSCI developed country stock market indexes may exhibit exploitable momentum since 1970. However, indexes do…
  • Combining Quality and Momentum ETFs Premium A subscriber asked about the performance of a 50-50 combination of a basket of momentum stock exchange-traded funds (ETF) and a basket of quality…
  • Are Equity Momentum ETFs Working? Premium Are stock and sector momentum strategies, as implemented by exchange-traded funds (ETF), attractive? To investigate, we consider nine momentum-oriented equity ETFs, all currently available,…
  • Treasuries ETFs Momentum Strategy Update/Extension Premium Monthly top-1 momentum rotation among seven Treasury ETFs (BIL, SHY, VTIP, IEI, IEF, TIP, TLT) beat the equal-weighted seven-ETF mix on CAGR in 9…
  • Doing Momentum with Style (ETFs) Premium Top 1 style ETF momentum (monthly hold of the best 6-month performer among six iShares Russell value/growth ETFs) had the highest gross terminal value…

All 391 articles in the Trend Following and Momentum guide

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 18, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›