Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Active Mutual Funds Beat Fair Benchmarks?

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Mutual/Hedge Funds

Key Insight

Top-decile active funds outperformed VFINX by 5.0% annually and earned 3.5% alpha vs passive index factor portfolio (Apr 1993–Mar 2010; 6,814 funds; momentum-sorted deciles, monthly rebalancing).

Have researchers unfairly treated actively managed mutual funds by using non-investable benchmarks? In their February 2012 paper entitled “Another Look at the Performance of Actively Managed Equity Mutual Funds”, David Blitz and Joop Huij evaluate the performance of actively managed equity mutual funds against a set of passively managed market, small capitalization, growth and value index funds rather than modeled risk factors. They select four Vanguard funds as passive benchmarks: 500 Index Investor (VFINX); Small Cap Index Investor (NAESX); Value Index Investor (VIVAX); and, Growth Index Investor (VIGRX). At the beginning of every month, they rank active funds into deciles based on 12-month lagged returns and calculate average fund returns by decile over the next month. They then relate the decile series returns to: (1) the commonly used market, size, book-to-market (value) and momentum factors; and, (2) factor-mimicking combinations of the Vanguard passive index funds. Using monthly returns for those of 6,814 living and dead U.S. equity mutual funds which are not obviously index funds from April 1993 (when all four Vanguard index funds become available) through March 2010, they find that:

  • Relating the passive index funds to the corresponding risk factors:
    • VFINX efficiently captures the overall equity risk (market factor) premium.
    • NAESX fails to capture much of the size factor premium.
    • In tandem, VIVAX and VIGRX do not capture the value factor premium, since these funds have nearly identical average returns.
    • A strategy that each month invests in the one of these four funds with the highest 12-month lagged return fails to capture the momentum factor premium.
  • The top 10% of actively managed mutual funds based on past performance beat the bottom 10% of funds by 8.8% per year, with the momentum factor explaining most of the gap. However, the top decile earns a statistically insignificant four-factor annual alpha of only 1.4%.
  • Relating actively managed mutual funds to the passive index funds, the top 10% of active funds:
    • Beat VFINX by 5.0% per year, with outperformance not attributable to market beta.
    • Earn a significant three-factor annual alpha of 3.5% relative to a portfolio of passive index funds that mimic the market, size and book-to-market factors (driven mostly by NAESX exposure). Incorporating a momentum strategy that each month invests in the passive index fund with the highest return over the past 12 months does not substantially affect this alpha.
    • Beat an equally weighted, monthly rebalanced portfolio of the four passive index funds by 4.3% per year.

In summary, evidence from benchmarking against real investment alternatives rather than factor models does not support belief that investors are better off buying low-cost index funds instead of actively managed mutual funds with strong past performance.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • As confirmed by one of the authors, active fund returns do not account for any loads (front-end and back-end), which may materially reduce net returns to investors. He pointed out that previous research finds similar performance persistence results for funds with and without sales loads, so restricting the active fund universe to no-load only should produce similar results.
  • As confirmed by one of the authors, mutual fund trading restrictions may interfere with any implementation of monthly ranking. He noted that the study is not intended to represent a realistic trading strategy, and that harvesting the potential alpha found remains an open question.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an actively managed equity mutual fund and how does it differ from a passive index fund?

An actively managed equity mutual fund is a fund whose managers select stocks in an attempt to outperform the market, unlike a passive index fund that simply tracks a benchmark. In the Blitz and Huij study, passive benchmarks were four Vanguard index funds covering the market (VFINX), small cap (NAESX), value (VIVAX) and growth (VIGRX), and the active universe was 6,814 living and dead U.S. equity funds that were not obviously index funds, from April 1993 through March 2010.

Do top-performing active mutual funds beat passive index funds?

Top-performing active mutual funds, ranked by past 12-month returns, beat passive index funds in this study. The top decile beat VFINX by 5.0% per year and earned a significant three-factor annual alpha of 3.5% relative to a portfolio of passive index funds (April 1993 to March 2010). The authors conclude the evidence does not support the belief that investors are better off in low-cost index funds than in active funds with strong past performance.

How do researchers test active mutual fund performance against passive index fund benchmarks?

Researchers in this study rank active funds into deciles each month based on 12-month lagged returns and compute average decile returns over the following month. They then relate those returns to (1) market, size, value and momentum factors and (2) factor-mimicking combinations of four Vanguard index funds (VFINX, NAESX, VIVAX, VIGRX). The sample covers 6,814 funds from April 1993 through March 2010.

How does benchmarking against index funds differ from using risk factor models to measure fund alpha?

Benchmarking against index funds yields much higher alpha for top active funds than risk factor models do. Against the four-factor model (market, size, value, momentum), the top decile earned a statistically insignificant annual alpha of only 1.4%, whereas against passive index fund portfolios it earned a significant 3.5%. The difference arises because the Vanguard funds do not fully capture the size, value and momentum factor premiums, notably NAESX on size, and VIVAX and VIGRX on value.

What are the limitations of the finding that active mutual funds outperform index funds?

The finding that top active funds outperform index funds has caveats: the active fund returns do not account for front-end or back-end sales loads, which may materially reduce investor net returns. Mutual fund trading restrictions may also interfere with implementing the monthly ranking strategy. One author noted the study is not meant to represent a realistic trading strategy, and that harvesting the potential alpha remains an open question.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›