Is the media more likely to accentuate the negative when Republicans hold the Presidency? In their October 2004 paper entitled “Is Newspaper Coverage of Economic Events Politically Biased?”, John Lott Jr. and Kevin Hassett of the American Enterprise Institute test for political bias in the economic (durable goods, GDP, retail sales and unemployment) news coverage of American newspapers, after controlling for economic content. Using headlines from a database of newspaper and wire service articles from 389 newspapers covering January 1991 through May 2004 (and back to 1985 for the top ten newspapers: USA Today, Wall Street Journal, New York Times, Los Angeles Times, Washington Post, New York Daily News, New York Post, Chicago Tribune, Newsday and Houston Chronicle), they find that:
- American newspapers tend to report the same economic news more positively when Democrats hold the Presidency. No newspaper shows pro-Republican bias, and the large national newspapers all tend to slant headlines favorably for Democrats.
- Specifically, controlling for economic content, Republican presidents get 20-30% less positive coverage on average from all newspapers and 20-40% less positive coverage from the top ten papers than do Democrats.
- There is no evidence that this bias varies with a President’s approval rating.
- Media coverage relates positively to perceptions about the economy. Partisan bias produces a 7-9% difference in survey respondents viewing the economy as getting better.
- Contrary to popular belief, good economic news generates more coverage than bad news.
In summary, a pro-Democrat/anti-Republican bias in the mainstream media may affect the economic risk perception of some investors/potential investors, thereby affecting stock valuations.
This bias may reflexively offset any perception that Republicans are better for business (and therefore stocks) than are Democrats. Might the migration to online news sources mitigate the impact of mainstream media bias?
A reader sent a note stating that the Media Matters article “AEI study on media bias flawed” refutes the study.
This refutation is not posted within the Social Sciences Research Network.
We contacted Mr. Hassett, who stands by the methodology and conclusions of the paper and regards the Media Matters critique as having no substantive points.
Readers may want to review the entire paper and decide for themselves whether its approach and results are reasonable, and whether the results are meaningful regarding investor sentiment and the behavior of financial markets.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is political bias in newspaper coverage of economic news?
Political bias in newspaper coverage of economic news is a systematic tendency to report the same economic data (such as GDP, unemployment, retail sales and durable goods) more or less favorably depending on which party holds the presidency. Lott and Hassett test for it by comparing headline tone after controlling for the underlying economic content of the news.
Do newspapers report economic news less positively when a Republican is president?
Yes, newspapers report the same economic news less positively under Republican presidents, according to Lott and Hassett's study of 389 newspapers from January 1991 through May 2004. Controlling for economic content, Republican presidents received 20-30% less positive coverage across all newspapers and 20-40% less positive coverage from the top ten papers. No newspaper showed pro-Republican bias, and the bias did not vary with a president's approval rating.
How do researchers test whether newspaper headlines about the economy are politically biased?
Lott and Hassett analyzed headlines from a database of newspaper and wire service articles covering durable goods, GDP, retail sales and unemployment news, while controlling for the economic content of each release. The sample spanned 389 newspapers from January 1991 through May 2004, extending back to 1985 for the top ten newspapers. They then compared headline positivity under Democratic versus Republican presidents and related coverage to survey perceptions of the economy.
Does media bias in economic coverage affect how people and investors perceive the economy and stock valuations?
Media coverage relates positively to perceptions of the economy, and Lott and Hassett find partisan bias produces a 7-9% difference in survey respondents saying the economy is getting better. The article suggests this bias may affect investors' economic risk perceptions and thus stock valuations, possibly offsetting any perception that Republicans are better for business than Democrats. This market link is a suggested implication, not a tested result of the study.
What are the criticisms and limitations of the study on newspaper bias in economic coverage?
The Lott and Hassett study has been criticized by Media Matters as flawed, though that critique is not posted on the Social Sciences Research Network and Hassett says it has no substantive points. The analysis covers only headlines on four economic indicators in a 1991-2004 sample, so it does not directly show effects on investor sentiment or financial market behavior. The article also notes that migration to online news sources might mitigate the impact of mainstream media bias, and encourages readers to review the paper themselves.