Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Left or Right, and Up or Down

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Political Indicators

Key Insight

U.S. stocks outperformed T-bills by 11% under Democratic vs 2% under Republican Presidents (9% difference; 1927-1998; value-weighted returns; 18 Presidential elections), but international evidence shows no such pattern.

Should investors lean toward governments at one end of the country political spectrum to find outperforming equity markets? In their October 2003 paper entitled “The Presidential Puzzle: Political Cycles and the Stock Market”, Pedro Santa-Clara and Rossen Valkanov examine monthly U.S. stock market performance versus executive branch party across 18 Presidential elections (1927-1998, 864 months) encompassing 10 Democratic and 8 Republican Presidencies. In their July 2006 paper entitled “Political Orientation of Government and Stock Market Returns”, Jedrzej Bialkowski, Katrin Gottschalk and Tomasz Wisniewski investigate whether the political orientation of 173 different governments systematically affects the performance of 24 international (mostly European) stock markets. Findings are:

“The Presidential Puzzle: Political Cycles and the Stock Market” concludes that:

  • The broad value-weighted stock market has beaten the 3-month Treasury bill (T-bill) rate by an average of about 11% under Democratic Presidents and just 2% under Republican Presidents — an economically and statistically significant 9% difference. Equal-weighting of stock returns produces a difference of 16%, with small-capitalization stocks strongly outperforming large-capitalization stocks. (See the chart below.)
  • The difference in returns holds for sub-periods 1927-1962 and 1963-1998, and is generally independent of business cycle explanations.
  • The difference in returns is not election-centered. It accumulates gradually across Presidential terms, suggesting it is due to systematic surprises in economic policies.
  • Volatility of returns is somewhat higher during Republican than Democratic Presidencies, indicating that stock market outperformance during the latter is not reward for risk.
  • The party in control of Congress does not indicate significant differences in excess stock market returns.
  • Given the limitations of the data, the impact of party-in-Presidency on the stock market in this study could be a statistical fluke.

The following chart, taken from this paper, shows the average annualized excess (versus the T-bill) value-weighted returns for each Presidential term during 1927-1998. Darker shading denotes Republican Presidencies. The dash-dotted line indicates the the average excess return for the entire period. Democratic (Republican) Presidencies tend toward higher than average (significantly lower than average) excess returns.

In summary, Democratic Presidencies are probably good for the the U.S. stock market.

The authors conjecture that party-in-Presidency affects the stock market through fiscal and regulatory policies.

The approach of this paper assumes two reasonably consistent economic policy regimes, one Democrat and the other Republican, alternately in power across 864 months of stock market returns. However, the sample spans only seven changes in party-in-Presidency. It may be more appropriate simply to test returns from change to change, a very small sample, rather than month to month or term to term. Also, the periods from election to economic policy implementation to economic policy efficacy can be many months, even years, suggesting that economic policy effects substantially lag party-in-Presidency. It is arguable that investors could be eliminating the lag by substantially anticipating policy implementation and effects.

The following chart shows two perspectives of the change in the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) across the seven regimes covered by the paper, plus the balance of the Democrat’s last regime and the to-date part of the current Republican regime. One perspective uses DJIA performance roughly coincident with regimes. The other lags DJIA performance by 12 months, arbitrarily assuming that actionable evidence of policy changes from regime to regime take one year to emerge. Neither the results nor the sample size justify assignment of stock market outperformance to a political party.

“Political Orientation of Government and Stock Market Returns” extends the study of regimes versus stock markets to an international setting, concluding that:

  • There are no statistically significant differences in returns between left-wing and right-wing regimes.
  • Investors do not adjust their discount rates based on election outcomes.
  • International investment strategies based on the political orientation of countries’ leadership are likely to be futile.
  • The anomaly observed in the U.S. appears to be country-specific.

In summary, economic activity generally transcends politics in politically free societies.

This bottom-line conclusion further suggests that the U.S. result may be a fluke.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the presidential puzzle in stock market research?

The presidential puzzle is the finding that U.S. stock market excess returns have differed sharply by the party of the President. In the Santa-Clara and Valkanov study of 18 Presidential elections (1927-1998), the value-weighted market beat the 3-month T-bill by about 11% annually under Democratic Presidents versus about 2% under Republican Presidents. It is called a puzzle because the difference is not explained by business cycle conditions or higher risk.

Do stocks perform better under Democratic or Republican presidents?

In U.S. data for 1927-1998, stocks performed better under Democratic Presidents, with value-weighted excess returns of about 11% versus about 2% under Republicans, a 9% difference. Equal-weighted returns showed a 16% difference, and the gap held in both 1927-1962 and 1963-1998 sub-periods. The article cautions that the result could be a statistical fluke and that the data do not justify assigning outperformance to a political party.

How is the effect of a president's party on stock market returns measured?

The study compares monthly U.S. stock market returns in excess of the 3-month Treasury bill rate across 864 months, covering 10 Democratic and 8 Republican Presidencies from 1927 to 1998. It examines value-weighted and equal-weighted returns, sub-periods, and whether the differences are explained by business cycle variables or concentrated around elections. The difference was found to accumulate gradually across Presidential terms rather than around elections.

Does the U.S. presidential party effect on stocks also appear in other countries with left-wing and right-wing governments?

No, the U.S. presidential party effect does not appear internationally. A study of 173 governments across 24 mostly European stock markets found no statistically significant return differences between left-wing and right-wing regimes. Investors did not adjust discount rates based on election outcomes, suggesting the U.S. anomaly is country-specific and that strategies based on political orientation are likely futile.

What are the limitations of using presidential party to predict stock market returns?

The main limitation of using presidential party to predict stock returns is the small sample, since the 1927-1998 data include only seven changes in party-in-Presidency. Policy effects may also lag elections by months or years, and investors may anticipate policy changes, blurring the timing of any effect. The article suggests the U.S. result may be a fluke, partly because the international evidence shows no similar pattern.

Guru Grades

1,181 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 16, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›