Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

SMAs for Measurement Intervals of Longer Than a Month

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Technical Trading

Key Insight

SMA12M outperformed SMA6B and SMA4Q in return/volatility ratios and terminal values across most start dates (Jan 1993–Apr 2014; SPY vs T-bills; monthly vs bi-monthly vs quarterly measurement intervals; 0.1% switching costs).

In reaction to “10-month Versus 40-week Versus 200-day SMA”, a reader inquired whether using measurement intervals of longer than a month to calculate simple moving averages (SMA) would suppress trading compared to monthly intervals and thereby lower trading frictions and improve performance. To check, we compare the performance of simple moving averages based on 12 months (SMA12M), six bi-months (SMA6B) and four quarters (SMA4Q). SMA6B samples six data points bimonthly, with each measurement spanning 11 months. SMA4Q samples four data points quarterly, with each measurement spanning 10 months. Using monthly dividend-adjusted closes for SPDR S&P 500 (SPY) from inception in January 1993 through April 2014 (about 21 years), along with the contemporaneous monthly 3-month Treasury bill (T-bill) yield, we find that:

For this contest, we make the following rules/assumptions:

  • Buy (sell) SPY at the close when it crosses above (below) its SMA, slightly anticipating signals such that trades occur at the close on the day of the signal (calculations occur just before the close).
  • Cash earns the contemporaneous T-bill yield.
  • Consider three sequential monthly start dates to mitigate the possibility of especially lucky starts for SMA6B and SMA4Q
  • Test sensitivity to one-way trading (switching between SPY and T-bills) frictions ranging from 0.0% to 1.0%, with focus on a baseline 0.1%.
  • Ignore dividend reinvestment frictions and tax implications of trading.

The following chart summarizes average net annual return divided by standard deviation of annual returns (return/volatility) for the three timing rules and for buying and holding SPY applied to samples starting in January, February or March 1993, and the average return/volatility across the three start dates. SMAs beat buy-and-hold for all combinations of rules and start dates. In general, using an SMA12M works better than SMA6B and SMA4Q. 

SMA12M, SMA6B and SMA4Q rules are in SPY 75%, 76% and 74% of the time averaged across the three starting months, respectively.

The January 1993 starting date for SMA4Q appears to be especially lucky, because the rule: (1) rides out the August 1998 crash and so does not miss the rebound; and, (2) rides out May-August 2010 sharp decline and so does not miss the rebound.

For another perspective, we look at terminal values of equal investments.

SMA12M-SMA6B-SMA4Q-return-volatility-ratios

The next chart summarizes average net terminal values for the three timing rules and for buying and holding SPY applied to samples starting in January, February or March 1993, and the average net terminal values across the three start dates. SMAs beat buy-and-hold for 11 of 12 combinations of rules and start dates. In general, using an SMA12M again works better than SMA6B and SMA4Q. 

How often do the three rules switch between SPY and cash?

SMA12M-SMA6B-SMA4Q-terminal-values

The next chart summarizes number of SPY-cash switches for the three timing rules applied to samples starting in January, February or March 1993, and the average number of switches across the three start dates. While both SMA6B and SMA4Q trade on average less frequently than SMA12M, SMA4Q does not trade less frequently than SMA6B.

What happens when we vary the assumed level of switching friction?

SMA12M-SMA6B-SMA4Q-switching-frequencies

The final chart shows how terminal values of the three SMA rules (averages across the three start dates) vary as the assumed level of switching friction ranges from 0.0% to 1.0% in increments of 0.1%. While SMA12M degrades more rapidly than SMA6B and SMA4Q, it is still wins across the entire range of frictions considered. SMA6B wins for switching frictions above about 0.015%.

SMA12M-SMA6B-SMA4Q-switching-friction-sensitivities

In summary, evidence from simple tests does not support belief that an SMA timing rule based on bimonthly or quarterly measurements outperforms a rule based on monthly measurements when applied to the broad U.S. stock market over the past 21 years.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • The sample period is very short in terms of number of bear markets, which drives SMA performance. Instability of SMA4Q rule performance emphasizes this caution.
  • See the discussion at the end of “10-month Versus 40-week Versus 200-day SMA”.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a simple moving average (SMA) timing rule in investing?

A simple moving average (SMA) timing rule is a trend-following strategy that buys an asset when its price crosses above its SMA and moves to cash when the price crosses below. In the article's test, the asset is SPDR S&P 500 (SPY) and cash earns the 3-month Treasury bill yield. The article compares SMAs built from monthly, bi-monthly and quarterly measurement intervals.

Does measuring a moving average bimonthly or quarterly work better than monthly for market timing?

No, bimonthly or quarterly measurement does not outperform monthly measurement for SMA market timing on the broad U.S. stock market. From January 1993 to April 2014, the 12-month SMA (SMA12M) generally beat the six-bi-month (SMA6B) and four-quarter (SMA4Q) SMAs on return/volatility and terminal values. All SMA rules beat buy-and-hold on return/volatility for every start date, and on terminal value for 11 of 12 rule and start-date combinations.

How do you test SMA timing rules with different measurement intervals?

The test uses monthly dividend-adjusted SPY closes from January 1993 through April 2014, with cash earning the 3-month T-bill yield. SMA6B samples six data points bimonthly (spanning 11 months) and SMA4Q samples four data points quarterly (spanning 10 months), versus a 12-month SMA. The rules buy SPY when it crosses above its SMA and sell when it crosses below, using three sequential monthly start dates and a baseline 0.1% one-way switching cost, with sensitivity tested from 0.0% to 1.0%.

Does trading less often with a quarterly or bimonthly SMA reduce costs enough to beat a monthly SMA?

No, trading less often does not make the quarterly or bimonthly SMA beat the monthly SMA in this test. SMA6B and SMA4Q trade less frequently than SMA12M on average, but SMA4Q does not trade less than SMA6B. SMA12M's terminal value degrades faster as switching frictions rise, yet it still wins across the entire 0.0% to 1.0% range.

What are the limitations of backtesting SMA timing rules on the S&P 500 over 21 years?

The main limitation is that the roughly 21-year sample (January 1993 to April 2014) contains very few bear markets, which drive SMA performance. The instability of SMA4Q results underscores this, as its January 1993 start looks especially lucky because it rode out the August 1998 crash and the May-August 2010 decline without missing the rebounds. The tests also ignore dividend reinvestment frictions and tax implications of trading.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›