Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

The Advised, the Non-advised and Frequent Traders

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Individual Investing, Investing Expertise

Key Insight

Advised German investors had slightly higher Sharpe ratios than non-advised (0.90 vs 0.80), but frequent traders drove most underperformance (0.22 Sharpe ratio; Feb 2006–Jul 2007; 65,000 investors).

How do financial advisors affect the investing practices of individual investors? Does their advice decisively improve client performance, or are other factors more explanatory? In their February 2009 paper entitled “The Influence of Financial Advisors on Household Portfolios: A Study on Private Investors Switching to Financial Advice”, Ralf Gerhardt and Andreas Hackethal compare the portfolios and transactions of advised and non-advised German investors to determine the effects of advice. They further decompose the sample of investors to explore whether differences between advised and non-advised arise from the advice per se or from investor socio-demographics or trading frequency. Using portfolio compositions and transactions for over 65,000 German investors during February 2006 through July 2007, including 597 who initiated a relationship with a financial advisor during that period, they conclude that:

  • Advised investors are more likely to be female, old, married, risk-averse, wealthy and rational (have a regular savings plan) than non-advised investors.
  • Advised investors have more diversified portfolios, trade less and have a higher aggregate portfolio Sharpe ratio than do non-advised investors (0.90 versus 0.80).
  • Frequent traders, with aggregate Sharpe ratio 0.22, contribute disproportionately and strongly to the underperformance of non-advised investors. Non-advised investors who are not frequent traders have a higher aggregate Sharpe ratio than advised investors (0.96 versus 0.90).
  • Non-advised investors who match advised investors in terms of socio-demographics have a Sharpe ratio comparable to that of advised investors (0.88 versus 0.90). However, their portfolios are more speculative, less balanced between equity and non-equity, and otherwise less diversified than the portfolios of advised investors. They are also more prone to overtrading.
  • The portfolios of investors just after retaining a financial advisor exhibit relatively high trading activity for restructuring to increase diversification and otherwise lower risk (less home bias and more passive investments). Advisors do not sell expensive products to their customers, but appear to prefer products that involve kickbacks for advisors.

The following chart, constructed from data in the paper, compares the aggregate Sharpe ratios as computed from the last 25 monthly portfolio returns during the sample period for various groups of investors, as follows:

  1. The entire sample of over 65,000 investors.
  2. The subsample of approximately 7,000 advised investors.
  3. The subsample of approximately 58,000 non-advised investors.
  4. The subsample of approximately 12,000 investors who are frequent traders.
  5. The subsample of approximately 46,000 non-advised investors who are not frequent traders.
  6. The subsample of approximately 7,000 non-advised investors who are socio-demographically most like the advised traders.

Results show that trading frequency is the most obvious indicator of risk-adjusted performance. All other Sharpe ratios fall into a fairly tight range.

sharpe ratios

In summary, evidence from this fairly short-term study supports a belief that heavy trading tends to depress risk-adjusted investing performance, but it does not indicate that advised investors outperform similarly motivated non-advised investors.

Might some of the conclusions from this study be peculiar to the state of equity markets during 2006-2007?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a Sharpe ratio and why is it used to compare investor portfolios?

The Sharpe ratio is a measure of risk-adjusted return, used to compare portfolio performance while accounting for risk. In the Gerhardt and Hackethal study of over 65,000 German investors (February 2006 to July 2007), aggregate Sharpe ratios were computed from the last 25 monthly portfolio returns to compare advised, non-advised and frequent-trading investor groups.

Does using a financial advisor improve investment performance for individual investors?

Financial advice does not clearly improve performance once investor characteristics are matched. Advised German investors had a higher aggregate Sharpe ratio than non-advised investors (0.90 versus 0.80), but non-advised investors with similar socio-demographics scored 0.88, comparable to advised investors. Non-advised investors who were not frequent traders scored 0.96, above the advised group.

How do researchers test whether financial advisors actually add value for clients?

Researchers compare portfolios and transactions of advised and non-advised investors, then break the sample into subgroups to separate the effect of advice from socio-demographics and trading frequency. This study used data on over 65,000 German investors from February 2006 to July 2007, including 597 who began working with an advisor during that period. Aggregate Sharpe ratios for each subgroup were computed from the last 25 monthly portfolio returns.

How do frequent traders compare to buy-and-hold investors in risk-adjusted returns?

Frequent traders performed far worse on a risk-adjusted basis, with an aggregate Sharpe ratio of 0.22 versus 0.96 for non-advised investors who were not frequent traders. Trading frequency was the clearest indicator of risk-adjusted performance in the study, while all other groups' Sharpe ratios fell into a fairly tight range. Frequent traders contributed disproportionately to the underperformance of non-advised investors.

What are the limitations of studies comparing advised and non-advised investor performance?

The Gerhardt and Hackethal study is fairly short-term, covering only February 2006 to July 2007, so its conclusions may be peculiar to equity market conditions during 2006-2007. Advised investors also differ systematically from non-advised ones, being more likely to be female, older, married, risk-averse, wealthy and to have regular savings plans, which complicates attributing results to advice itself. The study also found advisors appeared to prefer products involving kickbacks for advisors.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›