Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Sloppy Selling of Expert Traders?

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Investing Expertise

Key Insight

Institutional stock portfolio managers show skillful buying (added positions outperform held stocks by 0.60% over one year) but poor selling (liquidated positions also outperform held stocks by 1.00%); 783 portfolios, 2000-2016.

Do expert investors (institutional stock portfolio managers) add value both by buying future outperforming stocks and by selling future underperforming stocks? In their December 2018 paper entitled “Selling Fast and Buying Slow: Heuristics and Trading Performance of Institutional Investors”, Klakow Akepanidtaworn, Rick Di Mascio, Alex Imas and Lawrence Schmidt examine trade decisions of experienced institutional (e.g., pension fund) stock portfolio managers to determine whether they buy and sell shrewdly. In their main tests, they evaluate: (1) positions added versus randomly buying more shares of some stock already in the portfolio: and, (2) positions liquidated versus randomly selling some other holding that was not traded on that date. Using data for 783 portfolios involving 4.4 million trades (2.0 million sells and 2.4 million buys), and prices for assets held and traded in U.S. dollars, during January 2000 through March 2016, they find that:

  • The average portfolio in the sample:
    • Holds 78 stocks, with standard deviation 68.
    • Turns over about 4% of assets per month, with standard deviation 5.7%.
    • Has market beta about one, and average exposures to size, book-to-market and momentum close to zero.
    • Beats respective benchmarks by 0.22% per month (2.6% per year). Since factor exposures are near zero, this result indicates overall stock-picking skill.
  • Positions added outperform stocks already held by an average 0.60% over one year and 0.87% over two years, indicating skillful buying.
  • However, positions liquidated also outperform stocks already held, by an average 1.00% over one year, indicating adversely biased sell decisions.
  • Expert investors generally pay more attention to buy decisions than sell decisions, as evidenced by decisions coinciding with attention-grabbing firm earnings announcements.
    • Positions liquidated on earnings announcement days (other days) outperform (underperform) stocks already held by about 1.0% (2.0%) over the next year, suggesting inconsistent attention.
    • In contrast, positions added on earnings announcement days perform about the same relative to stocks already held as those added on other days, suggesting consistent attention.
    • Based on interviews with portfolio managers:
      • “Selling is simply a cash raising exercise for the next buying idea.”
      • “Buying is an investment decision, selling is something else.”
      • Many agree that they rush sell decisions in attempting to time buys.
  • In the absence of attention-grabbing news, experts overweight past returns when selling, but not when buying.
    • Experts liquidate both their worst and best performing stocks at rates over 50% higher than stocks with modest past returns. Buys exhibit no such pattern.
    • Experts exhibiting the strongest tendencies to sell based on past extreme returns exhibit the worst selling outcomes.
  • Findings are robust to using risk-adjusted returns and to model changes.

In summary, evidence indicates that expert stock portfolio managers tend to be sloppy when liquidating positions, but not when adding positions.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • Sampled expert investors may have motivations for taking gains/losses other than maximizing future portfolio return.
  • Sampled investors may not be representative of other types of investors.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does sloppy selling mean for institutional stock portfolio managers?

Sloppy selling refers to institutional portfolio managers making poor sell decisions, such as liquidating stocks that go on to outperform the holdings they keep. In a study of 783 institutional portfolios (2000-2016), positions liquidated outperformed stocks already held by an average 1.00% over the following year, indicating adversely biased selling.

Do professional fund managers add value by both buying and selling stocks?

Professional fund managers add value through buying but not through selling. Across 783 institutional portfolios (January 2000 to March 2016), positions added outperformed stocks already held by an average 0.60% over one year and 0.87% over two years, while positions liquidated also outperformed held stocks by 1.00% over one year, which is the opposite of skillful selling.

How do researchers test whether portfolio managers make good buy and sell decisions?

Researchers compare each trade against a random alternative within the same portfolio. Positions added are compared with randomly buying more of a stock already held, and positions liquidated are compared with randomly selling another holding not traded that date. The test used 4.4 million trades (2.0 million sells and 2.4 million buys) across 783 portfolios from January 2000 through March 2016, and the findings held up with risk-adjusted returns and model changes.

Why do portfolio managers pay more attention to buying than selling, and how do their buy and sell behaviors differ?

Portfolio managers treat buying as the investment decision and selling as a cash-raising step for the next buy idea, so buy decisions get more consistent attention. Buys perform about the same whether made on earnings announcement days or other days, while sells made on announcement days outperform held stocks by about 1.0% versus underperforming by 2.0% on other days. Absent attention-grabbing news, managers also overweight past returns when selling, liquidating both their best and worst performers at rates over 50% higher than modest performers, but show no such pattern when buying.

What are the limitations of research on institutional investors' selling skill?

The findings on institutional investors' selling skill carry two main caveats. The sampled managers may have motivations for taking gains or losses other than maximizing future portfolio return, such as raising cash for new buys. They may also not be representative of other types of investors, so the results may not generalize beyond this sample of 783 institutional portfolios.

Guru Grades

1,181 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 16, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›