What are ways to mitigate biases that interfere with rational investment decision-making? In their September 2019 paper entitled “The Psychology of Financial Professionals and Their Clients”, Kent Baker, Greg Filbeck and Victor Ricciardi describe common psychological biases and suggest ways to overcome them. Based on their knowledge and experience, they conclude that:
- A straightforward way to classify biases is:
- Cognitive – deficiencies or limitations in collecting, processing and interpreting information, manifested as: (1) ignoring or minimizing new information that conflicts with a prior belief; and, (2) failing to distinguish between relevant and irrelevant information.
- Emotional – spontaneous and deeply ingrained irrational responses to positive or negative information.
- Cognitive biases are generally more correctable than emotional biases.
- Strategies for mitigating cognitive biases include:
- Confirmation bias – make a list of contrary beliefs by seeking and reflecting on sources that look at things differently.
- Illusion of control bias – explicitly distinguish between controllable and uncontrollable aspects of investing outcomes.
- Hindsight bias – keep a journal of investing decisions and contemplate alternative explanations for outcomes.
- Framing bias – maintain objectivity, focus on total return and risk rather than gains and losses, and consider different perspectives on investments.
- Mental accounting – create a written financial plan that addresses the entire portfolio and translates separate investment buckets into their intended tangible uses.
- Familiarity bias – systematically seek unfamiliar asset classes and strategies for opportunities to increase diversification and reduce risk.
- Strategies for mitigating emotional biases include:
- Overconfidence and overoptimism bias – make decisions deliberately (slowly) and solicit second opinions.
- Loss aversion – recast “sell” decisions as hypothetical “buy” decisions, or use preset rules for when to sell winners and losers.
- Regret aversion – recast opportunities as decisions whether to maintain the status quo, and stick to the investment plan (especially during down markets).
- Status quo bias – adopt periodic portfolio rebalancing rules and/or continually revisit potential benefits of reallocation.
In summary, financial advisors and investors can mitigate psychological biases that lead to suboptimal investment decisions via deliberate, systematic, careful and open-minded planning and execution.
However, note that identification and analysis of financial biases implicitly assume a “rational world” benchmark that specifies optimal investment behaviors. The authors do not make a case that such a benchmark exists or is possible.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are cognitive and emotional biases in investing?
Cognitive biases in investing are deficiencies or limitations in collecting, processing and interpreting information, such as ignoring new information that conflicts with a prior belief or failing to distinguish relevant from irrelevant information. Emotional biases are spontaneous, deeply ingrained irrational responses to positive or negative information. Baker, Filbeck and Ricciardi (September 2019) use this cognitive-versus-emotional split as a straightforward way to classify financial biases.
Can investors actually correct psychological biases that hurt investment decisions?
Investors can mitigate psychological biases through deliberate, systematic, careful and open-minded planning and execution, according to Baker, Filbeck and Ricciardi. They conclude cognitive biases are generally more correctable than emotional biases. This conclusion rests on the authors' knowledge and experience rather than empirical testing.
How do you mitigate confirmation bias, hindsight bias and loss aversion in investing?
Confirmation bias is mitigated by listing contrary beliefs and seeking sources that view things differently, while hindsight bias is addressed by keeping a journal of investing decisions and contemplating alternative explanations for outcomes. Loss aversion, an emotional bias, is addressed by recasting 'sell' decisions as hypothetical 'buy' decisions or by using preset rules for when to sell winners and losers. These strategies come from the authors' experience-based framework, not from tested results.
How do overconfidence and status quo bias differ from framing bias and mental accounting?
Overconfidence and status quo bias are classed as emotional biases, while framing bias and mental accounting are classed as cognitive biases, which are generally easier to correct. Overconfidence is countered by deciding slowly and soliciting second opinions, and status quo bias by periodic rebalancing rules. Framing bias is countered by focusing on total return and risk rather than gains and losses, and mental accounting by a written plan covering the entire portfolio.
What are the limitations of behavioral bias frameworks in investing?
Identifying and analyzing financial biases implicitly assumes a 'rational world' benchmark that defines optimal investment behavior, and Baker, Filbeck and Ricciardi do not make a case that such a benchmark exists or is possible. Their mitigation strategies are also based on the authors' knowledge and experience rather than empirical testing. Emotional biases are additionally harder to correct than cognitive biases.