Objective research to aid investing decisions

Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)

Allocations for April 2024 (Final)

Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)

Allocations for April 2024 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

A Few Notes on A Trader’s First Book on Commodities

| | Posted in: Commodity Futures, Currency Trading

In her 2012 book A Trader’s First Book on Commodities: An Introduction to The World’s Fastest Growing Market (2nd Edition), author Carley Garner hopes to convey “the realization that anything is possible in the commodity markets. Never say ‘never’ — if you do, you will eventually be proven wrong. Additionally, trading the markets is an art, not a science. Unfortunately, there are no black-and-white answers, nor are there fool-proof strategies — but that does not mean that there aren’t opportunities.” Her further hope is that “this book is the first step in your journey toward victory in the challenging, yet potentially rewarding, commodity markets.” Some notable points from the book are:

From the “Introduction” (Page 17): “No ‘best tool’ exists, nor is there only a best way to use the tool. The paramount approach to any trading tool, whether technical, seasonal, or fundamental, is to use it — or better yet, a combination of a few tools — to form an educated opinion in your expectations of market price. With their findings, traders should approach the market with a degree of humbleness and with realistic expectations.”

From Chapter 1, “A Crash Course in Commodities” (Pages 33-35): “The easiest way to understand the spread between the bid and ask is by coming to peace with the fact that there are essentially two market prices at any given time. There is a price at which you can buy the contract (the ask) and one in which you can sell it (the bid). As a retail trader you will always be paying the higher price and selling the lower price… One of the biggest mistakes that I have witnessed beginning traders make is to ignore the repercussions of large bid/ask spreads. …Many beginning traders mistakenly assume that the commission and fees charged to them will depend on the number of order tickets rather than the number of contracts, but this is not the case. …Each round turn is accompanied with exchange fees, minimal NFA (National Futures Association) fees, and possible transaction fees charged by the clearing firm.”

From Chapter 2, “Hedging Versus Speculating” (Page 49): “…speculators in the futures markets enjoy, or perhaps suffer from, a considerable amount of leverage. The source of the leverage stems from low margin requirements set by the exchange to buy or sell futures contracts relative to the actual value of the commodity that is traded.”

From Chapter 3, “The Organized Chaos of Open Outcry and the Advent of Electronic Trading” (Page 55): “Electronic trading is now offered nearly 24 hours per day in most futures markets.”

From Chapter 4, “Account Access, Trading Platforms, and Quote Vendors” (Pages 64, 74): “…to gain access to real-time quotes and charts, a trader must either subscribe to a quote vending service or utilize a trading platform that offers a live data feed, most of which require subscription fees. …In many cases I recommend that traders use an affordable platform upgrade if the free platforms provided by their brokerage firms lack in terms of real-time quotes.”

From Chapter 5, “Choosing a Brokerage Firm” (Page 95): “…you should be researching brokerage firms and prospective brokers nearly as much as you research the markets.”

From Chapter 6, “Finding a Broker That Fits and Choosing a Service Level” (Pages 100-101): “You might be disappointed to discover that the only requirement to becoming a commodity broker is a passing score on a proficiency exam…the hurdle seems to be low considering the responsibilities that come with passing the test…visit www.NFA.Futures.org to research your choice.”

From Chapter 8, “Making Cents of Commodity Quotes” (Page 131): “…becoming comfortable with commodity quotes and calculating profit and loss in each market is even more critical than accurate market speculation. …each commodity contract has its own set of rules.”

From Chapter 9, “Figuring in Financial Futures — Stock Indices, Interest Rates, and Currencies” (Page 159): “…in both the futures and options markets, contracts with expirations other than the front month have dramatically lower liquidity. This is especially true in the case of the futures contract. Therefore, in most circumstances futures traders should avoid trading distant month contracts because the lack of liquidity creates large bid/ask spreads… I have found that beginning traders interested in holding a position for a considerable amount of time often want to trade in a back month to avoid the hassle and costs involved in rolling into the next contract month. In my opinion, this is destructive behavior…”

From Chapter 11, “The Only Magic in Trading — Emotional Stability” (Page 201): “In my years as a broker, I have come across droves of retail and institutional traders and just as many trading strategies and methodologies. I have yet to discover any individual system or style that is capable of making money in all market conditions all of the time. …In other words, there is no Holy Grail or easy money. …If you are looking for magic, go to Disneyland…”

From Chapter 12, “Trading Is a Business — Have a Plan” (Pages 212-213): “…one of the most important characteristics of a profitable trader is the ability to adapt to ever-changing market conditions. Being nimble is key; being stubborn is detrimental. …Although trading systems, as opposed to trading plans that can be modified, have grown in popularity due to technological advances and the availability of such system software to the general public, the odds of success facing retail traders hasn’t seemed to improve. This leads me to believe that..significant challenges stand in the way of creating a profitable trading model.”

From Chapter 13, “Why You Should Speculate in Futures” (Page 237): “…the convenience of gaining leverage and the ability to quickly buy and sell trading instruments in any order creates an extremely efficient means of betting on anticipated price changes. Also, the tax benefits of profitable speculation in commodities, as compared to equities, are dramatic and can potentially have a profound impact on the overall results.”

Principal differences between the first and second editions include incorporation of lessons/implications from the failures of PFGBEST and MF Global and updates on industry practices.

Per its title, the book is entry level. It does not describe or cite formal research on commodity futures trading strategies. For example, the book does not cover the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s Commitments of Traders (COT) reports as a means to measure hedging pressure. Nor does it address strategies based on roll return or momentum.

In summary, Carly Garner’s A Trader’s First Book on Commodities is a well-calibrated introduction (as advertised) to trading commodity futures and options, but readers will have to dig deeper for robust investigations of trading strategies.

Daily Email Updates
Filter Research
  • Research Categories (select one or more)