Objective research to aid investing decisions

Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)

Allocations for June 2024 (Final)

Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)

Allocations for June 2024 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Good Deals in Broad Market Index Options?

| | Posted in: Equity Options

Are investors on average overly fearful/greedy regarding overall stock market volatility, and therefore willing to overpay for insurance/leverage in the form of broad market index options? If so, what reliable strategies could a trader use to exploit this fear and capture the overpayments? In their January 2006 paper entitled “Option Strategies: Good Deals and Margin Calls”, Pedro Santa-Clara and Alessio Saretto investigate potential mispricings of S&P 500 index options and a range of trading strategies that might exploit those mispricings. Using daily S&P 500 index options data from the Chicago Mercantile Exchange for January 1985-May 2001 and from the Chicago Board Options Exchange for January 1996-May 2004, they conclude that:

  • Downside protection (via puts) generally costs more than upside leverage (via calls).
  • In general, the best strategies involve buying far-maturity calls, selling near-maturity calls and holding only short positions in puts. For example, shorting straddles and strangles yields annualized Sharpe ratios of about 2 (without transaction costs and margin calls). These results are significant even if market crashes occur more frequently than seen in the sample data.
  • Transaction costs, driven mostly by large bid-ask spreads, severely reduce the Sharpe ratios of option strategies.
  • Margin calls negatively impact trading strategies in three ways: (1) they limit the size of short positions; (2) they force investors out of trades at the worst times; and, (3) they force more trading, thereby exacerbating transaction costs.
  • With transaction costs and margin calls, the annualized Sharpe ratio of shorting near-maturity, out-of-the-money strangles decreases from 1.83 to 0.16.

In summary, investors/traders are generally willing to overpay for insurance and leverage via options, but only the market makers can consistently exploit this willingness.

Daily Email Updates
Filter Research
  • Research Categories (select one or more)