Is risk premium variation principally a consequence of changes in objective business conditions, or is some human dynamic important? In their November 2007 paper entitled “Diverse Beliefs and Time Variability of Risk Premia”, Mordecai Kurz and Maurizio Motolese examine the effect of diverse but individually rational market beliefs on risk premiums. They define belief as a variable independent of all observed fundamentals, with its own dynamic that reflects changes in the distribution of investor risk perceptions. Using monthly interest rate forecasts compiled by Blue Chip Financial Forecasts since 1983 to measure market beliefs and associated actual interest rate data, they conclude that:
- Fluctuations in market beliefs, above and beyond the effect of business cycles, make significant contributions to risk premium variability.
- The market belief component of the mean risk premium for such assets as Federal Funds Futures and 3-month and 6-month Treasury bills frequently exceeds 50% of the premium for horizons of one to 12 months.
- The shorter the horizon, the greater the influence of market belief. Market belief dominates economic fundamentals in forming the premium for horizons of less than two months.
- Investor optimism (pessimism) about future economic conditions depresses (elevates) the risk premium, supporting “bull” (“bear”) market conditions.
- An increase in diversity of market opinions decreases the risk premium because markets
with more diverse beliefs are more stable. Conversely, markets with a high degree of unanimity are more risky because small changes in market belief cause sharp price changes as many investors try to execute similar trades.
The following table, taken from the paper, summarizes the explanatory power (R-squared statistic) of market beliefs for excess returns on Federal Funds Rate futures, 3-month Treasury bills and 6-month Treasury bills over various horizons (“h” in months). The table shows that the predictive power of market beliefs declines with the forecasting horizon and dominates that of macroeconomic fundamentals for short holding periods.

In summary, perceptions move markets. Market beliefs, which may express mistaken forecasts, are at least as important to asset pricing as macroeconomic fundamentals.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the belief component of a risk premium?
The belief component of a risk premium is the part of the premium driven by diverse but individually rational market beliefs, defined by Kurz and Motolese as a variable independent of all observed fundamentals with its own dynamic. It reflects changes in the distribution of investor risk perceptions rather than objective business conditions.
Do market beliefs explain variation in risk premiums on Treasury bills and Federal Funds futures?
Market beliefs do explain a large share of risk premium variation, frequently exceeding 50% of the mean premium on Federal Funds Futures and 3-month and 6-month Treasury bills at horizons of one to 12 months. Their influence grows as the horizon shortens and dominates economic fundamentals at horizons under two months. This is based on Blue Chip Financial Forecasts data since 1983.
How are market beliefs measured when testing their effect on risk premiums?
Kurz and Motolese measure market beliefs using monthly interest rate forecasts compiled by Blue Chip Financial Forecasts since 1983, and compare them with actual interest rate data. They then use R-squared statistics to gauge how well beliefs explain excess returns on Federal Funds Rate futures and 3-month and 6-month Treasury bills over various holding horizons.
How do investor optimism and diversity of opinion affect risk premiums compared with unanimity?
Investor optimism depresses the risk premium, supporting bull markets, while pessimism elevates it, supporting bear markets. Greater diversity of market opinion lowers the risk premium because such markets are more stable, whereas high unanimity raises risk because small belief changes trigger sharp price moves as many investors trade similarly.
What are the caveats of attributing risk premium changes to market beliefs rather than fundamentals?
The explanatory power of market beliefs declines as the forecasting horizon lengthens, so beliefs dominate macroeconomic fundamentals only for short holding periods, under two months. Beliefs may also express mistaken forecasts, and the findings rest on one belief proxy (Blue Chip forecasts) and interest-rate-related assets since 1983, so they may not generalize to other assets.