Is there a single variable based on accounting data that reliably captures expected returns of individual stocks? In their October 2018 paper entitled “A Fundamental Factor Model”, Stephen Penman and Julie Zhu construct and test a fundamental expected returns factor based on array of accounting inputs, encompassing earnings, book value and items that sum to these income statement and balance sheet totals. They focus on a robust version of this factor incorporating eight of these inputs (ER8), but consider simpler versions relying on only four (ER4) or two (ER2) inputs. They calculate a premium based on a portfolio that is each month long (short) the equally weighted stocks of firms ranked in the top (bottom) three tenths, or deciles, of the fundamental factor. They update fundamentals yearly three months after firm fiscal year ends from numbers published in annual financial statements. In terms of smart beta terminology, their approach replaces market capitalization weights with fundamentals weights. Using monthly returns and annual financial statements for a broad sample of non-financial U.S. common stocks during April 1981 (or June 1975 or April 1966 for simplified factors) through December 2015, they find that:
- ER8 is related to earnings growth expectations and risks associated with those expectations.
- ER8 relates slightly negatively to the market factor, strongly positively to the conventional HML (high minus low book-to-market ratio) factor and positively to investment factors used in other models.
- ER8 works well in explaining contemporaneous cross-sectional stock returns and, moreover, generates significant alphas relative to returns explained by the most widely used models that employ three, four or five factors (indicating incremental information).
- ER8 works well in predicting next-month cross-sectional stock returns. Specifically:
- Excluding microcaps (bottom 20% of NYSE market capitalizations), ER8 generates average monthly gross premium 0.57% and annualized gross Sharpe ratio 0.73, among the highest of widely accepted stock factors.
- Using simplified versions ER4 and ER2 lowers average monthly gross premiums to 0.48% and 0.36% and annualized gross Sharpe ratios to 0.61 and 0.37, respectively.
- Including microcaps boosts ER8 average monthly gross premium to 0.793% and annualized gross Sharpe ratio to 1.17.
- Since ER8 has approximately zero market beta, the 2-factor market-ER8 model of stock returns combines a mean-variance efficient portfolio with a portfolio that hedges consumption and investment risks.
In summary, evidence indicates that a robust fundamental expected returns factor based on eight accounting inputs may be useful and comprehensive for screening U.S. stocks.
Cautions regarding findings include:
- Reported factor premiums are gross, not net. Accounting for the trading frictions associated with factor portfolio rebalancing and shorting costs would reduce these premiums. Moreover, shorting of some stocks as specified may be costly/infeasible due to lack of shares to borrow. Equal weighting of ERx factor portfolios exacerbates this concern.
- The approach is beyond the reach of many investors, who would bear fees for delegating to an investment/fund manager.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a fundamental expected returns factor in stock investing?
A fundamental expected returns factor is a single variable built from accounting data, such as earnings, book value and the items that sum to those totals, that aims to capture the expected returns of individual stocks. The ER8 version uses eight accounting inputs, with simpler versions using four (ER4) or two (ER2). Fundamentals are updated yearly, three months after each firm's fiscal year ends.
Does the ER8 fundamental factor predict stock returns?
The ER8 fundamental factor predicts next-month cross-sectional stock returns well in a sample of broad U.S. non-financial stocks through December 2015. Excluding microcaps, a long-short portfolio earned an average gross premium of 0.57% per month and an annualized gross Sharpe ratio of 0.73, among the highest of widely accepted factors. ER8 also generated significant alphas relative to three-, four- and five-factor models, indicating incremental information.
How is the ER8 fundamental factor portfolio constructed and tested?
The ER8 factor portfolio is each month long the equally weighted stocks in the top three deciles of the factor and short those in the bottom three deciles. Fundamentals come from annual financial statements and are updated yearly three months after fiscal year end. Tests use monthly returns for U.S. non-financial common stocks from April 1981 (or June 1975 or April 1966 for the simplified factors) through December 2015.
How does the ER8 factor compare to the simpler ER4 and ER2 factors and to the HML value factor?
ER8 outperforms the simpler versions: excluding microcaps, its average monthly gross premium is 0.57% with a Sharpe ratio of 0.73, versus 0.48% and 0.61 for ER4 and 0.36% and 0.37 for ER2. ER8 is strongly positively related to the conventional HML (book-to-market) factor, positively related to investment factors, and slightly negatively related to the market factor. Its approximately zero market beta means a market-ER8 two-factor model combines a mean-variance efficient portfolio with a portfolio hedging consumption and investment risks.
What are the limitations and risks of using the ER8 fundamental factor in practice?
The ER8 factor premiums are reported gross, so trading frictions from rebalancing and shorting costs would reduce them. Shorting some stocks may be costly or infeasible due to lack of shares to borrow, and equal weighting of the factor portfolios exacerbates this concern. The approach is also beyond the reach of many investors, who would bear fees for delegating to an investment or fund manager.