Do smart beta indexes efficiently exploit factor premiums? In his April 2016 paper entitled “Factor Investing with Smart Beta Indices”, David Blitz investigates how well smart beta indexes, which deviate from the capitalization-weighted market per mechanical rules, capture corresponding factor portfolios. He consider five factors: value, momentum, low-volatility, profitability and investment. He measures their practically exploitable premiums via returns on long-only value-weighted or equal-weighted portfolios of the 30% of large-capitalization U.S. stocks with the most attractive factor values. He tests six smart beta indexes:
- Russell 1000 Value.
- MSCI Value Weighted.
- MSCI Momentum.
- S&P Low Volatility.
- MSCI Quality.
- MSCI High Dividend.
Using monthly data for the five factor portfolios and the six smart beta indexes as available through December 2015, he finds that:
- For the factor portfolios:
- An equally weighted combination of value-weighted value, momentum and low-volatility factor portfolios has gross annualized Sharpe ratio 0.49, compared to 0.32 for the capitalization-weighted market portfolio.
- Using equal-weighted rather than value-weighted factor portfolios boosts this Sharpe ratio to 0.58
- Adding profitability and investment factor portfolios to the combination does not improve these Sharpe ratios, but does improve performance relative to the market.
- In general, the smart beta indexes track the capitalization-weighted market more closely than do the factor portfolios (see the chart below). Specifically, annualized tracking errors during 2001 through 2015 range from:
- About 2% for value indexes to about 5% for MSCI Momentum across the six smart beta indexes.
- 3% to 8% across the five value-weighted factor portfolios.
- 5% to 9% across the five equal-weighted factor portfolios.
- Value-weighted factor exposures and factor focuses for the smart beta indexes vary considerably.
- Russell 1000 Value has the largest value factor exposure (still only 36%) and some exposures to the investment (21%) and low-volatility (20%) factors.
- MSCI Value Weighted has only 29% exposure to the value factor.
- MSCI Momentum loads heavily on the momentum factor (73%).
- S&P Low Volatility loads heavily on the low-volatility factor (71%).
- MSCI Quality loads heavily on the profitability factor (76%).
- MSCI High Dividend loads very heavily on the low-volatility factor (83%), with some exposure to the value factor. In other words, MSCI High Dividend is largely redundant with S&P Low Volatility.
- Only S&P Low Volatility loads heavily on an equal-weighted factor portfolio in preference to a value-weighted factor portfolio. In other words, most smart beta indexes do not capture higher equal-weighted factor premiums.
The following chart, taken from the paper, summarizes annualized tracking errors relative to the capitalization-weighted market for the six smart beta indexes, the five value-weighted factor portfolios and the five equal-weighted factor portfolios as described above during January 2001 through December 2015. The smart beta indexes are generally much more like the broad market than are the factor portfolios.

In summary, evidence suggests that smart beta indexes capture only parts of corresponding factor premiums, and ostensibly similar smart beta indexes may have different capture efficiencies.
Cautions regarding findings include:
- In general, returns associated with smart beta indexes and factor portfolios are gross, not net. Trading frictions associated with maintaining the stock weights they specify in real portfolios may differ substantially, such that net findings would differ from gross findings.
- Testing many indexes/factor portfolios on the same set of data introduces snooping bias, such that the best performances overstate expectations.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a smart beta index in investing?
A smart beta index is an index that deviates from the capitalization-weighted market according to mechanical rules, usually to capture a factor premium such as value, momentum, low volatility, profitability or investment. The article examines six examples: Russell 1000 Value, MSCI Value Weighted, MSCI Momentum, S&P Low Volatility, MSCI Quality and MSCI High Dividend.
Do smart beta indexes capture factor premiums efficiently?
Smart beta indexes capture only parts of the corresponding factor premiums, and ostensibly similar indexes may differ in capture efficiency. Over 2001-2015, the six indexes tracked the capitalization-weighted market more closely than factor portfolios did. Most also failed to capture the higher premiums of equal-weighted factor portfolios.
How are factor portfolios built and compared with smart beta indexes?
Factor portfolios are long-only, value-weighted or equal-weighted portfolios of the 30% of large-capitalization U.S. stocks with the most attractive values on a factor. The five factors are value, momentum, low volatility, profitability and investment. Monthly returns through December 2015 are used to compare these portfolios with six smart beta indexes through annualized tracking error versus the capitalization-weighted market and through factor exposures.
How do smart beta indexes compare with pure factor portfolios in tracking error and factor exposure?
Smart beta indexes have lower tracking errors versus the market than factor portfolios do. For 2001-2015, annualized tracking errors were about 2% (value indexes) to about 5% (MSCI Momentum) for the indexes, 3% to 8% for value-weighted factor portfolios, and 5% to 9% for equal-weighted ones. Factor exposures also vary: Russell 1000 Value has only 36% value exposure, while MSCI High Dividend loads 83% on low volatility and is largely redundant with S&P Low Volatility.
What are the limitations of the evidence on smart beta index performance?
The returns for smart beta indexes and factor portfolios are gross, not net, so trading frictions from maintaining the specified stock weights could change the findings substantially. Testing many indexes and factor portfolios on the same data also introduces snooping bias, so the best performances overstate expectations. The evidence covers six indexes and five factors, mostly over 2001-2015.