Are cryptocurrencies potentially useful portfolio diversifiers? In their November 2017 paper entitled “Exploring the Dynamic Relationships between Cryptocurrencies and Other Financial Assets”, Shaen Corbet, Andrew Meegan, Charles Larkin, Brian Lucey and Larisa Yarovaya apply a battery of tests to analyze relationships: (1) among three cryptocurrencies; and, (2) between the cryptocurrencies and conventional asset classes. They consider cryptocurrencies with market values over $1B at the end July 2017: Bitcoin, Ripple and Litecoin. They consider equities (S&P 500 Index), bonds (Markit ITTR110), commodities (S&P GSCI Total Returns Index), currencies (U.S. Dollar Broad Index), gold (COMEX close) and S&P 500 implied volatility (VIX) as conventional asset classes. Using daily data for Bitcoin, Ripple and Litecoin and for conventional asset classes as specified during April 29, 2013 through April 30, 2017, they find that:
- Cryptocurrencies are highly volatile compared to conventional asset classes. In particular, cryptocurrencies are highly sensitive to changes in regulation, existence/effectiveness of an exchange market and technological/hacking failures.
- Cryptocurrencies are largely isolated from all other asset classes. It therefore appears that external financial market conditions are less important for cryptocurrency pricing than are internal issues of design, operation and clearing.
- Cryptocurrencies are substantially interconnected. For example, Bitcoin price affects Ripple and Litecoin prices, particularly during Bitcoin price surges. In view of the isolation of cryptocurrencies from other asset classes, this interconnectedness suggests speculation.
- Findings suggest that cryptocurrencies can be useful as a portfolio diversifier, and can offer investors a safe haven.
In summary, evidence suggests that cryptocurrencies comprise a new asset class, potentially (but with considerable risk) useful as a diversifier of conventional asset classes.
Cautions regarding findings include:
- The available sample is short, arguably encompassing a time of cryptocurrency market immaturity.
- As noted, cryptocurrency values exhibit high susceptibilities to perturbation by regulators.
- As noted, cryptocurrencies may be illiquid, especially during crises.
See also “What Kind of Asset Is Bitcoin?” and “Bitcoin Return Distribution”.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does it mean to call cryptocurrencies a separate asset class?
Calling cryptocurrencies a separate asset class means they behave differently from conventional assets such as equities, bonds, commodities, currencies and gold. In the study of Bitcoin, Ripple and Litecoin (April 2013 to April 2017), cryptocurrencies were largely isolated from these conventional asset classes, and the authors concluded they comprise a new asset class, potentially useful as a diversifier but with considerable risk.
Can cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin diversify a portfolio of stocks and bonds?
Cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, Ripple and Litecoin appear potentially useful as portfolio diversifiers, according to a study using daily data from April 29, 2013 through April 30, 2017. They were largely isolated from the S&P 500, bonds, commodities, the U.S. dollar, gold and VIX, and the authors suggest they can also offer a safe haven. This conclusion comes with considerable risk because cryptocurrencies are highly volatile.
How do researchers test the relationship between cryptocurrencies and traditional assets?
Researchers applied a battery of tests to daily data to examine relationships among Bitcoin, Ripple and Litecoin and between those cryptocurrencies and conventional assets. The cryptocurrencies were those with market values over $1B at the end of July 2017, and the conventional assets were the S&P 500 Index, Markit ITTR110 bonds, the S&P GSCI Total Returns Index, the U.S. Dollar Broad Index, COMEX gold and the VIX. The sample ran from April 29, 2013 through April 30, 2017.
Are cryptocurrency prices driven by the same factors as stocks and other financial assets?
Cryptocurrency prices do not appear to be driven by the same factors as conventional financial assets, since cryptocurrencies were largely isolated from all other asset classes in the study. External financial market conditions seem less important for cryptocurrency pricing than internal issues of design, operation and clearing. Cryptocurrencies were, however, substantially interconnected with one another, as Bitcoin prices affected Ripple and Litecoin prices, particularly during Bitcoin price surges, which suggests speculation.
What are the risks and limitations of using cryptocurrencies as a portfolio diversifier?
The risks of using cryptocurrencies as a diversifier include high volatility compared to conventional assets and high sensitivity to regulation, exchange market existence and effectiveness, and technological or hacking failures. The study's sample (April 2013 to April 2017) is short and arguably covers a period of cryptocurrency market immaturity. Cryptocurrencies may also be illiquid, especially during crises.