Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Impossibly Good?

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Technical Trading

Key Insight

Swing-Trading.net claims 200 trades with no losers using theoretical gains based on perfect exit timing at maximum prices within 10 days, which the post describes as having vanishingly small probability of real achievement.

A reader asked: “The performance on Swing-Trading.net must have 200 trades, and no losers. How is that possible?”


The returns presented at Swing-Trading.net appear to be theoretical gains based on perfect foresight and perfect execution (and no trading frictions), assuming exit at the maximum price (minimum price for short sales) during the ten days after entry.

The probability of achieving such perfection is vanishingly small (in other words, zero). Such information does not represent a realistic way to evaluate performance and places a large burden on prospective subscribers to determine whether the trade advice is good or bad. Determination would require development of realistic trade exit rules, modeling of realistic trading frictions and collection of detailed historical price data for each trade.

See “Steve Sarnoff’s Advice at the ‘Options Hotline'” for a sense of how hard it is to get a realistic read on such information.


Sinisa Persich, CEO of Swing-Trading.net and Traderhr.com, commented: “In this article you comment my performance but you didn’t mention that presented results are not exit price. This just shows max potential of our recommendation in a period of 10 days. For detailed results visitors must sign up for our free newsletter and than they receive detailed results. Can you please correct this in your article because someone who read this could receive wrong information about results. Here you can found detailed results at [performance data for members] . Performance doesn’t include brokerage fees.”

Response:

The above reply to the reader’s question, per your message, correctly and clearly interprets the publicly presented performance data, which is essentially uninformative.

As of 2/21/10, the performance data for members on the web page you cite lists 230 trades apparently spanning one year. Some metrics for these trades are:

  • There are an average of 19.5 trades per month
  • The average gross profit per trade is 0.42%.
  • About 59% of trades are profitable based on gross profits.

After incorporating reasonable trading frictions and accounting for open positions not listed, this sample may be market-underperforming and even unprofitable on both net per-trade and net portfolio levels for the typical investor. Trading frictions for individuals trading on advice depend on broker transaction fees, bid-ask spread (depending whether the advisor specifies limit prices) and position size. More concurrent positions translates to smaller position sizes and higher percentage trading friction. Bid-ask spreads are generally higher for stocks with relatively low trading volumes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is theoretical maximum-potential performance in trading advice?

Theoretical maximum-potential performance is a return calculation that assumes perfect foresight and perfect execution, with exit at the best price (the maximum for longs, the minimum for short sales) within a set window, such as ten days after entry. It ignores trading frictions. Swing-Trading.net's publicly presented results were of this type, showing the maximum potential of each recommendation rather than actual exit prices.

Can a swing trading service really have 200 trades with no losers?

A swing trading service showing 200 trades with no losers is not a realistic performance record, because the public results were theoretical gains based on perfect exit timing. The probability of achieving such perfection in practice is vanishingly small, effectively zero. Swing-Trading.net's members-area data, covering 230 trades over about one year as of 2/21/10, showed only about 59% of trades profitable on a gross basis.

How are swing trading performance results calculated from maximum price within 10 days?

The publicly presented Swing-Trading.net results assume exit at the maximum price (minimum for short sales) reached during the ten days after entry, with no trading frictions. Evaluating real performance instead requires realistic trade exit rules, modeling of trading frictions, and detailed historical price data for each trade. The members-area data, by contrast, reported 230 trades with an average gross profit of 0.42% per trade and 19.5 trades per month.

How do gross trade profits compare to net returns after trading costs for an individual investor?

Gross profits ignore brokerage fees, bid-ask spreads and position-size effects, so net returns for an individual investor can be much lower. In the Swing-Trading.net sample, an average gross profit of 0.42% per trade may become market-underperforming or even unprofitable on net per-trade and net portfolio levels after reasonable frictions and accounting for unlisted open positions. The company confirmed its performance does not include brokerage fees.

What are the limitations of evaluating a trading advisory service from its published performance data?

Published advisory performance can be uninformative if it shows theoretical rather than realized exits, as Swing-Trading.net's public data did, placing a large burden on prospective subscribers to judge the advice. Trading frictions also depend on broker fees, bid-ask spreads (higher for low-volume stocks) and position size, and more concurrent positions mean smaller positions and higher percentage friction. The members-area sample also omitted open positions and excluded brokerage fees, further limiting its reliability.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 18, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›