Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

What About KeyTurningDates.com?

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Individual Gurus

Key Insight

CXO Advisory found insufficient information to evaluate KeyTurningDates.com claims of "amazing accuracy" in market timing, with no verifiable past forecasts, performance data, or complete signal history available for analysis.

A reader asked: “Have you evaluated the newsletter at KeyTurningDates.com by Stephen Campbell?”


The offeror is Stephen Carpenter, not Stephen Campbell. There is not much information on the site:

The home page claims that the “KeyTurningDates Tutorial” provides “discoveries for timing any market, any individual stock, in any timeframe, with amazing accuracy!” The site disclaimer states: “The information on this website and in the KeyTurningDates.com monthly letters, the interim reports, or in any other correspondence, either written or oral…carries no warranty, either express or implied.” In other words, the offeror claims but does not warrant “amazing accuracy.” Confirmation bias and monetary incentive suggest that one should not rely solely on an offeror’s claims of past accuracy or an offeror’s presentation of favorable testimonials as proof of value.

Since the “Past Forecasts” page provides no past forecasts or links to any past forecasts, it is not possible to evaluate the “forecasts.”

The “Samples” page does not provide enough information for reliable inference.

There is not enough information on the “‘Old Reliable’ Cycle” page to determine whether the dates were predicted out of sample or extracted retrospectively. If predicted, there is not enough information to tell what signals the service gave at the time. There is not enough information to tell whether the cycle methodology generated spurious signals.

Evidence that would be useful in evaluating the offeror’s claims includes:

  • Posting for free review a complete set of obsolete newsletters on the site. Complete information on expired signals would likely support analysis of the statistical strength and economic value of those signals.
  • Posting for free review the offeror’s investment performance based on the signals given in the newsletter. Since the offeror’s methods enable timing “in any timeframe, with amazing accuracy,” his investment performance should be amazingly good and amazingly consistent.

It is reasonable to question why someone who should be amazingly wealthy (if his claims are accurate) would bother with the effort of writing and administering retail sales of reports and newsletters.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is market timing and what are key turning dates in investing?

Market timing is the attempt to shift investments into or out of markets, sectors, or individual stocks based on predicted price turning points. KeyTurningDates.com is a newsletter service that claims its cycle-based methods can time any market, any individual stock, and any timeframe 'with amazing accuracy.' The article notes these claims are not warranted by the site's own disclaimer.

Does KeyTurningDates.com market timing really work with amazing accuracy?

KeyTurningDates.com's claim of 'amazing accuracy' in market timing cannot be verified, because the site provides insufficient information to evaluate it. The 'Past Forecasts' page contains no past forecasts or links to any, and the 'Samples' page lacks enough detail for reliable inference. The site's disclaimer also states that its information carries no warranty, express or implied.

How can you test whether a market timing newsletter's signals are accurate?

Testing a market timing newsletter's signals requires a complete set of past signals, including expired ones, so their statistical strength and economic value can be analyzed. It also requires the offeror's actual investment performance based on those signals. For KeyTurningDates.com, the article says posting all obsolete newsletters and performance data for free review would support such evaluation, and neither is currently available.

Is an out-of-sample market timing forecast the same as a retrospectively identified cycle date?

An out-of-sample forecast is not the same as a retrospectively identified cycle date, because dates extracted after the fact can look accurate without having predictive value. For KeyTurningDates.com's 'Old Reliable' Cycle, the article says there is not enough information to determine whether the dates were predicted out of sample or found retrospectively. If they were predicted, the article adds that it is also unclear what signals the service gave at the time.

Why should investors be cautious about a market timing service's claims of past accuracy and testimonials?

Investors should be cautious about a market timing service's claims of past accuracy because confirmation bias and monetary incentive can distort an offeror's presentation of favorable results and testimonials. The article says such claims should not be relied on alone as proof of value. It also questions why someone with truly amazing timing accuracy, who should be amazingly wealthy, would bother writing and selling retail newsletters, and notes the cycle methodology may have generated spurious signals.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›