Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Aggregate Analyst Sentiment in the Long Run

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Investing Expertise

Guide Market Indicators Sentiment

Key Insight

Analyst upgrades to buy by brokers with the lowest percentage of buy recommendations outperformed upgrades by highest-buy-percentage brokers (50 basis points per month; Jan 1996–Jun 2003; 438K recommendations).

Does the distribution of analyst buy-hold-sell ratings predict the overall stock market? Is the distribution of ratings for a given firm indicative of the value of those ratings to investors? In the September 2005 version of their paper entitled “Buys, Holds, and Sells: The Distribution of Investment Banks’ Stock Ratings and the Implications for the Profitability of Analysts’ Recommendations”, Brad Barber, Reuven Lehavy, Maureen McNichols and Brett Trueman analyze the distribution of stock ratings at investment banks and brokerage firms and examine whether these distributions can be used to predict the profitability of analysts’ recommendations. Using 438,000 recommendations issued on more than 12,000 firms by 463 investment banks and brokerage firms from January 1996 through June 2003, they conclude that:

  • The percentage of buy recommendations increases substantially from 3/96-6/00, peaking at 74%, but decreases substantially thereafter. (See the chart below.)
  • There is persistence over time in the percentage of buy recommendations for given broker.
  • Stocks upgraded to buy by brokers with the lowest percentage of buy recommendations advance by an average of 50 basis points per month more than stocks upgraded to buy by brokers with the highest percentage of buy recommendations.
  • Stocks downgraded to hold or sell by brokers issuing the highest percentage of buy recommendations decline by an average of 46 basis points per month more than stocks downgraded to hold or sell by brokers issuing the lowest percentage of buy recommendations.
  • A portfolio strategy seeking to capture these two types of outperformance may not have been profitable due to the large number of stocks, and therefore high transaction costs, involved.
  • Stocks of small firms contribute disproportionately to both types of outperformance.
  • Both types of outperformance have diminished since 2002, when rules began requiring that analyst research reports include the issuing firm’s overall distribution of buys, holds and sells.

The following chart, taken from the paper, shows the distributions of buys, holds and sells and the the S&P 500 index using end-of-quarter measurements from March 1996 through June 2003. The evolution of distributions suggests that analysts as a group are trend-followers rather than contrarians. They are most bullish (bearish) when the stock market is high (low). The chart shows a marked change in aggregate analyst behavior in 2002 when: (1) the stock market declined dramatically; and, (2) rules began requiring that analyst research reports include the issuing firm’s overall distribution of buys, holds and sells.

B H S

In summary, aggregate distribution of analyst recommendations is a coincident or lagging stock market indicator, and those firms that appear to be most realistic (honest) with their distribution of recommendations provide the best advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the distribution of analyst buy, hold and sell ratings?

The distribution of analyst buy, hold and sell ratings is the share of a brokerage's or investment bank's stock recommendations that fall into each category. In the study of 438,000 recommendations on more than 12,000 firms from 463 brokers (January 1996–June 2003), the percentage of buy recommendations rose substantially from March 1996 to June 2000, peaking at 74%, and fell substantially thereafter.

Do upgrades from brokers with few buy ratings outperform upgrades from brokers with many buy ratings?

Yes, stocks upgraded to buy by brokers with the lowest percentage of buy recommendations outperformed those upgraded by brokers with the highest percentage by an average of 50 basis points per month (January 1996–June 2003). Similarly, stocks downgraded to hold or sell by the highest-buy-percentage brokers underperformed those downgraded by the lowest-buy-percentage brokers by an average of 46 basis points per month. Both effects have diminished since 2002.

How is the value of an analyst recommendation tested against a broker's overall rating distribution?

The study measured each broker's percentage of buy recommendations and compared the subsequent monthly returns of stocks upgraded to buy or downgraded to hold or sell, grouped by whether the broker had a low or high buy percentage. It used 438,000 recommendations on more than 12,000 firms from 463 investment banks and brokerage firms, January 1996–June 2003. The approach relies on persistence over time in each broker's buy percentage.

Is aggregate analyst sentiment a leading indicator of the stock market or a trend-following one?

Aggregate analyst sentiment is a coincident or lagging stock market indicator rather than a leading one, according to the study. Analysts as a group behave as trend-followers rather than contrarians, being most bullish when the stock market is high and most bearish when it is low. Brokers that were most realistic in their rating distributions gave the best advice.

Can investors profit from trading on brokers' buy-rating percentages after transaction costs?

A portfolio strategy capturing the upgrade and downgrade outperformance by broker buy-percentage may not have been profitable, because the large number of stocks involved implies high transaction costs. Small-firm stocks contribute disproportionately to both types of outperformance. Both effects have also diminished since 2002, when rules began requiring research reports to disclose the issuing firm's overall distribution of buys, holds and sells.

Market Indicators guide

More on sentiment

  • X Stocks & Economy Timeline Sentiment Premium We asked Grok to construct a time series for the overall sentiment of posts in the Stocks & Economy Timeline on X.com. Grok first…
  • Testing a Proxy for the Goldman Sachs Panic Index Premium Claude-estimated Goldman Sachs Panic Index values (pixel-reconstructed from a chart) showed high readings (above 8) followed by 1.2% average next-week S&P 500 returns vs…
  • AI-simulated CFO Sentiment Premium GPT-5.4-simulated CFO optimism correlates with actual Duke-Federal Reserve CFO Survey responses (LLM mean 56.6 vs actual 60.1; regression coefficient over six standard errors from…
  • CFO U.S. Economic Sentiment and Stock Market Returns Premium CFO average U.S. economic sentiment shows little ability to predict S&P 500 returns; correlations with next-four-quarter returns are very weak and negative, while change…
  • How Are Sentiment-driven ETFs Doing? Premium An equal-weighted average of three sentiment ETFs (BUZZ, MOOD, NEWZ; monthly rebalanced) underperformed VTI (1.0% vs 10.7% CAGR; MaxDD -51% vs -25%; sample periods…

All 310 articles in the Market Indicators guide

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›