Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Forecasting Stock Market Returns in Europe

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Equity Premium

Key Insight

Macroeconomic and technical variables often beat historical average for predicting European stock returns, with risk-free rate and price pressure outperforming in ~half of countries (14 markets; 2000-2011; 60-month rolling regressions).

Are European stock market returns predictable? In their September 2012 paper entitled “Forecasting Returns: New European Evidence”, Steven Jordan, Andrew Vivian and Mark Wohar test the ability of fundamental, macroeconomic and technical variables to predict next-month returns in 14 developed and emerging European country stock markets both in-sample and out-of-sample. They consider four fundamental variables (using logarithms): dividend-price ratio; dividend yield; earnings-price ratio; and, dividend payout ratio (dividend-to-earnings). They consider two macroeconomic variables: the risk-free rate; and, variance of weekly stock market returns over the last 52 weeks. They consider two technical variables: monthly price pressure (ratio of number of rising stocks to number of falling stocks); and, monthly change in volume of all stocks. They test predictive power via simple linear regression, with a rolling historical window of 60 months for out-of-sample tests. They use the historical average as a benchmark forecast. To assess the economic value of forecasts, they examine whether portfolio allocations based on regression outputs beat those based on the historical average. Using monthly data for 14 European/Mediterranean stock market indexes during January 1995 (so out-of-sample tests begin in 2000) through December 2011, they find that:

  • Fundamental ratios exhibit little or no out-of-sample predictive power or gross economic value.
  • Macroeconomic and technical variables often beat the historical average as predictors both statistically and economically. The risk-free rate and price pressure each beat the historical average in about half the countries. In 10 of 13 countries (not enough data for Cyprus), at least one of these variables outperforms the historical average.
  • Restricting macroeconomic and technical variables to ranges that “make sense” does not improve their predictive power.
  • Fundamental variables consistently work better in liquid rather than illiquid markets. Macroeconomic variables work better in developed rather than emerging markets.
  • The average of all simple (single-variable) models consistently (11 of 14 countries) outperforms the historical average benchmark.

In summary, evidence suggests some economic value from forecasting European stock market returns with individual macroeconomic and technical variables; the average forecast from all eight predictors most consistently outperforms the historical average.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • The sample period is very short compared to variable construction intervals.
  • The study uses indexes rather than tradable assets. Costs of constructing tradable assets (trading frictions and management fees) would reduce returns, perhaps differently across markets.
  • The study apparently ignores any trading frictions associated with entering/exiting indexes to estimate economic value. Incorporating these frictions would reduce performance.
  • Applying different rules to the same individual markets, and the same set of rules to individual markets introduces data snooping bias, such that the best results incorporate luck. The fact that different predictors beat the benchmark in different markets undermines belief that any specific predictors link to fundamental principles of investment or human behavior.
  • A monthly forecast horizon may not fit the hypothetical effectiveness of specific variables.
  • Random timing may be instructive as an alternative benchmark (see “The 2000s: A Market Timer’s Decade?”).

Frequently Asked Questions

What does out-of-sample return predictability mean in stock market forecasting?

Out-of-sample return predictability means a variable can forecast future stock returns using only data available at the time of the forecast, rather than fitting the full historical sample. In the European study, out-of-sample tests used 60-month rolling windows, with forecasts beginning in 2000 and running through December 2011. A predictor is considered useful only if it beats a benchmark such as the historical average return.

Can macroeconomic and technical variables predict European stock market returns better than the historical average?

Macroeconomic and technical variables often beat the historical average for predicting next-month European stock returns, both statistically and economically. The risk-free rate and price pressure each outperformed in about half of 14 countries, and at least one of them outperformed in 10 of 13 countries tested. Fundamental ratios such as dividend-price and earnings-price showed little or no out-of-sample predictive power.

How do researchers test whether a variable predicts stock returns using rolling regressions?

Researchers in this European study ran simple linear regressions of next-month returns on each predictor, using a rolling 60-month window for out-of-sample forecasts and the historical average return as the benchmark. To assess economic value, they compared portfolio allocations based on the regression forecasts with allocations based on the historical average. The data covered monthly returns for 14 European and Mediterranean stock indexes from January 1995 through December 2011.

Is combining all predictors better than using a single variable to forecast stock returns?

Combining predictors worked more consistently than relying on any single variable in the European study. The average forecast from all simple single-variable models outperformed the historical average benchmark in 11 of 14 countries. Individual predictors, by contrast, beat the benchmark in different markets, so no single variable worked everywhere.

What are the limitations of using macroeconomic and technical variables to forecast European stock returns?

The European forecasting results come with several caveats: the sample period is short, the tests use indexes rather than tradable assets, and trading frictions and management fees would reduce returns. Testing many rules across many markets creates data snooping bias, so the best results may reflect luck. The fact that different predictors work in different markets also undermines confidence that any specific variable reflects fundamental investment principles or human behavior.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 19, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›