Do the experts who arguably should have the most informed opinions, finance professors, believe that the U.S. stock market is efficient? Do they invest in accordance with their beliefs? In their August 2007 paper entitled “Market Efficiency and Its Importance to Individual Investors – Surveying the Experts”, James Doran, David Peterson and Colby Wright seek to answer these questions via an email-initiated electronic survey of over 4,000 finance professors at accredited U.S. universities and colleges. Using data provided by 642 qualified respondents, they conclude that:
- Finance professors tend to believe that the U.S. stock market is weakly to semi-strongly efficient. Specifically,
- Weak: 8% (59%) generally agree (disagree) that it is possible to predict future stock returns using only past returns.
- Semi-strong: the sample is largely neutral but leaning toward agreement that it is not possible to predict future returns using only past returns and publicly available information.
- Strong: 57% (10%) generally agree (disagree) that it is possible to predict future returns using past returns, public information and private information.
- Those who specialize in market efficiency tend to believe a little less strongly in efficiency than does the overall sample.
- 18% (42%) of the sample generally agree (disagree) that their investing goal is to beat the market, implying that the overall sample largely accepts semi-strong market efficiency. Specifically,
- 10% generally accept market efficiency but still try to beat the market.
- 12% generally reject market efficiency but still do not try to beat the market.
- 15% generally reject market efficiency and do try to beat the market.
- 27% generally accept market efficiency and do not try to beat the market.
- The rest are noncommittal on either market efficiency or investment goals.
- Investing behavior varies somewhat by specialty:
- The investing behavior of those who specialize in market efficiency is much like that of the overall sample.
- Those specializing in behavioral finance and derivatives tend to invest more actively.
- Those specializing in fields less related to market efficiency (capital structure and corporate governance) tend to invest much more passively.
- The primary driver of a finance professor’s tendency to invest actively is confidence in personal ability to outperform, regardless of belief about market efficiency.
The following table, taken from the paper, sorts respondents based on whether they invest to beat the market and based on their belief in market efficiency (average response to the three statements of belief regarding weak, semi-strong and strong efficiency). Response scales for all statements are 1 (strongly agree) to 7 (strongly disagree). Gray (black) highlighting indicates respondents whose investment goals match (do not match) beliefs in market efficiency. The table shows that about 22% of these experts exhibit dissonance between investing goals and self-reported beliefs regarding market efficiency.

In summary, finance professors generally reject the value of technical analysis and mostly reject the value of public information in predicting stock returns, but they accept the importance of private information. However, about one fifth of them adopt investing goals that disregard their stated market efficiency beliefs.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is market efficiency in investing?
Market efficiency is the idea that stock prices already reflect available information, so returns cannot be reliably predicted using that information. It is commonly split into weak form (past returns), semi-strong form (past returns plus public information), and strong form (past, public and private information). A 2007 survey of 642 finance professors found they tend to view the U.S. stock market as weakly to semi-strongly efficient.
Do finance professors believe the stock market is efficient?
Finance professors tend to believe the U.S. stock market is weakly to semi-strongly efficient, based on a 2007 survey of 642 respondents. Only 8% agreed that past returns can predict future returns (59% disagreed), while 57% agreed that returns can be predicted using past, public and private information combined (10% disagreed). The sample was largely neutral but leaned toward agreeing that past returns and public information cannot predict returns.
How was finance professors' belief in market efficiency measured?
Belief in market efficiency was measured through an email-initiated electronic survey sent to over 4,000 finance professors at accredited U.S. universities and colleges, yielding 642 qualified respondents. Respondents rated statements on weak, semi-strong and strong efficiency on a scale from 1 (strongly agree) to 7 (strongly disagree). The average response across the three statements was compared with whether respondents said their investing goal was to beat the market.
Do finance professors who specialize in market efficiency invest differently from other finance professors?
Finance professors who specialize in market efficiency invest much like the overall sample, though they believe in efficiency a little less strongly than the overall sample. Those specializing in behavioral finance and derivatives tend to invest more actively, while those in capital structure and corporate governance tend to invest much more passively. The survey found the main driver of active investing is confidence in one's own ability to outperform, regardless of belief about market efficiency.
Why do some finance professors try to beat the market even if they believe markets are efficient?
About 22% of surveyed finance professors showed dissonance between their market efficiency beliefs and investing goals, including 10% who generally accept efficiency yet try to beat the market. Another 12% reject efficiency but do not try to beat the market. The survey found the primary driver of active investing is confidence in personal ability to outperform, regardless of efficiency beliefs; the results rely on self-reported beliefs and goals from a 2007 survey.