Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

News, VIX and Stock Market Returns

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Sentiment Indicators, Volatility Effects

Guide Volatility and the VIX The VIX as a signal

Key Insight

Aggregate unscheduled firm news sentiment and VIX extremes correlate with S&P 500 returns; combined low VIX/sentiment generated 1.8% avg monthly return vs high readings' 7.7% (Jan 2000–Dec 2010; descriptive).

How does aggregate stock news sentiment relate to equity market return and volatility? In his October 2012 paper entitled “Time-Varying Relationship of News Sentiment, Implied Volatility and Stock Returns”, Lee Smales investigates relationships among aggregate unscheduled firm-specific news sentiment, changes in the S&P 500 Implied Volatility Index (VIX) and both contemporaneous and future S&P 500 Index returns. He measures daily aggregate unscheduled firm-specific news sentiment as an average of scores calculated by the RavenPack news analysis tool for articles with headlines specifying S&P 500 stocks published for the first time that day on the Dow Jones news wire and in the Wall Street Journal. Unscheduled means exclusion of scheduled news releases such as earnings and dividend announcements. Using daily aggregated news sentiment for S&P 500 firms and levels of the S&P 500 Index and VIX during January 2000 through December 2010, he finds that:

  • Based on the specified measurement methodology over the entire sample period, average aggregate daily news sentiment is -1.1, ranging from a low of -59.7 in 2007 to a high of +38.0 in 2003.
  • For contemporaneous measurements over the entire sample period:
    • Aggregate daily news sentiment relates negatively to change in VIX, much more strongly when VIX is high and news sentiment negative (such as 2007-2009).
    • There is also an inverse and asymmetric relationship between change in VIX and S&P 500 Index return, but the asymmetry may not hold after controlling for news sentiment.
  • Leading relationships are:
    • S&P 500 Index return (change in VIX) relates positively to itself over the next interval (autocorrelation). 
    • Aggregate news sentiment relates positively (negatively) to next-interval stock return (change in VIX).
    • Stock market return relates negatively to next-interval change in VIX.
  • Regarding potential trading strategies:
    • Extremely high (low) current levels of VIX signal attractive buy (sell) points for the S&P 500 Index. Specifically, when VIX falls in the lowest 6 (highest 3) of 21 ranks based on the lagged year of daily closes, average gross S&P 500 Index returns over the next 1, 5, 20, 60 and 250 trading days are always negative (positive). When VIX falls in rank 21 (1), average gross S&P 500 Index return over the next 20 trading days is 9.2% (-3.0%). However, when VIX falls in ranks 7-18, there is no clear pattern in stock market returns. 
    • Extremely low current levels of aggregate news sentiment signal attractive sell points for the S&P 500 Index. Specifically, when news sentiment falls in the lowest 5 of 21 ranks based on the lagged year of daily closes, average gross S&P 500 Index returns over the next 1, 5, 20, 60 and 250 trading days are always negative. When aggregate news sentiment falls in rank 1, average gross S&P 500 Index return over the next 20 trading days is -2.1%. However, when aggregate news sentiment is rank 5 or above, there is no clear pattern in stock market returns.
    • A strategy that sells the S&P 500 Index when both aggregate news sentiment and VIX are high relative to the past year is consistently profitable at a gross level, generating an average 1-month (3-month) gross return of 7.7% (10.7%). A strategy that buys the S&P 500 Index when both aggregate news sentiment and VIX are low relative to the past year is consistently profitable at a gross level, generating an average 1-month (3-month) gross return of 1.8% (5.0%).

In summary, evidence suggests that traders may be able to time the U.S. stock market based on extremely high or low values of VIX and/or extremely negative values of the sentiment embedded in aggregate unscheduled news about component stocks.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • Trading strategy calculations ignore dividends, to the disadvantage of a buy-and-hold benchmark. Use of the S&P 500 Index also ignores any costs of forming and maintaining a tradable tracking asset.
  • Reported average trading strategy returns are gross, not net. Including reasonable frictions for entering and exiting positions and costs of shorting would reduce these returns.
  • Returns ignore the costs of generating aggregate news sentiment on a daily basis. Such costs would reduce profitability of any strategies based on this metric.
  • For holding intervals longer than one day, reported average trading strategy returns involve overlapping return measurement intervals, thereby obscuring portfolio level performance. Realistic trading would require either skipping many signals (because funds are already committed) or allocating only fractions of the portfolio to each signal (estimating position size ex ante would be problematic). Effectively, use of overlapping signals overstates sample size and may amplify impacts of extreme events.
  • The data in Table 9 of the paper do not appear to support the assertion in Section 4.2.2 of the paper that “very positive levels of news sentiment, R ≥ 20, produce forward looking returns that are always positive on average.” The table shows that average gross S&P 500 Index returns are negative for horizons of 60 and 250 trading days.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is aggregate unscheduled firm-specific news sentiment in investing?

Aggregate unscheduled firm-specific news sentiment is a daily average of RavenPack sentiment scores for first-time-published articles about S&P 500 stocks on the Dow Jones news wire and in the Wall Street Journal. Unscheduled means scheduled releases such as earnings and dividend announcements are excluded. Over January 2000 through December 2010, the average daily score was -1.1, ranging from -59.7 in 2007 to +38.0 in 2003.

Can VIX and news sentiment predict S&P 500 returns?

VIX and aggregate news sentiment show some ability to predict S&P 500 Index returns at extremes, based on January 2000 through December 2010 data. A strategy buying when both VIX and sentiment were low relative to the past year earned an average 1.8% gross return over one month, while selling when both were high earned 7.7% (10.7% over three months). Readings in the middle of the range show no clear pattern in subsequent returns.

How are VIX and news sentiment ranked to generate S&P 500 trading signals?

VIX and aggregate news sentiment are each ranked into 21 buckets based on the lagged year of daily closes, and average gross S&P 500 Index returns are then measured over the next 1, 5, 20, 60 and 250 trading days. When VIX is in the lowest 6 ranks, subsequent returns are always negative, and when it is in the highest 3 ranks they are always positive. Rank 21 VIX produced an average 9.2% 20-day return versus -3.0% for rank 1.

How does high VIX compare with negative news sentiment as a stock market timing signal?

Extreme VIX readings signal both buy and sell points for the S&P 500 Index, whereas news sentiment is mainly a sell signal when extremely low. When news sentiment is in the lowest 5 of 21 ranks, returns over the next 1 to 250 trading days are always negative, with rank 1 averaging -2.1% over 20 days. Sentiment in rank 5 or above shows no clear pattern, and high VIX ranks 1 and 21 show a wider 20-day return spread (-3.0% versus 9.2%).

What are the limitations of trading the S&P 500 on VIX and news sentiment signals?

The reported VIX and news sentiment strategy returns are gross figures that ignore trading frictions, shorting costs, tracking-asset costs, dividends, and the cost of generating daily sentiment data, so real-world profitability would be lower. Holding-period returns for intervals beyond one day use overlapping measurement windows, which overstates the sample size and may amplify extreme events. Additionally, the paper's claim that very positive sentiment always precedes positive returns is not supported by its own Table 9, which shows negative average returns at 60 and 250 trading days.

Volatility and the VIX guide

More on the vix as a signal

  • Asset Class ETF Interactions with VIX Premium Asset class ETF returns show moderately negative lead-lag correlations with future VIX, strongest for equities and missing for TLT and GLD; best and worst…
  • VVIX/VIX as a Return Indicator? Premium Monthly VVIX/VIX and its monthly change show no reliable relationship with next-month SPY returns; SPY returns lead VVIX/VIX, and quintile results are unsystematic (Sep…
  • VVIX as a Return Indicator? Premium Monthly VVIX and monthly change in VVIX showed no reliable predictive relationship with next-month SPY returns; quintile averages were erratic (Sep 2006–Mar 2025; end-of-month…
  • VIX Seasonality Premium VIX average monthly changes are larger and more variable in February and July–October (VIX since Jan 1990; VIXY since Jan 2011; SVXY since Oct…
  • Exploit VIX Percentile Threshold Rule Out-of-Sample? Premium VIX Percentile Strategy (monthly SPY or T-bills by inception-to-date VIX percentile threshold; 70th-90th percentiles and 0-3 skip months tested) had lower CAGR but shallower…

All 162 articles in the Volatility and the VIX guide

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 18, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›