Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Exploiting the Implied Volatility Term Structure

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Equity Options, Volatility Effects

Guide Volatility and the VIX The VIX as a signal

Key Insight

Implied volatility term structure slope predicts option returns, with straddle hedge strategies generating 27.1% average monthly gross returns (12.3% net; Jan 1996-Jun 2007; long high-slope/short low-slope stocks; 260 stocks monthly).

An upward (downward) trend in implied volatilities with option maturity indicates that investors expect volatility to increase (decrease) over time. Do such expectations reliably predict future stock options prices? In his October 2011 paper entitled “Volatility Term Structure and the Cross-Section of Option Returns”, Aurelio Vasquez investigates whether the implied volatility term structure (measured as slope of implied volatilities across at-the-money options with receding expiration dates) predicts future option returns. Specifically, each month he ranks stocks into deciles by volatility term structure slope and then calculates future returns for extreme deciles from five option trading strategies: (1) naked calls; (2)naked puts; (3) straddles; (4) delta-hedged calls; and, (5) delta-hedged puts. He calculates returns relative to the initial prices of the options traded. Using monthly closing bid and ask prices for at-the-money options (moneyness between 0.95 and 1.05) on a broad sample of U.S. stocks, and associated firm characteristics, during January 1996 through June 2007 (260 stocks per month on average), he finds that:

  • Over the entire sample period, the average slope of the monthly volatility term structure ranges from -15.0% for decile 1 to 8.5% for decile 10. These extremes represent stocks with implied volatilities currently well above and below their long-term means, respectively, with mean reversion expected.
  • Option portfolios with the most positive volatility term structure slopes significantly outperform those with the most negative. For example, over the entire sample period: 
    • A hedge portfolio that each month buys (sells) straddles for the tenth of stocks with the highest (lowest) volatility term structure slopes generates an average monthly gross return of 27.1%, with 14.8% (12.2%) coming from the long (short) side. 81% of the monthly gross returns are positive.
    • Similar hedge strategies using naked calls, naked puts, delta-hedged calls and delta-hedged puts generate average monthly gross returns of 35.7%, 25.6%, 4.0% and 3.5%, respectively with 61%, 63%, 81% and 81% of monthly gross returns positive.
  • Assuming trading friction equal to the bid-ask spread (1.1 times the bid-ask spread), the hedge strategy employing:
    • Straddles generates an average monthly net return of 12.3% (10.9%).
    • Naked calls generates an average monthly net return of 15.0% (13.3%), with hardly any contribution from the short side.
    • Naked puts generates an average monthly net return of 7.6% (6.0%), with the contribution from the long side negative.
    • Delta-hedged puts generates an average monthly net return of 0.8%% (0.6%).
    • Delta-hedged calls generates an average monthly net return of 1.5% (1.3%).
  • Gross results are robust to different setups, adjustments for common risk factors, and characteristic sorts. Average monthly gross returns for the hedge strategy using straddles are 29.9% during 1996-2000 and 24.9% during 2001-2007, with a decrease in trading frictions more than compensating for the lower gross profitability.

The following chart, taken from the paper, shows the time series of monthly gross return for a hedge portfolio that each month buys (sells) straddles for the tenth of stocks with the highest (lowest) volatility term structure slopes over the 1996-2007 sample period. Average monthly gross return is 27.1%, with 81% of the monthly returns positive.

The paper presents similar charts for hedge strategies executed with naked calls, naked puts, delta-hedged calls and delta-hedged puts.

In summary, evidence indicates that investors may be able to generate abnormal returns via option strategies that are long (short) options of those individual stocks with the most positive (negative) implied volatility term structures.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • The study calculates returns relative to option prices and not relative to required margin plus capital reserve. Return on capital based on broker margin requirements for the largest expected drawdown would be much lower.
  • It would be interesting to extend the data through the 2008-2009 financial crisis to understand how crises might affect indicator performance.
  • Trading frictions used in the study account for the bid-ask spread but do not address broker commissions/fees.
  • The slope metric used assumes the term structure is essentially linear. A non-linear term structure model might produce better results.
  • Statistical significance tests in the paper assume a tame return distribution. Distribution wildness diminishes confidence in the test.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the implied volatility term structure and what does its slope tell investors?

The implied volatility term structure is the pattern of implied volatilities across options with different expiration dates. An upward slope indicates investors expect volatility to increase over time, while a downward slope indicates they expect it to decrease. In the study, slope was measured across at-the-money options with receding expiration dates.

Does the implied volatility term structure slope predict future option returns?

Implied volatility term structure slope does predict option returns in this study: option portfolios for stocks with the most positive slopes significantly outperformed those with the most negative slopes. A straddle hedge strategy (long highest-slope decile, short lowest-slope decile) earned an average monthly gross return of 27.1% and 12.3% net of bid-ask spread costs, with 81% of monthly gross returns positive (January 1996-June 2007).

How is the volatility term structure strategy for stock options tested?

Each month, stocks are ranked into deciles by implied volatility term structure slope, and future returns for the extreme deciles are calculated for five option strategies: naked calls, naked puts, straddles, delta-hedged calls and delta-hedged puts. The test uses monthly closing bid and ask prices for at-the-money options (moneyness 0.95 to 1.05) on about 260 U.S. stocks per month from January 1996 to June 2007, with returns measured relative to initial option prices.

Which option strategy works best for trading volatility term structure slope: straddles, naked options or delta-hedged options?

Naked calls produced the highest average monthly gross hedge return (35.7%) and net return (15.0%), followed by straddles at 27.1% gross and 12.3% net, and naked puts at 25.6% gross and 7.6% net. Delta-hedged calls and puts were far lower, at 4.0% and 3.5% gross and 1.5% and 0.8% net. Straddles had 81% positive monthly gross returns, versus 61% for naked calls and 63% for naked puts.

What are the limitations of using implied volatility term structure slope to trade options?

The reported returns are calculated relative to option prices rather than required margin plus capital reserve, so return on capital based on broker margin for the largest expected drawdown would be much lower. Trading frictions account for the bid-ask spread but not broker commissions or fees. The slope metric assumes a roughly linear term structure, the data exclude the 2008-2009 financial crisis, and the significance tests assume a tame return distribution, which reduces confidence if returns are wild.

Volatility and the VIX guide

More on the vix as a signal

  • Asset Class ETF Interactions with VIX Premium Asset class ETF returns show moderately negative lead-lag correlations with future VIX, strongest for equities and missing for TLT and GLD; best and worst…
  • VVIX/VIX as a Return Indicator? Premium Monthly VVIX/VIX and its monthly change show no reliable relationship with next-month SPY returns; SPY returns lead VVIX/VIX, and quintile results are unsystematic (Sep…
  • VVIX as a Return Indicator? Premium Monthly VVIX and monthly change in VVIX showed no reliable predictive relationship with next-month SPY returns; quintile averages were erratic (Sep 2006–Mar 2025; end-of-month…
  • VIX Seasonality Premium VIX average monthly changes are larger and more variable in February and July–October (VIX since Jan 1990; VIXY since Jan 2011; SVXY since Oct…
  • Exploit VIX Percentile Threshold Rule Out-of-Sample? Premium VIX Percentile Strategy (monthly SPY or T-bills by inception-to-date VIX percentile threshold; 70th-90th percentiles and 0-3 skip months tested) had lower CAGR but shallower…

All 162 articles in the Volatility and the VIX guide

Guru Grades

1,179 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 13, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›