Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Testing a Complex Breakout Indicator

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Technical Trading, Volatility Effects

Key Insight

Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel breakouts show no reliable trend continuation, with breakout direction explaining just 1% of subsequent trend variation (R-squared 0.01; SPY 1993-2010; 86 breakouts).

A reader, citing a technical indicator recommended in Mastering the Trade by John Carter, inquired about the usefulness of watching for times when certain Bollinger Bands (upper and lower bounds two standard deviations from a 20-day simple moving average) converge within a certain Keltner Channel (upper and lower bounds 1.5 times the 20-day average range from a 20-day average typical price). Breakouts from this condition are supposedly reliable for both indexes and individual securities, meaning that price continues in same direction for a while without material reversal, because the condition represents true “consolidation.” There is no specification for trend duration after these “reliable” breakouts. Using daily high, low and unadjusted closing prices for S&P Depository Receipts (SPY) for band/channel calculations, and adjusted closing prices for return calculations, over the period 1/29/93 through 1/8/10 (nearly 17 years), we find that:

The following chart illustrates the Bollinger Band and Keltner Channel boundaries as specified during 2008-2009. Visual inspection shows that the former occasionally track inside the latter. However, visual inspection is not effective for measuring the reliability of subsequent breakouts over the entire sample period.

BB KC

Calculations show that the Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel condition holds at the close for 818 out of 4250 trading days (19% of the time) over the entire sample period. These 818 days tend to cluster. We make the following assumptions to enable a systematic test of subsequent breakouts:

  • The sum of daily close-to-close returns during the three trading days after Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel conditions end defines the direction and size of breakout. There are 126 such breakouts over the entire sample period. In other words, if the condition holds on Day 0 but not on Day 1, the return from the close on Day 0 to the close on Day 3 defines the breakout.
  • The average daily close-to-close return during the 18 trading days after the breakout interval (for a total breakout-trend interval of 21 trading days or about a month) defines the direction and size of the post-breakout trend. The last breakout in the sample period is therefore too recent to use.
  • Based on these definitions, breakouts that occur within a month (30 calendar days) of each other are not both exploitable. We therefore winnow the set of breakouts such that no two breakouts are within 30 calendar days of each other, leaving an exploitable sample of 86 breakouts (about one every 2.3 months on average).

Applying these assumptions, the following scatter plot relates the post-breakout trend for SPY to the associated SPY breakout over the entire sample period. The Pearson correlation for the two series is -0.11 and the R-squared statistic at 0.01, indicating that variation in breakouts explains just 1% of variation in subsequent trends. Any relationship is opposite the hypothesized belief.

For the unwinnowed sample of 125 breakouts, the Pearson correlation is -0.16.

In case the relationship is non-linear, we try a ranking.

scatter

The final chart summarizes the average SPY post-breakout trend by quintile of SPY breakouts over the entire sample period. Results across quintiles are not notably systematic. If anything, the post-breakout trend tends to be more positive after negative breakouts than after positive breakouts. Results do not support the hypothesized belief described above.

The quintile subsamples are small (just 17-18 observations each), so a few additional observations could alter results substantially.

quintiles

In summary, evidence based on straightforward assumptions and tests does not support a belief that breakout indications after Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel conditions are reliable.

Modifying the test specifications and/or adding restrictions may produce different results, but would introduce data snooping bias.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel squeeze in technical analysis?

A Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel squeeze is a technical condition in which Bollinger Bands (two standard deviations around a 20-day simple moving average) contract inside a Keltner Channel (1.5 times the 20-day average range around a 20-day average typical price). Proponents, such as John Carter in Mastering the Trade, treat it as true price consolidation that precedes a reliable directional breakout. In the SPY test from 1993 to 2010, the condition held at the close on 818 of 4250 trading days (19%).

Does a breakout from a Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel squeeze predict trend continuation?

No, a breakout from a Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel squeeze did not reliably predict trend continuation in SPY from 1/29/93 to 1/8/10. Across 86 exploitable breakouts, the correlation between breakout and subsequent trend was -0.11 with an R-squared of 0.01, so breakout direction explained only 1% of trend variation. Any relationship ran opposite to the hypothesis, with post-breakout trends tending to be more positive after negative breakouts.

How do you test whether breakouts from a Bollinger Band and Keltner Channel squeeze are reliable?

The test defines a breakout as the sum of daily close-to-close returns over the three trading days after the Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel condition ends. The post-breakout trend is the average daily return over the next 18 trading days, for a 21-day total interval. The 126 breakouts were winnowed to 86 by removing any within 30 calendar days of another, then analyzed with Pearson correlation, R-squared, and a quintile ranking to allow for non-linear relationships.

Do positive breakouts lead to stronger trends than negative breakouts after a Bollinger Band squeeze?

No, positive breakouts did not lead to stronger trends than negative breakouts after the Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel condition in SPY. When breakouts were ranked into quintiles, results were not notably systematic, and if anything the post-breakout trend tended to be more positive after negative breakouts than after positive ones. The unwinnowed sample of 125 breakouts showed a similar correlation of -0.16.

What are the limitations of backtesting Bollinger Band and Keltner Channel breakout signals?

The Bollinger Band-within-Keltner Channel test is limited by its small samples, with only 17-18 observations per quintile, so a few additional observations could substantially alter the results. It also tests only SPY under one set of assumptions, including a three-day breakout window and an 18-day trend window, because the indicator specifies no trend duration. Modifying the specifications or adding restrictions might produce different results but would introduce data snooping bias.

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 18, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›