Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Three Centuries of Calendar Effects

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Calendar Effects

Guide Calendar Effects Calendar studies

Key Insight

Halloween/Sell-in-May effect persists across all 50-year and 100-year subperiods, with November-April beating May-October by 0.56% monthly average (1693-2009; UK stock index; descriptive; not a trading test).

How well do calendar-based anomalies, such as the January and Halloween/Sell-in-May effects, hold up for data extending back three centuries? Do any new anomalies emerge from such a data set? In their October 2010 paper entitled “Are Monthly Seasonals Real? A Three Century Perspective”, Ben Jacobsen and Cherry Zhang examine an extremely long record of UK stock returns for evidence of calendar anomalies. Using 317 years of monthly UK stock index returns and risk-free rate proxies spanning 1693 through 2009, they find that:

  • Most months exhibit 50-year subperiods of outperformance, demonstrating why researchers need extremely long data sets to neutralize sample noise, selection bias and data snooping bias.
  • Average December, January, April and August returns are significantly higher than the returns for the rest of the year over the entire sample period, but no month significantly outperforms the market in all 50-year and 100-year subsamples.
    • December comes close, underperforming only during the 1901-1950 subperiod.
    • The January effect emerges in the 1830s, when Christmas becomes a UK public holiday, apparently leaching performance from a previously dominant December. During the preceding 150 years, January underperforms (see the first chart below).
  • October (July) underperforms the other months by an average 0.68% (0.46%) over the entire sample period.  October and July also underperform consistently during all 50-year and 100-year subperiods. September underperforms and outperforms during 50-year subsamples and is not as bad as October.
  • November-April beats May-October (which, per the second chart below, actually underperforms the risk-free rate) by an average 0.56% over the entire sample period. This Halloween or Sell-in-May effect persists during all 50-year and 100-year subperiods. A Sell-in-May strategy beats the market more than 80% (90%) of the time over 5-year (10-year) horizons.

The following chart, taken from the paper, plots in percent the 10-year moving average of the difference between January returns and the average returns for the other 11 months across the entire sample period. It shows that the January effect emerged in the early 1800s, coincident with increased emphasis on the Christmas holiday. Before that time, January underperforms.

January effect

The next chart, also taken from the paper, plots in percent the May-October 10-year moving average return relative to the risk-free rate across the entire sample period. It shows that the the summer risk premium is negative over most of the past 300 years, and positive only during the 1930s to 1950s.

The persistence of this negative May-October premium and of the associated Halloween/Sell-in-May effect offers support for belief in a fundamental cause, such as Seasonal Affective Disorder.

sell in May effect

In summary, evidence from an extremely long UK data set indicates that some calendar-based anomalies are persistent and others are not, suggesting a mix of biological, cultural and data snooping sources. The Halloween/Sell-in-May effect is among the most persistent.

Note that:

  • The stock index used in this study consists of very few stocks in early subperiods, just three stocks for the first 110 years of the sample. There is generally a trade-off between sample duration and data quality/reliability.
  • Calendar-based anomalies associated with public holidays suggest a cultural source, such that different cultures/countries would have different anomalies.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Halloween effect or Sell-in-May anomaly in stock markets?

The Halloween effect, also called Sell-in-May, is the calendar anomaly in which stocks perform better from November through April than from May through October. In a study of 317 years of UK stock returns (1693-2009), November-April beat May-October by an average 0.56% per month. The May-October period actually underperformed the risk-free rate over the full sample.

Does the Sell-in-May effect hold up over long periods of stock market history?

The Sell-in-May (Halloween) effect persisted in every 50-year and 100-year subperiod of UK stock data from 1693 through 2009, making it among the most persistent calendar anomalies found. A Sell-in-May strategy beat the market more than 80% of the time over 5-year horizons and 90% over 10-year horizons. No individual month outperformed in all 50-year and 100-year subsamples, so the persistence of this seasonal effect stands out.

How do researchers test whether calendar anomalies like the January effect are real?

Researchers can test calendar anomalies using an extremely long return history and checking whether the effect holds in separate subperiods. Jacobsen and Zhang used 317 years of monthly UK stock index returns and risk-free rate proxies (1693-2009), comparing each month's average return to the rest of the year across the whole sample and across 50-year and 100-year subsamples. The long data set is meant to reduce sample noise, selection bias and data snooping bias.

How does the January effect compare to the Halloween effect in terms of persistence?

The Halloween effect is far more persistent than the January effect in the UK data from 1693-2009. The Halloween effect held in all 50-year and 100-year subperiods, while the January effect emerged only in the 1830s, around when Christmas became a UK public holiday, and January underperformed during the preceding 150 years. This suggests the January effect has a cultural source, whereas the persistent Halloween effect may point to a more fundamental cause such as Seasonal Affective Disorder.

What are the limitations of using centuries of historical data to study stock market seasonality?

Very long stock histories involve a trade-off between sample duration and data quality or reliability. The UK index in this 1693-2009 study contained just three stocks for the first 110 years of the sample. Also, calendar anomalies tied to public holidays suggest a cultural source, so findings from UK data may not apply to other countries with different cultures.

Calendar Effects guide

More on calendar studies

  • Using AI to Discover Calendar-based Return Anomalies Premium Grok-identified turn-of-the-month window (last 3 to first 3 trading days; 38% of days) averaged 0.084% daily S&P 500 return vs 0.000% outside (Dec 1927–mid-Oct…
  • Alternative U.S. Stock Market Calendar Visualizations Free S&P 500 monthly returns show December and September as best and worst months respectively by reward-to-risk ratio, with January, April, July also favorable (Jan…
  • Aggregate Firm Events as a Stock Return Anomaly Free Aggregate firm event strategies generated gross monthly alphas of 0.27% to 1.12% (through Dec 2016; long-short equal-weighted; earnings/dividend announcements, ex-days, splits; 100% monthly turnover).
  • Short-term VIX Calendar Effects Free VIX exhibits a Monday close-to-close pop and OE-1 decline, but VXX futures data suggests limited exploitability (VIX 1990-2015, VXX 2009-2015; day-of-week and options expiration…
  • Interaction of Calendar Effects with Other Anomalies Free Most U.S. stock anomalies exhibit January effects (several switch sign) and first-month-of-quarter effects; 11 anomalies tested (Jan 1964–Dec 2013; gross returns, value-weighted portfolios).

All 185 articles in the Calendar Effects guide

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 18, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›