Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Simple Sector ETF Momentum Strategy

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Momentum Investing

Guide Trend Following and Momentum Asset class and ETF momentum

Key Insight

Sector ETF momentum strategies underperformed equally weighted benchmarks (4.4-5.0% vs 6.2% CAGR; Dec 1998-Dec 2015; 6-month momentum ranking with monthly rebalancing; 9 SPDR sector ETFs).

Do simple momentum trading strategies applied to major U.S. stock market sectors outperform reasonable benchmarks? To investigate, we apply three simple momentum strategies to the nine sector exchange-traded funds (ETF) defined by the Select Sector Standard & Poor’s Depository Receipts (SPDR):

Materials Select Sector SPDR (XLB)
Energy Select Sector SPDR (XLE)
Financial Select Sector SPDR (XLF)
Industrial Select Sector SPDR (XLI)
Technology Select Sector SPDR (XLK)
Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR (XLP)
Utilities Select Sector SPDR (XLU)
Health Care Select Sector SPDR (XLV)
Consumer Discretionary Select SPDR (XLY)

The three strategies are: (1) allocate all funds at the end of each month to the sector ETF with the highest total return over the past six months (6-1); (2) allocate all funds at the end of each month to the sector ETF with the highest total return over the six months ending the prior month (6-1;1), hypothesizing that the skip-month avoids short-term reversals; and, (3) more cautiously, allocate all funds at the end of each month either to the sector ETF with the highest total return over the past six months or to cash depending on whether the S&P 500 Index is above or below its 10-month simple moving average (6-1;SMA10). A six-month ranking period is intuitively large enough to gauge sector momentum but small enough to react to changes in business conditions that might favor one sector over others. Using monthly dividend-adjusted closing prices for the sector ETFs, the S&P 500 index, 3-month Treasury bills (T-bills) and S&P Depository Receipts (SPY) over the period December 1998 through December 2015 (205 months), we find that:

The following chart shows the distribution of sector ETF winners based on past six-month total return over the entire sample period. The energy sector comprises 48 of the 199 monthly winners (24%).

How does applying the above 6-1 and 6-1;1 strategies translate into cumulative returns?

sector-ETF-momentum-winners

The next chart compares the cumulative values of $100,000 initial investments in the 6-1 and 6-1;1 strategies, SPY and an equally weighted portfolio of the sector ETFs (EW), rebalanced monthly, over the available sample period. Calculations derive from the following assumptions:

  • Reallocate/rebalance at the close on the last trading day of each month (assume that values and total six-month past returns for the ETFs can be calculated just before the close).
  • Trading (switching) friction for the 6-1 and 6-1;1 strategies is 0.25% of the balance whenever there is a change in holdings, but EW portfolio rebalancing is frictionless for conservative benchmarking.
  • Ignore any tax implications of trading.

At the assumed level of switching friction, the 6-1 strategy mostly outperforms SPY and sometimes outperforms the EW portfolio (sometimes adds value to simple diversification). However, the 6-1 strategy recently underperforms EW and has a lower terminal value than both EW and SPY. The attractiveness of the 6-1 strategy depends mostly on the 2003-2007 subperiod.

The 6-1;1 strategy mostly trails the 6-1 strategy until the end of the sample period.

Compound annual growth rates are about 4.4%, 5.0%, 4.6% and 6.2% for 6-1, 6-1;1, SPY and EW, respectively.

How do average monthly returns, as alternative measures of strategy performance, compare?

sector-ETF-momentum-cumulatives

The next chart summarizes gross average (arithmetic mean) monthly returns and standard deviations of monthly returns for each of the sector ETFs, SPY, the EW portfolio and the 6-1 and 6-1;1 strategies over the available sample period. The 6-1 strategy underperforms the EW portfolio, with lower average return and considerably higher volatility. Monthly gross reward-to-risk ratios (rough Sharpe ratios) for 6-1, 6-1;1 and EW are 0.14, 0.11 and 0.12, respectively.

What is the long-term trend in performance of the 6-1 strategy relative to the EW portfolio?

sector-ETF-momentum-and-component-monthly-stats

The next chart shows the net monthly return for the 6-1 strategy minus same-month EW portfolio return over the available sample period, along with a best-fit trend line. The trend line slopes downward into negative values, suggesting that the 6-1 strategy adds value to simple diversification early in the sample period but is a drag later. However, the sample period is not long and monthly relative returns highly variable.

How does the terminal value of the 6-1 strategy vary with assumed level of switching friction?

sector-ETF-momentum-monthly-outperformance-trend

The next chart plots the terminal value of the 6-1 strategy for switching frictions ranging from 0.00% to 1.00%, along with the fixed terminal values of buying and holding SPY and holding the frictionless EW portfolio. Results indicate that the 6-1 strategy beats SPY at low but achievable levels of switching friction but never beats the EW portfolio benchmark.

How does the alternative 6-1;SMA10 strategy compare?

sector-ETF-momentum-trading-friction-sensitivity

The next chart compares the distributions of sector ETF winners/Cash for the 6-1 and 6-1;SMA10 strategies. The latter is in Cash for 64 of the 199 monthly winners (32%). Defensive sectors tend to become less relevant for the 6-1;SMA-10 strategy than for the 6-1 strategy.

How does applying the 6-1;SMA10 strategy translate into cumulative returns?

sector-ETF-momentum-plus-SMA10-winners

The final chart compares the cumulative values of $100,000 initial investments in the 6-1 strategy, the 6-1;SMA10 strategy and a benchmark EW:SMA10 strategy that holds the EW portfolio (goes to cash) when the S&P 500 Index is above (below) its 10-month simple moving average. An auxiliary test requested by a subscriber substitutes iShares Core US Aggregate Bond (AGG) for T-bills when in “cash” since its initial availability in October 2003 (6-1;SMA10;AGG). As above, calculations derive from the following assumptions:

  • Reallocate/rebalance at the close on the last trading day of each month (assume that values and total six-month past returns for the ETFs, and the S&P 500 Index 10-month simple moving average, can be calculated just before the close).
  • Switching friction for the 6-1 and 6-1;SMA10 strategies is 0.25% of the balance whenever there is a change in holdings, but EW portfolio rebalancing is frictionless for conservative benchmarking.
  • Ignore any tax implications of trading.

The 6-1;SMA10 strategy generally outperforms the 6-1 strategy based on avoidance of most of major downturns. It also mostly provides an edge over EW;SMA10, suggesting that sector ETF momentum mostly adds value to simple diversification during bull markets. However, this value disappears at the end of the sample period. Using AGG rather than T-bills as “cash” provides some boost. However, this boost may derive from AGG capital gain during a sample period with mostly falling interest rates.

The average monthly gross return for the 6-1;SMA10 (6-1) strategy is 0.79% (0.60%), with standard deviation of monthly returns 4.14% (5.37%) and and rough monthly Sharpe ratio 0.19 (0.11). Comparable statistics for EW;SMA10 are 0.70%, 2.57% and 0.27.

Compound annual growth rates are about 4.4%, 7.7% and 8.5% for 6-1, 6-1;SMA10 and EW;SMA10, respectively.

sector-ETF-momentum-plus-SMA10-cumulatives

In summary, evidence from a limited sample period suggests that a simple sector ETF momentum strategy does not add value to an equally weighted benchmark due to increasingly weak relative performance.

For robustness tests and consideration of additional strategy variations, see “Simple Sector ETF Momentum Strategy Robustness/Sensitivity Tests”, “Alternative Sector ETF Momentum Metrics” and “Hedges/Shorting to Exploit Sector ETF Momentum?”.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • Sample size is modest (just 34 independent six-month momentum ranking intervals and about 20 independent 10-month SMA intervals).
  • The selected ETF ranking interval derives from prior academic studies that most often use six-month and 12-month ranking intervals, with one-month holding intervals. This prior research may impound (and therefore transmit) data snooping bias, which is especially pernicious for small samples. Ranking intervals other than six months and holding periods other than one month may produce different results. For the above tests, using longer ranking and holding intervals would effectively reduce the already-small sample size. Optimizing the ranking and holding intervals would elevate data snooping bias.
  • As noted, the boost in performance from the 6-1;SMA10;AGG strategy may derive from falling interest rates over much of the available sample period. This outperformance may not persist when interest rates rise.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a sector ETF momentum strategy?

A sector ETF momentum strategy allocates funds to the sector exchange-traded fund with the highest recent total return, on the premise that recent winners keep outperforming. In the tested version, all funds go each month to the best performer among the nine Select Sector SPDR ETFs (materials, energy, financials, industrials, technology, consumer staples, utilities, health care, consumer discretionary), ranked on past six-month total return.

Does a simple sector ETF momentum strategy beat an equally weighted sector portfolio?

A simple sector ETF momentum strategy did not beat an equally weighted sector portfolio over December 1998 to December 2015. Compound annual growth rates were about 4.4% for 6-month momentum and 5.0% with a skip-month, versus 4.6% for SPY and 6.2% for the equal-weighted portfolio. Even at zero to 1.00% switching friction, the momentum strategy never beat the equal-weighted benchmark.

How is a six-month sector ETF momentum strategy tested and rebalanced?

The six-month sector ETF momentum strategy ranks the nine Select Sector SPDR ETFs by total return over the past six months at each month-end and puts all funds in the top performer. Tests used monthly dividend-adjusted prices from December 1998 to December 2015 and assumed 0.25% friction on each change in holdings, with no taxes. Variations skip the most recent month or move to cash when the S&P 500 Index is below its 10-month simple moving average.

Does adding a 10-month moving average filter improve sector ETF momentum compared with plain momentum?

Adding a 10-month S&P 500 moving average filter improved sector ETF momentum, lifting compound annual growth from about 4.4% to 7.7% by avoiding most major downturns. However, it still trailed an equally weighted portfolio using the same filter, which returned about 8.5% with a rough monthly Sharpe ratio of 0.27 versus 0.19. The momentum edge appeared mainly in bull markets and disappeared at the end of the sample.

What are the limitations of backtesting sector ETF momentum strategies?

The sector ETF momentum backtest rests on a modest sample of just 34 independent six-month ranking intervals and about 20 independent 10-month moving average intervals. The six-month ranking and one-month holding periods come from prior academic studies, which may carry data snooping bias that is especially problematic in small samples. Relative performance versus the equal-weighted portfolio was also highly variable month to month, and the boost from using a bond ETF as cash may reflect falling interest rates.

Trend Following and Momentum guide

More on asset class and etf momentum

  • Developed Country Stock ETF Momentum? Premium "Developed Country Stock Index Momentum?" summarizes a short paper finding that  MSCI developed country stock market indexes may exhibit exploitable momentum since 1970. However, indexes do…
  • Combining Quality and Momentum ETFs Premium A subscriber asked about the performance of a 50-50 combination of a basket of momentum stock exchange-traded funds (ETF) and a basket of quality…
  • Are Equity Momentum ETFs Working? Premium Are stock and sector momentum strategies, as implemented by exchange-traded funds (ETF), attractive? To investigate, we consider nine momentum-oriented equity ETFs, all currently available,…
  • Treasuries ETFs Momentum Strategy Update/Extension Premium Monthly top-1 momentum rotation among seven Treasury ETFs (BIL, SHY, VTIP, IEI, IEF, TIP, TLT) beat the equal-weighted seven-ETF mix on CAGR in 9…
  • Doing Momentum with Style (ETFs) Premium Top 1 style ETF momentum (monthly hold of the best 6-month performer among six iShares Russell value/growth ETFs) had the highest gross terminal value…

All 391 articles in the Trend Following and Momentum guide

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 18, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›