Evidence-based investing research
Value Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
Cash TLT LQD SPY
Momentum Investing Strategy (Strategy Overview)
Allocations for November 2026 (Final)
1st ETF 2nd ETF 3rd ETF

Challenging SMA Effectiveness for Stocks

Steve LeCompte | | Posted in: Technical Trading

Guide Trend Following and Momentum Moving averages

Key Insight

After correcting for one-month look-ahead bias, SMA timing strategies showed no statistically significant improvement over buy-and-hold (Jan 1960–Dec 2011; 10/24-month SMAs on French portfolios; net Sharpe ratios).

 “Pervasiveness and Robustness of SMA Effectiveness for Stocks” summarizes research finding that applying a simple moving average (SMA) trading strategy to U.S. stock portfolios produces strong risk-adjusted performance. This strategy is in stocks (cash) when price is above (below) its SMA. Is this finding valid? In his March 2016 paper entitled “Revisiting the Profitability of Market Timing with Moving Averages”, Valeriy Zakamulin challenges the validity of the research. First, he replicates the finding via simulations that incorporate one-month look-ahead bias (by including the last month of SMA calculation intervals as a strategy return). He then corrects strategy return calculations to eliminate this bias. As in the original research, he bases simulations on the following:

  • Test data are monthly value-weighted returns of three sets of 10 portfolios from the data library of Kenneth French, each set formed by sorting on market capitalization, book-to-market ratio or momentum.
  • Return on cash is the one-month U.S. Treasury bill yield.
  • One-way stocks-cash switching cost is 0.5%.
  • The sample period is January 1960 through December 2011.

Key performance metrics are net Sharpe ratio and four-factor alpha (adjusting for market, size, book-to-market and momentum factors). Using the specified data and assumptions, he finds that:

  • The look-ahead bias in the original research explains the extraordinary effectiveness of SMA strategies in that study.
  • In other words, after removing the bias, SMA strategy performance is at best only marginally better than that of the corresponding buy-and-hold strategy. Any outperformance is not statistically significant. Specifically (see the charts below):
    • Average net Sharpe ratio of a 24-month SMA strategy is lower than that of buy-and-hold.
    • Average net Sharpe ratio of a 10-month SMA strategy is marginally higher than that of buy-and-hold, but the outperformance is not statistically significant.
    • Average alphas of the SMA strategy are negative because the strategy employs momentum.

The following charts, taken from the paper, summarize average net Sharpe ratios (upper chart) and average four-factor alphas) for simulations of a 24-month SMA strategy, a 10-month SMA strategy and a corresponding buy and hold strategy after removing the look-ahead bias in the original research. Results show that the SMA strategy does not convincingly improve risk-adjusted performance. Results suggest that the SMA strategy is an inefficient way to exploit the momentum effect.

unbiased-simulated-SMA-strategy-performance

In summary, evidence does not support belief that SMA-based U.S. stock portfolio timing strategies significantly improve risk-adjusted performance.

Cautions regarding findings include:

  • Findings for the 10-month SMA strategy may incorporate data snooping bias inherited from much prior research on U.S. stocks, making this measurement interval a “conventional” length.
  • The paper does not provide details on the simulation method (but does offer the program code for independent testing).

See also “Net Performance of SMA and Intrinsic Momentum Timing Strategies”, “Long-run Moving Average Horse Race for Timing the U.S. Stock Market” and “Best Moving Average Weighting Scheme for Market Timing?”.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a simple moving average (SMA) timing strategy for stocks?

A simple moving average (SMA) timing strategy holds stocks when price is above its SMA and moves to cash when price is below it. In the research reviewed, SMAs of 10 and 24 months were applied to U.S. stock portfolios, with cash earning the one-month U.S. Treasury bill yield and a 0.5% one-way switching cost.

Do SMA timing strategies beat buy-and-hold for U.S. stocks?

No, SMA timing strategies do not significantly beat buy-and-hold for U.S. stocks once one-month look-ahead bias is removed (January 1960–December 2011). The 24-month SMA had a lower average net Sharpe ratio than buy-and-hold, while the 10-month SMA was marginally higher but not statistically significant. Average four-factor alphas were negative.

How is the performance of SMA timing strategies tested using French portfolios?

SMA timing strategies were tested by simulating them on monthly value-weighted returns of three sets of 10 Kenneth French portfolios sorted on market capitalization, book-to-market ratio and momentum, over January 1960–December 2011. Performance was measured by net Sharpe ratio and four-factor alpha (market, size, book-to-market, momentum), using a 0.5% one-way switching cost and Treasury bill returns for cash. The corrected test removes look-ahead bias that arose from including the last month of the SMA calculation interval as a strategy return.

How does an SMA timing strategy compare to a momentum strategy?

An SMA timing strategy effectively employs momentum, which is why its average four-factor alphas are negative, since the alpha regression already adjusts for the momentum factor. The research suggests the SMA strategy is an inefficient way to exploit the momentum effect, and it does not convincingly improve risk-adjusted performance versus buy-and-hold.

What are the limitations of research on SMA market timing results?

Research on SMA market timing has two cautions: the 10-month SMA findings may carry data snooping bias, because 10 months is a conventional length inherited from much prior research on U.S. stocks. Also, the paper does not detail its simulation method, though it provides program code for independent testing. Results cover U.S. stock portfolios from January 1960 to December 2011.

Trend Following and Momentum guide

More on moving averages

All 391 articles in the Trend Following and Momentum guide

Guru Grades

1,206 predictions by 42 market gurus since 2022: 41% right. Always saying stocks will go higher: 62%.

As of the Nov 18, 2026 close

  1. 1 Ed Yardeni A 71%
  2. Always bullish B 62%
  3. 2 Jim Paulsen B 61%
  4. 3 Sam Stovall B 58%
  5. 4 Adam Turnquist B 58%
  6. 5 Ryan Detrick B 56%

Full leaderboard ›